Anonymous
6/19/2025, 1:02:21 AM No.713037242
Now that the dust has settled.... Was it actually a decent game or is it just nostalgia?
Replies:
Thread 713037242 - /v/ [Archived: 972 hours ago]
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 1:03:59 AM No.713037358
>>713037242 (OP)
The Sonic/Shadow levels and the Chao Garden were the major redeeming factors, and the cutscenes are neat
Everything else was filler
The Sonic/Shadow levels and the Chao Garden were the major redeeming factors, and the cutscenes are neat
Everything else was filler
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 1:15:23 AM No.713038191
>>713037242 (OP)
It's still a very good game. I'm not the biggest fan of the Chao Garden as it is though, if it was like twice as fast for increasing levels and didn't have a limited inventory for animals I'd probably be a bigger fan of it.
It's still a very good game. I'm not the biggest fan of the Chao Garden as it is though, if it was like twice as fast for increasing levels and didn't have a limited inventory for animals I'd probably be a bigger fan of it.
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 1:22:11 AM No.713038665
>>713037242 (OP)
People will tell you the mech and emerald searching stages suck but the truth is that people misunderstand them. They become infinitely more fun when you start going for A ranks and begin to understand the mechanics behind the points system
People will tell you the mech and emerald searching stages suck but the truth is that people misunderstand them. They become infinitely more fun when you start going for A ranks and begin to understand the mechanics behind the points system
Replies:
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 1:29:01 AM No.713039175
it's a 10/10
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 1:29:25 AM No.713039207
>>713038665
This, I always loved mech levels, always loved the music in them, also, to the fuckers who say "Tails, Rouge and Shadow were last minute additons" then fucking LOL, you just don't "shit out" half a game at the last minute with unique music, gimmicks, layout and art direction for the stages.
This, I always loved mech levels, always loved the music in them, also, to the fuckers who say "Tails, Rouge and Shadow were last minute additons" then fucking LOL, you just don't "shit out" half a game at the last minute with unique music, gimmicks, layout and art direction for the stages.
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 1:36:39 AM No.713039694
>>713038665
I will continue to get E rank, sorry
I will continue to get E rank, sorry
Replies:
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 1:44:52 AM No.713040302
>>713037242 (OP)
It's shit. Even the Sonic/Shadow levels are extreme janky garbage.
It's shit. Even the Sonic/Shadow levels are extreme janky garbage.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 1:46:15 AM No.713040409
>>713037242 (OP)
chaos are cute and its engine got used in the solo shadow game, so it's ok
chaos are cute and its engine got used in the solo shadow game, so it's ok
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 2:21:59 AM No.713042956
>>713037242 (OP)
It's an 4/10
It's an 4/10
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 2:40:16 AM No.713044283
>>713038665
This, I even managed to complete the timed level with Rogue on my first try. That level has filtered countless players.
This, I even managed to complete the timed level with Rogue on my first try. That level has filtered countless players.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 2:46:53 AM No.713044815
>>713037242 (OP)
the music was the savior of it.
the music was the savior of it.
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 2:49:56 AM No.713045053
>>713037242 (OP)
>Now that the dust has settled.... Was it actually a decent game or is it just nostalgia?
It was a great game but with glaring flaws.
>Now that the dust has settled.... Was it actually a decent game or is it just nostalgia?
It was a great game but with glaring flaws.
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:01:31 AM No.713045928
>>713040302
The jank is part of the charm though. It’s like skateboarding down a broken escalator—you’re either eating shit or having the time of your life. Sonic/Shadow stages had flow if you actually learned the routes. If you're speed boosting into walls, that's on you, not the game.
The jank is part of the charm though. It’s like skateboarding down a broken escalator—you’re either eating shit or having the time of your life. Sonic/Shadow stages had flow if you actually learned the routes. If you're speed boosting into walls, that's on you, not the game.
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:02:32 AM No.713046000
it's a masterpiece but only on dreamcast
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:03:06 AM No.713046046
>>713037242 (OP)
Its an alright 10/10.
Its an alright 10/10.
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:03:48 AM No.713046098
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:04:30 AM No.713046160
>>713037242 (OP)
One of the best games of all times. Best game in the Sonic series by far.
One of the best games of all times. Best game in the Sonic series by far.
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:04:32 AM No.713046169
I enjoyed it so much more when I installed a mod that let me play through a single style of gameplay at a time. It felt much easier to engage with the search and shooting stages on their own terms when I wasn't getting bounced around
Replies:
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:04:55 AM No.713046210
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:06:03 AM No.713046284
>>713037242 (OP)
ECHIDONA THAT'S WHAT I'M REPRESENTIN'
ECHIDONA THAT'S WHAT I'M REPRESENTIN'
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:19:26 AM No.713047239
Unironically the best Sonic game of all time it's the magnum opus of the series and it isn't even close don't @ me
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:24:55 AM No.713047605
>>713037242 (OP)
Dark story was better than Hero story.
But it begs the question why there was a space shuttle in a haunted pyramid, that also didn't have it go into low Earth orbit.
