>>214443671
Analog instruments --> Analog microphone --> digital capture. That digital capture is the most accurate way of doing so. There is no way of arguing against this. Similarly, the digital copy of that is the most accurate capture of that signal.
Whether or not it sounds the best to your taste is a different matter and not way proponents of vinyl argue. Like I said, sometimes remastering for digital isn't as palatable because music is often recorded/mixed to sound best through certain mediums. Like songs created for mono airplay often sound like shit on modern systems. But this is all subjective and has nothing to do with the quality of the medium itself. It's just pic related.