Thread 712604304

>Reddit is based
Apologize

SS is infinitely better than the Switch open-turds

>>712604304 (OP)
>Top 3 are the most boring and predictable choices ever
It's reddit indeed

>>712604304 (OP)
I think majoras mask is better than oot

>>712604304 (OP)
Replace Wind Waker and BOTW, then move Twilight Princess down to 3rd and i'd agree

>>712604304 (OP)
Why do normies hate BOTW now?

>>712604304 (OP)
>old good, new bad
reddit has fallen

>>712604304 (OP)
>WW is second last
'fraid not, chief.

Tears of the kingdom might be the best and most impressive game of the last 15 years

>>712604304 (OP)
Pretty good list, I only have minor disagreements.

>>712604480
Everyone shat on TP when it released. I'm glad history has vindicated it

>Twilight Princess above Majora's Mask

Nuke em.

>>712607370
the gameplay and camera improvements from the HD version are great, it just sucks that it added way too much fucking bloom. i have found that the best way to enjoy the game now is emulating the hd version on cemu with a graphics patch that tones down the bloom heavily. the true patrician experience.

Is there a more retard-bait game than Twilight Princess
>dude... what if Zelda was LotR... ebin...
It's easily the worst 3D Zelda by a longshot, at least Wind Waker and Skyward Sword don't go out of their way to inconvenience you for the sake of 'realism'.

>>712604480
>i....must....be....contrarian
kys. they're predictable because they're true.

>>712604304 (OP)
How so? Wind Waker isn't number 1.

>>712607153
you're not wrong

>>712604304 (OP)
>Bloom princess #2
Crazy what rule34 can do the the popularity of a game

Move SS and WW above BotW and Totk and you got a decent list

OoT
TP
Skyward sword
Majora
Breath
Windwaker
Tears

>>712604304 (OP)
>BEHOLD the second best 3D Zelda game apparently

>>712607551
>at least Wind Waker and Skyward Sword don't go out of their way to inconvenience you for the sake of 'realism'.
like when the KoRL wouldnt let you sail anywhere until you beat 3 dungeons? Or made you do forsaken fortress AGAIN? or made you pay an NPC to continue playing the game?

Characters make or break these games and the characters of the open world games are abysmal. The voice acting was such a misstep and the procedurally generated faces are just nothing

reddit wants an OOT remake in the style of BOTW

>>712607885
Name 10 characters from OOT. Characters have never made these games you stupid faggot.

>>712607927
Zelda,
Link,
Saria,
Ruto,
Malon,
Malon's Dad,
Mido,
Ganondorf,
Impa,
Darunia

>>712607907
We already established that they're based

>>712607885
What the actual fuck are you talking about?
You can probably count the number of compelling characters across all the games in the OP pic on one hand - you probably won't even need that many fingers either.
Ironically BotW was actually an IMPROVEMENT in this regard since a lot of people seem to be fond of characters like Urbosa, Sidon, Mipha, Paya and the new Zelda.
Meanwhile the old games have uh... Tingle? Mido? People like Mido right?

>>712607760
>you got ANOTHER clawshot!
Gotta admit it's at least a viable solution to the "you will only use this item once" dilemma.

>>712607927
saria
malon
impa
ganon
rupee game shop owner
guard you give the pikachu mask to
mido
dog lady
ruto
nabooru

>>712608015
>lets ruin a game by BTOWing it

>>712608113
Yes. Let's all start Wildin'.

>>712604304 (OP)
everyone knows the series has only gotten progressively worse with only the first few actually being good

>>712604404
And wind waker too for that matter.

>>712608469
you could never do it in a way that would make everyone happy

>>712607551
>It's easily the worst 3D Zelda by a longshot
I'd say it's the worst by a hookshot.

>>712604304 (OP)
>bothering making rankings instead of playing them.

You're trying to convince people that you like them?

>Zelda fan excited to play it for the first time.

>>712604304 (OP)
>OoT

the nostalgia is strong.

>>712608079
None of the characters you listed are compelling. People just jerk off to them. The mask salesman contains more character then all of the above combined

twilight princess is too high up, otherwise not too bad

I do respect putting SHIT waker at th ebottom alongside SS instead of felating it like most zelda fandoms

Replayed TP again, currently on Arbitier's Grounds. This dungeon is very good, i'd say it's great. If the remaining dungeons are better than this i might have to revise my rankings for this game and put it up around Resident Evil 4 level. I can't imagine having 5 consecutive dungeons in a row on this quality honestly

>>712607493
>TP HD
>added too much fucking bloom

what? are you getting it confused with WW? TP HD removed some of the bloom people complained about with the original

>>712609605
arbiter's grounds is the best dungeon in the game, one of the best in the series. I don't think the ones after come to its level but snowpeak ruins is close

>>712609605
I cant speak for Temple in the sky itself but the dragon boss fight is great. Feels very monster hunter-esque. Albeit its piss easy

>>712608006
>>712608102
>having to list characters who literally have 2 minutes of screentime
kys

>>712604304 (OP)
>... on shit and retarded opinions
FTFY

>>712607907
I want a Wind Waker remake in the style of BOTW.

>>712609727
>th-those dont count!!!!
sasuga

>>712604304 (OP)
Wind waker is better than majora

reddit is beyond retarded at this point

>>712609769
No one watches a 2 hour long film and says the guy with 1 scene was so good he made the movie enjoyable. Yet you stand here and say these characters made this game. If we met in real life I would actually beat the shit out of you.

>>712609605
Snowpeak > Arbiter's Grounds > Lakebed > Temple of Time > Hyrule Castle > City in the Sky > Palace of Twilight > Mid > The Rest

>>712609885
>I get violently angry because people remember characters from an n64 game

If only people could stop pretending that the 64 games are good these days. Even on my own list OoT is probably overrated.

BotW
TotK
WW
OoT
SS
TP
MM

>>712610521
They're not amazing but there's no world in which WW, SS, or TP are better. Simple truth is that most 3D zeldas are mid.

Twilight Princess needs a proper remake, i hate open world shit but this game's world is so empty that it needs one. If they added the beta content, like a larger forest, castle town etc and more side quests, difficulty options it would be potentially better than Majora's Mask or ALTTP

>>712605587
When it comes to Zelda that's true. Also how is OOT 3D old good? It's the fucking remake.

>>712610748
Do you seriously think the remasters would be separate options from the originals on a vote like this?

>>712604304 (OP)
OoT/MM>TP>WW>BotW>TotShit>SS

>>712610637
>Twilight Princess needs a proper remake
There's nothing that you could to to improve TP via a remake that couldn't also be done in a potential OoT remake that would be vastly better than it in every way. TP is a fundamentally weak game, its whole structure is bad and overly restrictive, with no concession to player freedom despite having a decent sized world, so it's just a slog and would have to be redesigned from the ground up to basically be good. OoT, OTOH, is already the best and would only be improved that much more greatly by adding "beta content, like a larger forest, castle town etc and more side quests, difficulty options", which could all be incorporated into its world better.

>>712604304 (OP)
totk overrated

>>712604304 (OP)
>tears of the shitdom anything above dead last
No.

>>712612651
It definitely shouldn't be above Wind Waker, but Skyward Sword has earned its place in the bottom rung.