I think maybe 5 out of 11 years are okay picks that are believable.
Most years I didn't play any of the nominees, maybe 1.
The popular social media crap usually isn't for me, but I can see why they pick some of them.
GoW winning over RDR2 and MHW is dumb as shit. Iceborne hadn't come out yet, but GoW2018 is probably the most overrated game of all time.
Is there any game more overrated than nu-GoW? I can't think of one atm.