Mobile Suit Gundam: The Witch from Mercury (and others) - /u/ (#4409060) [Archived: 963 hours ago]

Anonymous
4/25/2025, 10:04:30 PM No.4409060
bafkreibw7rm4v3gdhcszjdowalw4h7iyblivfsyd5ep4cz7ms2pncc72de
I didn't realize how much I'd miss you girls.

Previous thread: >>4405746

Extra materials:

>Cradle Planet
https://en.gundam.info/about-gundam/series-pages/witch/music/novel/

>Vanadis Heart Manga
https://www.zeonic-republic.net/?s=VANADIS+HEART

>Special Drama CD - Episode.01: What Miorine Wants
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SAh5ScjxH5g
>Drama CDs part 1-2
https://mega.nz/folder/YpMR2IAC#NyjE6N__hG-Cit7J9yWtuQ

>Suletta & Miorine Japan Tour
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uHUmRo3MzCE
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1P5B9vgi2EUey86UWRPQ7EJr40n40j590p-GiDFJo-ZE/htmlview#

>Light Novel
https://mega.nz/folder/V3chxQxD#-ug69uN5kQw9elD85iq3aA

>Doujinshi folder
https://mega.nz/folder/2EBBEYia#6CTRFMPoZJ8LffBm-TUxdg
>Doujin Anon's ko-fi
https://ko-fi.com/thatanon

>All About Mercury ZIP
https://mega.nz/file/REdEmYJC#USI-CHp48bDKvqnNdZuaI7oWKLw7zTEHnHejXRI1ia0
>Accompanying TL Notes
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1RPIKat-pn2KzCvy6PZzZHtByfigJApNd/view

>Misc Translations (including the School Assembly Drama CD)
https://roguemaki.tumblr.com/gwitch
>Translated MajoRaji snippets:
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLn9KxueQgEUcvoaMHaJdcMgsfhJBJvygQ
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLueB-DN62sJtDMY6xSpbF7Vs6p1eyc7Ib

>SuleMio comics translated and typeset on /u/
https://mega.nz/folder/B7sBQR6a#C_H3QF5Tvj4U8FdkgbqiuA

>Asticassia School Festival BD rips
https://mega.nz/folder/QvkFHADZ#abreWiPFwRTmtEQfHJWWbQ
>School Festival Drama CD (parent directory contains WfM-related scans, including non-/u/ doujins)
https://mega.nz/folder/wLcRxD6a#q7L818Ixfxn6terqdTwF0Q/folder/oeUGUB7J
Replies: >>4409119
Anonymous
4/25/2025, 10:12:59 PM No.4409075
bafkreid6ehmjkxj2xis45n3zslrg2wx37wbnkf2qevofxnv73top6wfnpm
Also, the second episode of GCucks was maybe the most annoyed I've ever been at 30 minutes of animation. This is what happens when no one can tell the boss "No".

I hope no one minds the continuing SuleMio OPs, but I'm gonna need something a little stronger from Machu/Nyaan before they make the cut.
Replies: >>4409083 >>4409131
Anonymous
4/25/2025, 10:21:17 PM No.4409083
>>4409075
What was wrong with episode 2
Replies: >>4409096
Anonymous
4/25/2025, 10:32:31 PM No.4409096
>>4409083
It ruined the series' early momentum by wasting an episode on Anno's OYW fanfic that could have been a five minute flashback and two cryptic Challia Bull dialogues.

One of the things I like about this franchise is how generally forward-looking it is. Like okay, you need a Char clone, but you're supposed to do something new with them. Before this, Char and Amuro haven't made substantial appearances in any anime after Char's Counterattack, aside from productions that involved Yaz. Anno recycling old 0079 storyboards but replacing Amuro with Char reeks of nostalgia.
Replies: >>4409131 >>4409789 >>4409876
Anonymous
4/25/2025, 10:59:45 PM No.4409119
>>4409060 (OP)
Did we get any date for the modern? School au manga yet?
Anonymous
4/25/2025, 11:13:35 PM No.4409131
20250425_144315
20250425_144315
md5: 40baa244562c15b9ff12bd494f6705c2๐Ÿ”
I hope the TL anons and Djsis are still here.

