>>543718965
It's... For a lot of reasons. If you were a core /drg/ user you'd have seen my 1927392 full length rants written about HL back when it first released, but you have core user potential so I'll tell you, it's a bad game. Hope this helps!
No, but seriously. It's just horrible in Gameplay and Story and Plot and Writing for literally any given scene and the whole 50 writers gimmick is meaningless when they're all bad, same with the bazillion endings if not one of them is worth something or is just a good story. 
>>543720136
If you also were a core user you'd realize it takes less than that for me to simp on someone, but it'll never be (You) in any case. I like pure souls.