>>713168194 (OP)If the controls aren't borked, then KB+M is hands down the best for basically everything outside of specialist controllers like flightsticks, wheels and VR.
>>713168238Unless the camera is fixed, automatic or otherwise not related to your movement (thus forcing you to truly use only 8-directional movement), KB+M still generally provides far more precise movement controls than dual analog does and non-VR controllers only come close when they can also use gyroscopes.
Basically the only thing that the analog stick adds at that point is slow movement and you can do that on keyboard with a walk toggle.
>>713169986You are sacrificing fun for "efficiency" when you're playing FPS on conventional controllers. There are far more fun input methods for FPS than conventional controllers and M+KB beats conventional controllers at efficiency.
>>713170538Games after the mid-2000s radically reduced verticality, introduced slow-motion, introduced stealth elements, introduced cover mechanics, adopted a walk button for aiming on every weapon and heavily emphasized context sensitivity.
3D Games are so crippled that controllers can sort of play them now.