Thread 95895546 - /tg/ [Archived: 1023 hours ago]

Anonymous
6/18/2025, 5:35:38 AM No.95895546
frog (78)
frog (78)
md5: 7cf29749d45fe716afa9e3165569d633🔍
ShadowDark
FeyWild
etc.

What prompted these lazy, idiotic names where they just smash two similar words together and call it a day?
It's as bad as calling a penis a dickcock or a vagina a pussycunt.
It's like a toddler making its first attempts at speech and failing hard.
Replies: >>95895568 >>95895654 >>95895832 >>95895997 >>95896018 >>95896095 >>95896232 >>95896399 >>95896619 >>95903180
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 5:38:02 AM No.95895552
Give retards like OP an inch, and they take a mile.
Replies: >>95895594
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 5:39:47 AM No.95895561
Man, wait until you learn about agglutinative languages. Or German, which has gems such as the word for airplane, flugzeug, which is literally "fly thing."
Replies: >>95895606 >>95895666
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 5:41:18 AM No.95895568
>>95895546 (OP)
dumb frogposter
Replies: >>95895594
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 5:48:59 AM No.95895594
>>95895552
>>95895568
>angry fat chicks
YWNBAW
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 5:50:36 AM No.95895606
>>95895561
German is crazy.
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 5:57:48 AM No.95895654
>>95895546 (OP)
No, its not, because its the nounverb naming convention
>shadowdark
>feywild
You're using a nounnoun convention
>peniscock
When it would obviously be
>dickthrust
Replies: >>95895781 >>95895929
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 5:59:11 AM No.95895666
>>95895561
I mean, the word airplane is just the word air and the word plane slammed together so we're not exactly innocent here either.
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 6:23:47 AM No.95895781
>>95895654
Dark and wild are used as nouns in OP's post and in the games.
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 6:36:48 AM No.95895832
>>95895546 (OP)
Please provide some examples of placenames you think are cool.
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 7:03:19 AM No.95895929
>>95895654
Wild is an adjective too you ESL fuckwit
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 7:24:13 AM No.95895997
>>95895546 (OP)
Kill yourself, frogposting faggot.
Replies: >>95896072
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 7:30:12 AM No.95896014
They're product names. The point is to convey a mood while being memorable and easily searchable. Shit like "Darkbad" performs these functions adequately, making them perfectly functional. Far better than all the indistinguishable variants of "Game that uses [dice]" I've seen.
Replies: >>95896073
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 7:31:20 AM No.95896018
>>95895546 (OP)
Shadowdark is so thoroughly retarded that I'd sooner assume the creator was mocking "grimdark" fiction where the psychogrinders put bloodsouls into the painvortex engines to power their slaughterblasters, or whatever.

A lot of other compound fantasy words are just avoiding needlessly clunky fantasy proper nouns. Feywild rolls off the tongue and reads better than calling it the Fla'Xata-Du-Bruk'Mar, which is supposed to sound special and fantastical, because it's got extra apostrophes and hyphens, like something Tolkien would write if he had brain damage and didn't study linguistics
Replies: >>95896145
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 7:42:22 AM No.95896067
you made me post it
you made me post it
md5: 3d1f98ac03c67bcecfa2cab5ada3bc4c🔍
It's your fault OP, not mine.
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 7:45:35 AM No.95896072
923ee220-ee43-4d03-907b-d4461898d09f_237662651815430
923ee220-ee43-4d03-907b-d4461898d09f_237662651815430
md5: 0bb60d7b87988f48adfc24439835b6ae🔍
>>95895997
>fears frogs
Post hand, tubby.
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 7:46:37 AM No.95896073
>>95896014
It's still supergay.
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 7:50:32 AM No.95896095
>>95895546 (OP)
I'm not fond of them (ShadowDark sounds specially stupid) but they're still better than fully made up weird terms, and also better than messing with real existing words in a way that contradicts their real world meaning (such as making wisdom something separate from intelligence or knowledge in d&d).
Replies: >>95896157
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 8:00:24 AM No.95896145
>>95896018
You could easily call the faerie realm Avalon or something similar. No need for retarded FeyWild style bullshit. It's like the guy that renamed everything was high on his own farts.
Replies: >>95896439
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 8:03:19 AM No.95896157
>>95896095
The places with the faggy names already had good names before some hipster faggot named ButterflyMoth ButtfuckAnalsex decided he was far more clever than any person beforethebeforetime or sincethereafter.

