I think the main issue is these games are both morally gray start to finish and deal with some heavy mature themes. And /v/ on the other hand is mostly filled with manchildren who only think about: jews, indians and cuck fantasies. Mix the two together and of course you will get pointless arguments that go nowhere. Very few people here will be able to appreciate the story. You also have people like this >>718168149 who brag about not playing it but are always in the threads "arguing" as if they did. So all you have is:
>/v/ as a whole who mostly didn't play the game and hate it blindly because of memes and seeing some of the controversial moments on youtube
>a few who played it and liked it
>a few who played it and didn't like it