Why is Silent Hill 3 so divisive?

>>713458838 (OP)
f isn't a real silent hill

>>713458886
It's better

it isn't. never heard of that. im pretty sure its beloved and seen by many as the last good SH game, no?

>>713458886
Yep, it's Siren. None of it's designs so far looked silent hill.

>>713458838 (OP)
it's not, it's just the vocal SH2 cultists who shits on everything that isn't SH2

>>713459227
So why call it silent hill? Shouldn't have to ride off another game's name if it's better.

>>713459443
because you purpose is to make money you retard. Why call it forbidden siren/fatal frame or whatever C tier horror game when they can call it silent hill?

>>713458838 (OP)
The first 3 games are universally considered the only good ones.

>>713458838 (OP)
is this bitch wearing tights?

>>713458838 (OP)
>escape from Douglas through bathroom window
>first roadblock is a bunch of boxes next to a small fence
>next roadblock is an easily jumable car retardedly parked between two walls
>hhmmmm better go inside this strangely empty mall with monsters.
a little later
>find Douglas again, first real human after beating dozens of monsters
>hmmm I better go alone into this strangely EMPTY subway, it's not like shit needs actual people to work and take me home :D what could go wrong???
The first part of this game is pure trash, it does get better on the second half.

>>713458838 (OP)
It's not.

>>713459710
3 is technically the best but suffers from shit pacing and story. 4 design is shit but it has thenmost interesting ideas and story. SH1 and SH2 are just better.

>>713458838 (OP)
>squatting behind the trash bin of a dirty back alley
old habits die hard

>>713458838 (OP)
Heatherfags are annoying simps that make the franchise look bad. The game is alright.

>>713459878
nah the nonsensical dreamy vibe of the beginning is kino

>>713460045
waifufags are always like this and just ruin everything

>>713459443
Because of sh2 demake. Something, something engagement numbers

>>713458838 (OP)
Go back faggot >>11816345

>>713458838 (OP)
This is the first I've heard of that.
Everyone I know liked it or at least wanted to try it.

>>713460045
>>713460104
Fucking THIS!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UkumV_dHbkg

>>713458838 (OP)
SH2 is the divisive one because it borders on being a movie game. The game only had like 7 enemies (8 if you count the bugs) and apparently the director wanted even less.
It still mogs the remake.

>>713458838 (OP)
Now that SH1 Remake is confirmed by Bloober again, do you think that they'll deliver or go back to their usual self? I don't want the game to be shit, but I don't think they'll be successful twice. I plated Blair Witch a month ago and it was complete shit.

>>713460750
>it borders on being a movie game
such a fucking 4chan opinion. its got combat, zone exploration, puzzles, skippable cutscenes, a god damn speedrun stat and grade ranking, and the games several endings are all tied to the things you choose to do as james, not a branching dialogue tree. i can't even think of a single other relevant metric. just because the story isnt forgettable garbage doesn't mean that its not a video game.

>>713461113
Chronos looks alright
They've gotten better

>>713458838 (OP)
Pachinko machine game turned into a full numbered title and it shows.

>>713458838 (OP)
i need to see her pissing

>>713461134
Notice how I said "borders on" anon. It's as much of a movie game as Portal 2 where the story kinda takes over certain parts of the game. Basically the type of game you'd recommend to people who've never played a game.

>>713461867
You're reaching, you fucking know Silent Hill 2 is not a good game for someone who has never played one.

>>713459804
That's better though

>>713462054
>has never played one
Yeah, that's a bit too far, but still. I think normies could play normal difficulty on autopilot because it's easy to get invested in the story.

>>713458838 (OP)
>wants to do a sh cosplay
>needs a fitting location
>Yeah this random ass back alley dumpster at night will do
Lol

>>713460190
I am fucking this though

it's bread

>>713458838 (OP)
If I was born when the last good Silent Hill was released I'd be eligable for early retirement

>>713461867
so your metrc for movie game is "a me that sometimes takes control from you"? that's nothing.

>>713462675
>19-21
>early retirement

>another silenthill 'fan' bpdwhore thread
based

3 can afford to have otherworld sequences outside of the town because Heather is the reincarnation of Cheryl

What is the Short Message's excuse?
What is Ascension's excuse?
What will be f's excuse?