This is why fags don't belong in gaming. They fag it all up.
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 8:17:35 AM No.95896232
Owlbear
Owlbear
md5: c1b91e19cebfd51e4dbc8f744dcb573b🔍
>>95895546 (OP)
Yeah, that's gay, literally no one is RPGs ever just jammed two words together to name something!
Replies: >>95896287
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 8:26:44 AM No.95896287
>>95896232
>In-world colloquialism describing a monster that is quite literally those two things put together
>pointless bland marketing title that conveys no meaningful information
yeah
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 8:59:36 AM No.95896399
>>95895546 (OP)
>ShadowDark
>FeyWild
>as bad as calling a penis a dickcock or a vagina a pussycunt

Maybe it is as bad, maybe it's not, but it's not as bad as the analogy you're trying to make. penis = dick = cock is fine, vagina = pussy = cunt is passably accurate if you allow that people often use vagina where they should be saying vulva, and pussy and cunt both variously refer to vagina and/or vulva.
Shadow and Dark are related but they are not as close to being exact synonyms as you are pretending they are when you say it's like vagina = pussycunt. Fey and Wild are not synonyms (even if you try to stretch fey to mean unpredictable or mad).
Worse is that you've ignored that you haven't completed your comparison. You claimed first word = compound of second and third words. So where are these putative synonymous first words for each of ShadowDark and FeyWild?
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 9:10:37 AM No.95896439
>>95896145
>he doesn't know avalon is also just a mash up of two words
Language-let detected.
Replies: >>95896561 >>95896887
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 9:53:01 AM No.95896561
>>95896439
Avalon is a proper portmanteau and just just near synonyms within the lingua franca of the age said as a compound word.
Given the nature of how real names work, I'd even take Shadownox over shadowfell.
Replies: >>95896887 >>95896887
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 10:17:45 AM No.95896619
>>95895546 (OP)
Trannydorks
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 11:54:37 AM No.95896887
>>95896561
>Avalon is a proper portmanteau
>>95896439
>>he doesn't know avalon is also just a mash up of two words
Is it? I thought avalon was the simple Anglicising of a single foreign word meaning apple/fruit tree. It didn't come into English as two words that were compounded and it wasn't two words in its source language, even if it is expressed as two words in English translation. What two words are both of you claiming it's formed from?

>>95896561
>Shadownox over shadowfell
Why? Fell has lots of meanings. Shadowfell could be
>shadow mountains
>shadow moor
>bloodthirsty/fierce/cruel shadow
>shadow kill(ed)
along with the play on words that shadow/darkness figuratively or literally descended over the region.
Replies: >>95899352
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 7:46:04 PM No.95899352
>>95896887
>Avalaon
Holy Apple portmanteu'd to holapple.

>Shadowfell has lots of meanings.
Could have lots of meaning, has only one. Scarybad.
Shadowmoor would be a great name actually.
Replies: >>95902790
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:54:58 AM No.95902790
>>95899352
>Holy Apple portmanteu'd to holapple
Well tickle me pink and call me a flamingo but I don't see the resemblance. Avalon and holapple are both three syllable words with a and l, but in a happy coincidence that I didn't plan when I wrote that first sentence, so is flamingo, and those similarities don't count for much.

Avalon however I can see is a lot like avallo. In Celtic avallo meant fruit, not just apple. In English too until a few hundred years ago apple meant almost any nut or fruit but not berries. In Latin, pomus meant any fruit, including berries, or nut, or the tree they grew on.

Geoffrey of Monmouth was the first to mention Avalon. He was writing 900 years ago when apple/avallo/pomus meant almost any fruit or nut not just what we today call apples. He first called the place Avallo and in a later book he called it Insula Pomorum. Insula means island and pomorum is the genitive plural of pomum. In Modern English it would be Island of Fruit/Apples.

Thank you for taking my question seriously. Do you know of anything more convincing than what you have said? The similarity between Avallo/avalon, which is not folk etymology but serious etymological research, is readily apparent but avalon/holapple is missing a whole lot of steps to say one morphed from the other. It doesn't look to me that Avalon is a portmanteau or any compound noun, and that the people making fun of the anon for not knowing Avalon is a mashup of two words might in fact have egg on their own faces for saying it is.
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 4:29:23 AM No.95902926
Dogshit grifter game
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 5:26:13 AM No.95903180
>>95895546 (OP)
"Feywild" came about when WotC wanted a trademarkable name for the "realm of fairies" during 4e. This is also when the "Plane of Shadow" was renamed to the "Shadowfell." As these areas had Underdark equivalents in 4e, they coined the terms "Feydark" and "Shadowdark" for the associate Underdarks.