After months of hiatus, Vanadis manga and the novelization are back, like /u/. Will this luck streak include Youth Frontier?

>>4409075
>>4409096
>the second episode of GCucks was maybe the most annoyed I've ever been at 30 minutes of animation.
>It ruined the series' early momentum by wasting an episode on Anno's OYW fanfic
Maybe I wasn't affected because I watched the movie and knew what was going to happen in the first 3 episodes, but I absolutely agree with you. The movie started with the Char Aznable/Challia Bull fanfic before introducing Machu and her story. At least nobody is sperging about episode 3. Btw, WfM episode 15 exists... kek.

>I hope no one minds the continuing SuleMio OPs
Who would mind?
Replies: >>4409197 >>4410113
Anonymous
4/25/2025, 11:17:09 PM No.4409135
20250425_151557
20250425_151557
md5: 66dbd0b18880c06d294bc5fff262838c๐Ÿ”
Anyway, this artist @BeSong_good has been drawing some good Sulemio fanart.
Replies: >>4409136
Anonymous
4/25/2025, 11:17:52 PM No.4409136
20250425_151602
20250425_151602
md5: f8f35fc75c9a938b7c4c23e5c419f140๐Ÿ”
>>4409135
Anonymous
4/25/2025, 11:18:24 PM No.4409137
20250425_151612
20250425_151612
md5: 16c7d364f3a4b87b3c31f331096c49c9๐Ÿ”
Replies: >>4409788
Anonymous
4/25/2025, 11:19:17 PM No.4409138
20250425_144307
20250425_144307
md5: 36951470b384205ebd6f13a28ca379d7๐Ÿ”
Anonymous
4/25/2025, 11:28:20 PM No.4409142
bafkreia2mkxm6edhh2qjxujxj7olrkplccouqxeqoqxzvwncca2pwpq5wa
GQucks is gonna end with a scene of CCA-era Char zoning out, looking at his glass of whiskey, and saying to himself, "that's what things would be like if I had stolen the RX78"

Also why did the mods steal the last thread?
Replies: >>4409144
Anonymous
4/25/2025, 11:31:22 PM No.4409144
20250425_153027
20250425_153027
md5: 4dacbcc05ab7f9e56ac929456fdccc23๐Ÿ”
>>4409142
>Also why did the mods steal the last thread?
They like Sulemio.
Anonymous
4/25/2025, 11:36:06 PM No.4409148
Annoโ€™s 0079 famfic should have been a prologue ONA like they did with WfM prologue. Would allow them to release the whole thing that was in the movie rather than having to cut shit to fit TV time limits
Would also mean once the show starts, the story isnโ€™t interrupted by episode 2 being a flashback
Replies: >>4409197
Anonymous
4/26/2025, 12:08:00 AM No.4409156
Seishun Frontier doko
Seishun Frontier doko
md5: 90af5b146824dbd11650ca21b317ae9b๐Ÿ”
@sun_4x3 has more activity on bluesky, their profile is @sun4x3.bsky.social

Also, Takashi Ohashi worked on Gcucks OP, he did the sequence of Machu running with the Gundam and the last one with everyone running.
Replies: >>4409712
Anonymous
4/26/2025, 12:48:09 AM No.4409197
>>4409148
>>4409131
Nah let's be real this shit could go Gundam Sneed-level sideways and they could just rely on Char pandering to carry it to the end. They use that motherfucker to sell sardines.
One of the first three episodes being entirely devoted to Gundam 78 The Legend of Char's Gold is a tactical choice. Yes it could've been a prequel episode outside of the traditional story order, but it wasn't.
Replies: >>4409250
Anonymous
4/26/2025, 2:22:34 AM No.4409250
>>4409197
>They use that motherfucker to sell sardines.
The Char vibrator.

