Do these games really deserve to be some of the highest rated games ever?

the originals, maybe
the remakes, no

the remakes, absolutely
the originals, no

They're pretty fun for sports games. The arcade nature of the gameplay is nice.

>>712922139
Oh here we fucking go
What's wrong with 1+2

>>712922139
>>712922213
I'm so confused
About what to do
Sometimes I want to throw it all away

>>712922112 (OP)
marathoned thps1-4 and thug1-2 a few months ago. yup, they are that good. building up sick combos never gets old.

They pretty much nailed arcade-y skateboarding while also having interesting variety like time attack competition levels, collectables and platforming.
Don't really see what more you can fundamentally add to them aside from more moves like manuals and reverts were added in the later ones. They basically started as near perfectly designed games.
I'd even argue the first game without manuals feels more like real skating cause you're limited by what things you can trick off of and can't just chain insane infinite combos everywhere. But adding in manuals and reverts gives it a different arcade power fantasy feel. They're both great.

>>712922308
ugly UE5 game with bloated resource requirements and missing content

>>712922324
It's important to practice good hygiene if you want to run with my team.

Depends when you rate it. If it's rated now, then no. But if at the time, sure why not.

tony hawk 2-3 are perfect games
like tetris

>>712922615
Oh yeah, then what character is Cleveland Z?

how do I stop bailing every 5 seconds

>>712922531
Its ue4. And runs on a original switch

>>712922531
>>712922139
this level of contrarianism is just gay
not only it preserved the soul of the originals but improved upon it
great remasters/remakes like thps1+2, aoe2, starcraft, crash trilogy, should be praised

>>712922112 (OP)
yes, multiple entries easily in the top 10 3D platformers

>>712922532
Based, how low can you go?
Want dubs, check the number though