Which one did it better?

Well one is a solid stealth game and the other is the most linear, generic FPS possible made by an ideas guy who just thought of a cool setting

Dishonored, obviously

>>713380929 (OP)
People still make dishonored videos(mostly stealthgamerbr). No one cares about bioshock in the year 20+25

>>713380929 (OP)
Dishonored is better stealth/action game.
Bioshock was all about making player feel immersed from very first minutes of gameplay.

bait

>>713381331
>if people make youtube videos about a game that means its better
lol

lmao, perchance.

Bioshock doesn't let you try and do no kill runs they aren't really the same game.

>>713385160
Point is that you would be hard pressed to find anyone who still remembers Bioshock let alone calls themselves Bioshock fans in 2025. Same can't be said about Dishonored which left a much bigger legacy.

>>713380929 (OP)
Do what better? Be a poor imitation of a better game from the 90s?

>>713386278
>do what
Do your mum lol.

>>713386206
upcoming Pragmata is basically repainted Bioshock - dude in armor with creepy girl sidekick prowling through dystopian ruins

>>713380929 (OP)
They have a lot of similar elements but they're very different games, mainly because Dishonored is a stealth game first and foremost, while Bioshock is a pure action game. Personally I think while Dishonored has cooler magic, you're discouraged from doing all the cool magic and combat abilities since you get a bad ending if you kill too many people. Bioshock encourages you heavily to use plasmids and combo them with different guns and using the environment around you. Personally I think Dishonored and Bioshock Infinite are more apt for comparisons. Infinite is closer in gameplay, setting, and story to Dishonored and they are both considered to be two of the best "steampunk" games out there, in that case Dishonored takes the cake as being far more interesting and cooler than Infinite. Bioshock 2 and Infinite are better experiences than Dishonored 2 however by far, I think Bioshock 2 might be even better than Dishonored 1.

>>713387279
weak comeback kiddo.

>>713386206
I love both games.

>>713380929 (OP)
Did what better? Bioshock is a more well rounded game but Dishonored has peaks that are beyond by any game, the setting and mood in Dishonored are operating at a level only matched by pure aesthetic exercises like mirrors edge, the gameplay in both is fine, Dishonored is more engaging with the stealth focus.

>>713381102
To be fair, both of them have cool settings. "Space station but with crushing water instead of vacuum of space" took surprisingly long to be made as a vidya, and "City 17 but with whale oil instead of dark matter" is equally neat.