ER has better bosses, map and combat
KCD is more immersive and has more interesting side quests
DD is a better action rpg
RDR2 has a lot more lived in beautiful world
like a dragon has more interesting characters
TES has more freedom

KCD2 sold really well for a game of it's kind despite the issues, being a direct sequel and not breaking into the mainstream
people are dying for a big budget RPG after ER specially after every other franchise shat the bed