I don't have issues with the OYW episode, I only think Gcucks should've started with it (like the movie), or at least introduced it as a some sort of flashback.
Replies: >>4409749 >>4409751
Anonymous
4/26/2025, 3:28:05 PM No.4409553
Machu doesn't know who Char was, so I guess that's that for any theories of her being Haman.
Anonymous
4/26/2025, 9:46:02 PM No.4409712
>>4409156
>good sulemio artists' new home is bluesky now
Do they hate twitter or something?
Replies: >>4409788
Anonymous
4/26/2025, 10:57:32 PM No.4409749
102327157_p1
102327157_p1
md5: c23522b98b5ac0c75be755a5ada3b373๐Ÿ”
>>4409250
>I only think Gcucks should've started with it
You can't really do a tv show about the adventures of a girl named Machu and dedicate your first episode to the adventures of a beloved legacy character.

That's the main problem with ep 2. It isn't necessary and it doesn't fit anywhere within the structure of the series. It's pure self-indulgence. This is exactly the kind of darling a writer is supposed to kill.
Replies: >>4409751 >>4409788
Anonymous
4/26/2025, 11:09:45 PM No.4409751
>>4409250
>>4409749
It could have been an episode 0 aired before the series, exactly like what G-Witch did.
Replies: >>4409788 >>4410179
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 12:34:56 AM No.4409788
20250426_161452
20250426_161452
md5: d79ad4cd9560ca992ab3bbfd41e4fbfd๐Ÿ”
>>4409137

>>4409712
Nah, they're still posting on twitter. I think it's because allegedly X feeds its AI with the art posted there, it was a huge deal in November. Iirc they said something about it back then, "polluting Musk's AI".

>>4409749
>dedicate your first episode to the adventures of a beloved legacy character
Yeah, you got me there, but in my opinion the real problem with episode 2 is how it interrupts Machu's story. That's why I agree with >>4409751 episode 2 should've episode 0, for some worldbuilding.
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 12:36:24 AM No.4409789
>>4409096
Yeah I'm just so tired of the Char wankery. I get it, he was an interesting character and a good rival...but the franchise as a whole regularly going yo remember Char he's pretty cool huh both via expies and actual recycling is just exhausting.
Replies: >>4410179
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 12:39:19 AM No.4409791
20250426_163836
20250426_163836
md5: aed2a5696ab28e9de5f83e31dd665f13๐Ÿ”
Replies: >>4409792 >>4409883
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 12:39:56 AM No.4409792
20250426_163835
20250426_163835
md5: f9c8faf5831e9bf98d87c539575e7833๐Ÿ”
>>4409791
Replies: >>4409793
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 12:40:27 AM No.4409793
20250426_163839
20250426_163839
md5: 850726bbdf875c83bc90559d96e7393d๐Ÿ”
>>4409792
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 12:43:18 AM No.4409794
20250426_164229
20250426_164229
md5: 7d7b2fb3c0c2b1ad3840188af9990774๐Ÿ”
Replies: >>4409886
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 12:43:51 AM No.4409795
20250426_164217
20250426_164217
md5: 6d37c874e6b31c77c1b14f1c67c57b74๐Ÿ”
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 12:44:22 AM No.4409797
20250426_164203
20250426_164203
md5: ada4a36e69309662280ade291752e849๐Ÿ”
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 12:44:54 AM No.4409798
20250426_164244
20250426_164244
md5: 80ea8bf97d83a1b292e7327e20ac5e3a๐Ÿ”
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 12:46:31 AM No.4409799
20250426_164155
20250426_164155
md5: 8c45be6501024eab62b4161809d1220e๐Ÿ”
@dh_lbg on twitter.
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 12:47:39 AM No.4409801
20250426_164705
20250426_164705
md5: c86504f9d44e4399a0ee0ea6ca3b37bf๐Ÿ”
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 1:01:20 AM No.4409805
null
md5: null๐Ÿ”
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 3:46:59 AM No.4409862
null
md5: null๐Ÿ”
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 4:51:41 AM No.4409876
>>4409096
While i did not dislike it, i feel it should have been an Episode 0 like what WfM did
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 5:34:30 AM No.4409883
>>4409791
>covered in scars
>but no permet scars
:(
Replies: >>4409965
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 6:03:45 AM No.4409886
>>4409794
Sis reuploading is prohibited
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 8:38:35 AM No.4409965
>>4409883
There should be model sheet that shows the permet scars in full body
Replies: >>4409980
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 9:20:55 AM No.4409980
null
md5: null๐Ÿ”
>>4409965
The closest thing we got is ED2.
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 9:26:17 AM No.4409982
null
md5: null๐Ÿ”
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 9:26:48 AM No.4409983
null
md5: null๐Ÿ”
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 9:27:19 AM No.4409984
null
md5: null๐Ÿ”
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 9:30:47 AM No.4409985
null
md5: null๐Ÿ”
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 9:35:31 AM No.4409986
null
md5: null๐Ÿ”
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 8:49:13 PM No.4410113
>>4409131
Other TL-anon here, I love these girls too much to leave them. I like to think the other two are still around here and there, just busy.
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 11:09:42 PM No.4410179
null
md5: null๐Ÿ”
>>4409751
I assume there was some contractual reason it couldn't be a web-only episode 0, since it worked so well for GWitch.

