When does a magical realm becomes too magical ?

>>95930775 (OP)
What the fuck is wrong with you.

>>95930775 (OP)
Work backwards and back away from yours until you get some friends. That'll tell you the point at which people stop finding your retarded faggotry unbearable.

>>95930775 (OP)
When you're reviewing your own notes from few weeks ago and realize you're low key worried about your past self that wrote them.

>>95930962
Already tried and didn't work
My friends just went head in and added their own magical twists to it

>>95930775 (OP)
When it has things I don't like

>>95930775 (OP)
The way that BG3 does that shit. If a DM did that in a regular sit down D&D game all the players would leave.

>>95930775 (OP)
When the animals talk

>>95931257
Are they enjoying themselves? If so, what's the problem?

>>95932457
This is a good danger zone. When the animals can talk and the thought, “so they can give consent” enters your head.

>>95932498
>Are they enjoying themselves?
Yes

>If so, what's the problem?
Me possibly going to far the ruing it

>>95930775 (OP)
What game?

>>95933365
No game is necessary.
/tg/ isn't just for games.

>>95930775 (OP)
>people still utena posting
good, good. more bdsm magical girls please

>>95933489
Imagine outing youself as a nogames this hard.

>>95930775 (OP)
Traditional games?

>>95930775 (OP)
For aesthetics and themes (pic related), you can go as far out as you want, and you can even stuff your fetishes into your work (see H.R. Geiger). I'd argue it makes it that much more unique and authentic.
The issue is when you directly involve your players in your fetish. If the reason you're describing a vore scene to them or making them piss into a bridge troll's mouth is to just get your rocks off, don't fucking do it

>>95930775 (OP)
Extreme /d/ stuff that's possible and yet victim (since that ain't partnership anyway) remains alive and mostly intact

>>95930775 (OP)
Let me explain it like this; Nobody will complain about vanilla. Everyone likes vanilla. You can bring a scoop of vanilla to a table and every person there will eat it. You can also mix a scoop of vanilla with chocolate or striacatella. Not as many people want it but it's still nice and reasonable.

Now if you get a scoop of mint, licorice, tutty fruity and Woodruff you want a very niche audience or else it's gonna be weird.

Good luck mixing in a scoop of cream cheese and mayonnaise tho. It's not gonna fly.

>>95933365
Any game

>>95930775 (OP)
When we can't goon to it (anything outisde of the most vanilla straight or sapphic sex).

>>95935840
Snakes and ladders?

>>95936490
Snakes: The laddering 5th edition.

>>95933522
I was surprised how fun of a read the manga was.
Kind of reminded me of Kill la Kill, you kind of forgot about the half naked girls.

>>95935814
your point ?

>>95936490
>>95936520
Slop, but you can absolutely make a sexy version

>>95933365
Pathfinder 2e

>>95930775 (OP)
When the players get physically uncomfortable. "You get it on with the fat dragon lady" is funny and has implications of magical realm but opens the party to coming up with stuff. "You fuck the fat dragon lady" is more straightforward, still ok but like don't linger on it. "The fat dragon lady stuffs her mouth with loads of food while you stick your body in her cloaca and reenact your birth when she cums" is bad.

>>95936592
Make sure your magical realm isn't cream cheese.

>>95930775 (OP)
When you cum

>>95936959
Please clarify by defining fat and dragon. If it's a FAT (curvy) DRAGON (human with a few vaguely draconic features), you get a lot more leeway before things get uncomfortable.

>>95948195
Uh, still think "The fat dragon lady stuffs her mouth with loads of food while you stick your body in her cloaca and reenact your birth when she cums" is going to look bad there...

>>95948195
Counterpoint: having a DRAGON (human with a few vaguely draconic features) in a setting with mostly DRAGONS (dragon) is magical realmy. Compare this to DRAGON (humanoid dragon with boobs), which is more acceptable if DRAGONS (dragon) exist in the setting. Counter example, banging a DRAGON (dragon in a setting where DRAGONS (human with a few vaguely draconic features) exist would be taken as magical realmy and feral adjacent.

>>95930775 (OP)
When
a) You force your fetish upon players who, despite being adults and expecting some degree of adult situations, never signed up for it
b) Your session devolves into ERPing for hours despite your game not being about erotica

>>95948308
I'll be real, scaly dragons with tits is a way bigger red flag for me. Because the only reason to give scaly dragons tits is because you want to fuck them. At least humanoid with dragon features have an excuse of fitting in with non-dragon society better.

>>95933365
The game you just lost

>>95948308
Counter-counterpoint: all three levels of DRAGON can be the result of crossbreeding with humans across various generations, leading to a casta system but with FAT DRAGON WIVES, FAT COW WIVES, FAT DOG WIVES etc.

This is too much magical realm

>>95930775 (OP)
>When does a magical realm becomes too magical ?
When the group doesn't enjoy it

>>95948195
Eh, a fat "dragon" that just happens to look like woman with some vaguely draconic features seems more obviously magical realm than an actual fat dragon. The latter could probably be played off as a joke, while the former is obvious intended as fapbait.

>>95930775 (OP)
When you're obviously violating the interests and comfort of your players. If the GM is doing weird shit that people didn't sign on for, then they didn't set good expectations, which makes them a shit GM. You can do whatever the fuck you want, as long as everyone was on board for it up front. Communication is the most important part of any social gaming.

>>95948920
Being 5'6" is not a "small" character. That's not how that works. But goliaths are generally still much more robustly built than tieflings.

Does anyone here remember that greentext about a tied up fairy that some people used as a magic charm? That was some magic realm shit

>>95930775 (OP)
When it clearly just the writer's barely disguised fetishes and them just ripping off other stories

>>95930779
What's so bad about it?

>>95930775 (OP)
Only when I, THE HIGH GRAND WIZARD OF MAGICAL REALMS, deem it as such

>>95930775 (OP)
When you get an erection, and your players look at you with disgust and anger

>>95930775 (OP)
When everyone can use it

>>95959592
All Hail the Gra-wait is this the KKK again?