Dark story was better than Hero story.
But it begs the question why there was a space shuttle in a haunted pyramid, that also didn't have it go into low Earth orbit.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:25:20 AM No.713047628
Eggman levels are better than sonic
Werehog is better than day stages
3D platformers are king, running fast is for COWARDS
Werehog is better than day stages
3D platformers are king, running fast is for COWARDS
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:28:21 AM No.713047825
>>713040302
>Even the Sonic/Shadow levels are extreme janky garbage
You suck at the game plus you're a nigger.
>Even the Sonic/Shadow levels are extreme janky garbage
You suck at the game plus you're a nigger.
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:36:05 AM No.713048380
>>713037242 (OP)
Its the best 3D sonic, from a time when Sega had to actually put in the effort.
The chao garden alone could have been a whole ass game on the ps1.
Its the best 3D sonic, from a time when Sega had to actually put in the effort.
The chao garden alone could have been a whole ass game on the ps1.
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:38:16 AM No.713048519
>>713047605
The whole pyramid is eggmans secret base, it's the only place in the game that has eggman SA1 bots. There are some GUN bots on the outside, but eggman himself explains they are trying to find the entrance.
The whole pyramid is eggmans secret base, it's the only place in the game that has eggman SA1 bots. There are some GUN bots on the outside, but eggman himself explains they are trying to find the entrance.
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:59:52 AM No.713050084
>>713037242 (OP)
It was actually s decent game and none of these youtuber loving cunts over analyzing a game made for children over 25 years ago will ever change that
It was actually s decent game and none of these youtuber loving cunts over analyzing a game made for children over 25 years ago will ever change that
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 4:03:36 AM No.713050346
>>713044283
Idk how people can hate security hall, it's one of the best stages in the game.
Idk how people can hate security hall, it's one of the best stages in the game.
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 4:06:21 AM No.713050563
>Almost all speed stages are excellent
>Most of the mech stages are fine, only 1 is actually anywhere close to bad, and a few are great
>Treasure stages are a mix of good and flawed ones
>Chao garden is one of the most in depth pet raising sims around
>multiplayer versus has a variety of modes even if none are particularly fleshed out
>god tier soundtrack
>One of the best narratives in the franchise
It's an 8/10 at worst
>>713037457
>>713040302
No
>>713046169
Anon there's already a level select
>Most of the mech stages are fine, only 1 is actually anywhere close to bad, and a few are great
>Treasure stages are a mix of good and flawed ones
>Chao garden is one of the most in depth pet raising sims around
>multiplayer versus has a variety of modes even if none are particularly fleshed out
>god tier soundtrack
>One of the best narratives in the franchise
It's an 8/10 at worst
>>713037457
>>713040302
No
>>713046169
Anon there's already a level select
Replies:
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 4:11:55 AM No.713050941
>>713050563
I really don't like any of tails mech stages. Eggmans are good because they actually focus on racking up big scores, instead of slapping on weird gimmicks. Except sand ocean, that level sucks.
I really don't like any of tails mech stages. Eggmans are good because they actually focus on racking up big scores, instead of slapping on weird gimmicks. Except sand ocean, that level sucks.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 4:27:43 AM No.713051889
>>713050941
I agree that Eggman's are better on average (same for Knuckles over Rouge and Sonic over Shadow: You can tell that the original intent was just Sonic, Knuckles, and Eggman being playanle or at least the focus per the early teaser trailers), but I don't think any of Tail's stages are "bad" other then maybe Eternal Engine which is the only arguably bad mech stage in general
In fact i'd say Hidden Base is probably better or as good as Sand Ocean, Prison Lane is about as good or only slightly worse then Iron Gate, and the same is probably true for Mission street vs Lost colony. It's really mostly just that Eternal Engine is iffy and Weapon's Bed and Cosmic Wall are great
I agree that Eggman's are better on average (same for Knuckles over Rouge and Sonic over Shadow: You can tell that the original intent was just Sonic, Knuckles, and Eggman being playanle or at least the focus per the early teaser trailers), but I don't think any of Tail's stages are "bad" other then maybe Eternal Engine which is the only arguably bad mech stage in general
In fact i'd say Hidden Base is probably better or as good as Sand Ocean, Prison Lane is about as good or only slightly worse then Iron Gate, and the same is probably true for Mission street vs Lost colony. It's really mostly just that Eternal Engine is iffy and Weapon's Bed and Cosmic Wall are great
Replies:
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 4:41:32 AM No.713052734
>>713051889
Mission street is also annoying, mostly because of those slow moving up and down platforms you constantly have to wait on. Hidden base is bad for the same reasons sand ocean is bad, since they are basically the same stage. The prison levels are fine I guess, but eggmans feels like it has more focus on busting up stuff.
Mission street is also annoying, mostly because of those slow moving up and down platforms you constantly have to wait on. Hidden base is bad for the same reasons sand ocean is bad, since they are basically the same stage. The prison levels are fine I guess, but eggmans feels like it has more focus on busting up stuff.