>>4409789
I think the Char clones generally work pretty well. Most of Tomino's are basically joke characters (I smile a little every time I remember F91's Iron Cuck). 00's Graham was funny but kind of inessential, AGE's Zeheart maybe more conventional but also one of the few parts of that show that worked.

IBO's McGillis was a really good reworking of Char and his relationship with Garma, as you'd expect from the Fujo Gundam. Prospera's just great, and pretty far from the archetype. Notably the last two weren't even rivals to the hero.

I think Zechs from Wing is the only outright terrible Char clone. He tries to hit all the hits of the original's character arc, only in ~50 episodes and maybe a year's time in-universe, which ends up silly.
Replies: >>4410187
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 11:25:16 PM No.4410187
>>4410179
I think my main issue with Char clones as a concept is they're usually established early on and it's very easy to tell what role they'll be playing because of it. It takes away some narrative ambiguity when you can tell at a glance ah so this character is gonna be the rival ace type. Not that Gundam has especially ambiguous characterization, but I value characters like Cina who have their ups and downs across the narrative and have obviously been through the wringer way more than the unflappable, charismatic ace of nearly unparalleled skill pidgeonhole.

And then there's like Full Frontal who kind of literally only exists to evoke Char in the lamest ways possible. CCA ending like it did was nearly perfect Tomino, we don't need a literal clone situation to drum up hype. I don't think Tomino even worked on Unicorn but I'm still blaming him. I do agree the recent trend of having them be unexpected/reluctant allies to the protagonists has been neat though.
Replies: >>4410188 >>4410191
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 11:26:19 PM No.4410188
>>4410187
Whoops I meant Cima and not Cina obviously. Man I love Cima so much.
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 11:34:05 PM No.4410189
null
md5: null๐Ÿ”
Disappointed with the novel because the illustration didn't feature wetdog Miorine having handsex with Suletta, but I'm glad the "Guel lost intentionally" argument is finally dead.
Replies: >>4410190 >>4410311
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 11:34:57 PM No.4410190
>>4410189
Are the novels finally done?
Replies: >>4410192
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 11:39:37 PM No.4410191
>>4410187
>I don't think Tomino even worked on Unicorn but I'm still blaming him

He didn't and allegedly he hated all the rehash in it
Anonymous
4/27/2025, 11:42:32 PM No.4410192
null
md5: null๐Ÿ”
>>4410190
No, read the thread. This month's GundamAce issue has episode 22. The TL is on MEGA.
Replies: >>4410311
Anonymous
4/28/2025, 1:07:49 AM No.4410224
is the spin-off manga STILL not out?

did new information come out at least?
Anonymous
4/28/2025, 6:54:58 AM No.4410293
null
md5: null๐Ÿ”
Anonymous
4/28/2025, 6:55:29 AM No.4410294
null
md5: null๐Ÿ”
Anonymous
4/28/2025, 7:17:26 AM No.4410311
>>4410189
You mean they only showed this? >>4410192 or are there more pics from that chapter?