which one do you consider their best game?

dark souls 2 (scholar) fuck jannies

>>713479324 (OP)
Darksouls 1 and Bloodborne.

Dark Souls 1, even though Demon's Souls is my favorite.

>>713479324 (OP)
Sekiro probably

>>713479324 (OP)
sekiro bc it doesn't waste my time and is just fun

>>713479324 (OP)
ER>BB>DS2-3-1>DeS>Sekiro

>>713479324 (OP)
Elden Ring. The world is better.
I think bloodborne is overrated. But then I didn't play it as a teenager.

>>713479921
First 1/3 is shitty mob fights. You NG plus fiends forget how bad that original start was.

>>713479324 (OP)
It's between these two, not those two.

>>713479324 (OP)
Sekiro > Bloodborne > Lies of P > Dark Souls = Elden Ring

>>713480354
>Lies of P
That's a different company.

Kings Field IV, Otogi: Myth of Demons, and Bloodborne are my favorites. I have not played Shadow Tower Abyss yet, but I plan to.

>>713480180
I didnt care much for Demon Souls but that final boss may have been the peak of the series. I feel similar about the back half of DS1.

>>713480415
Bro put Sekiro first, if he could read he would be very upset.

For me, it's King's Field II JP

>>713480686
I kneel!

i've only played sekiro, armored core, and elden ring
so
sekiro, because it's a game that teaches you about your own levels of persistence through strife
elden ring, game's fuckhuge and the messages crack me up. i also like flexibility in builds and what order you can tackle everything
armored core, pretty robot zoom boom fun

>>713480542
I didn't ask for you dogshit takes.

>>713480029
couldn't give a shit you kill them in like 2 hits and the game isn't 60 hours long for no reason
or fucking 100 in the case of elden ring. I liked Elden ring but good lord that moment when you unlock mountaintops and the map expands, I can't believe I continued playing

>>713479324 (OP)
Elden ring for sure, I really like bb too. Its not really necessary to choose in my mind.
Er base game just gives me more for my imagination. BB has more direct themes, its a narrower scope of ideas that are awesome to explore but er gives me that and more. Open world doesn’t frighten me, I have the time to spend in them and appreciate it.

ER as Bloodborne is overrated

>>713479324 (OP)
elden ring. it's like all the previous souls games combined in terms of content. good hitboxes, good challenge, good graphics. storylines are actually completable without looking them up. then they released a DLC with the content of another souls game. usually the gameplay suffers when devs try to go for quantity, but not Elden Ring

ER goes to shit after the capital (just like DaS!)

>>713479324 (OP)
Sekiro
and it's not even close

>>713479324 (OP)
i've only played bloodborne and elden ring but i prefer bloodborne. i have bounced off dark souls 1 a couple times because it's quite a bit clunkier than those two, but i will continue attempting it until i get it, since A) that's the one that most people agree is the best and B) the opening cinematic might be the GOAT

>>713479324 (OP)
The one with the cutest doll.

>>713479324 (OP)
Elden Ring because it was an experience unlike any other. It lived up to the hype. The variety and builds are insane. My only real complaint is that there’s no dedicated pvp/invasion hub like Pontiff Sullivahn bonfire in Dark Souls 3.

>>713479324 (OP)
The one that doesnt have cheap as fuck aimbot, input read and spin 360° on the same spot to hit you bullshit

>>713479324 (OP)
i like all of them :)

>>713479324 (OP)
1.Bloodborne

2.demon souls

3.Ds2 (original version)

4.Ds1 second half in all honesty is the biggest piece of dog shit.

5. Sekiro

6. Elden ring

7. Dark souls 3

Honestly the bottom 3 are all tied.

As someone who started with demon souls back in 2009.

elden ring is fucking dogshit

i just played through ER BB and demons souls and by far demons souls is the best one.
BB is near unplayable with sub 20 fps, pixelated as fuck graphics , ER is pure copy pasted slop with no thought put into design or purpose of the world

>>713485465
ds1 second half is absolutely at the bottom of my list if we are allowed to separate it from the rest of the game

like holy SHIT. Even for the time it was inexcusable

>>713485612
Ds1 was the first that showed me that sometimes cutting content down is good.

Basically everything after anor Londo.

i tried playing BB but I just can't with the performance memes on the PS4, people who claimed it even ran at stable 30 were lying, you were lucky if it was even 20
I beat cleric beast and cascoigne and then just couldn't take it anymore

and I'm sure it's fine but you can't convince me to emulate it bc in the end it is yet another fromsoft plot that we have seen like 7 times at this point

>>713479324 (OP)
Bloodborne by a mile, everything is just perfect, combat, story, world building, enemy design, boss design, level design etc.

>>713486017
FPSfags are the worst

>>713486017
On PS5 its a locked 30fps at 1080p. it feels pretty playable i platinumed it as well. Also PS5 gives it improved loading times

>>713486562
"30" fps with constant and unpredictable dips sucks fucking ass, deal with it

Bloodborne is extremely overrated by hardcore snoys purely because it's exclusive. Yes, I have played it to completion + DLC (even on real hardware before emulation became available for it).

The best one is Demon's Souls (original) because it has the most soul.

>>713486596
cool, I'm not gonna buy a PS5 for 1 game at 30fps locked

>>713486562
Frame drops are objectively bad.

>>713486787
I didnt say anything about buying anything. I was just saying something about the state of it.

there is literally nothing wrong with 30fps

>>713486948
wouldn't it be cool if the PS4 could actually run BB at 30

>>713487037
I beat Bloodborne twice on the base PS4. your just being a pussy

um bros you've been able to emulate bloodborne at 60fps and beyond for a while now, whats your excuse

>>713479938
>ER at the top
>the game that is like other Souls games starring the jump and speed of Sekiro
>Sekiro at bottom
retard stuff

>>713487182
it's a fromsoft game I already know what the story is so I just don't care that much
it's not even particularly different combat wise, roll is just replaced with dashing and the gun is parry. It is not some kind of miracle of gaming