Good setting with iffy systems - /tg/ (#95968459) [Archived: 1014 hours ago]

Anonymous
6/28/2025, 4:45:09 AM No.95968459
1751052116981
1751052116981
md5: 3047bbe32f4bdfb356a4b7e8208b6e19🔍
Do you have any settings that you like that have systems that you dislike? For me, it's Dark Sun. I really like the dying earth, mad max/dune feel, the intrigue, and the interplay between psionics and magic, and the stark beauty of Athas itself. I like the takes on the races and cultures, and the detail that went into the tablelands.

I'm not the biggest fan of DnD however. While the cosmology per planescape is neat, I find classes to be restrictive, even with multiclassing, and the large focus on combat mechanics and the comparative lack of social mechanics leaves a lot to be desired, comparatively speaking. I also feel the d20 is a poor choice for a universal die given the flat 5% chance per side. Right now I'm hoping to try a different system, though I'm still unsure if I want GURPS or something that is still universal but less complex like BRP.
Replies: >>95968465 >>95968582 >>95969235 >>95974358
Anonymous
6/28/2025, 4:46:10 AM No.95968465
>>95968459 (OP)
refluffed runequest/mythras fits it very well
Replies: >>95968499
Anonymous
6/28/2025, 4:51:57 AM No.95968499
>>95968465
Yeah, I'm definitely learning towards mithras, I typically prefer building a setting out of the box with GURPS, conversion seems much more of a pain. Main kink is the magic system, Psionics is easy enough to emulate but I want to get the defiler/preserver magic right. I'm not as familiar with Runequest, beyond playing King of Dragon Pass.

Also I fucking love there being a two minute wait time to post.
Anonymous
6/28/2025, 4:55:14 AM No.95968515
Maybe Barbarians of Lemuria or Savage Worlds could work
Anonymous
6/28/2025, 5:08:04 AM No.95968582
>>95968459 (OP)
I also really like the Dark Sun setting but never liked the rules for DnD. Always thought about using some generic rules and use the Dark Sun setting, or just make/adapt my own rules for my own game, but that's never gonna happen.
Anonymous
6/28/2025, 6:20:07 AM No.95968906
Vampire the Masquerade
Vampire the Masquerade
md5: 644643cd51acff5e1795315d4fdcdcaf🔍
Anonymous
6/28/2025, 7:31:40 AM No.95969235
>>95968459 (OP)
Dark Sun and Star Wars would be perfect for Neverwinter Nights 3
Replies: >>95969311
Anonymous
6/28/2025, 7:39:23 AM No.95969271
When it comes to tabletop games, I don't have any examples of liking setting and disliking system; I'll only play what I make, and I only make what I like.

>cosmology
Ah, it's a Literary Lord thread.
Anonymous
6/28/2025, 7:48:22 AM No.95969311
>>95969235
Neverwinter Nights 3 isn't a tabletop game
Anonymous
6/28/2025, 8:46:10 AM No.95969555
>subject header: "good"
>body: "you like", "you dislike"
Anonymous
6/29/2025, 2:04:28 AM No.95974358
>>95968459 (OP)
I've read people recommending Savage Worlds for Dark Sun but I haven't used it myself yet. I'm pretty inexperienced in the system and only have cursory knowledge of Dark sun so idk if I should still just take some fanmade conversion and still run it