Ok gentlemen, it is time for a real and important discussion on this board.

Which one is the best for marriage and procreation, and who did you choose and why?

Thinking about going with Emily this time, because I'm in the mood of dating an autistic & cute woman. Penny likes Sam so that's a no in my book, not to mention it's implied they still fuck from time to time in the forest. The other ones I might date them in other playthroughs.

emily has a yuge ass but is a canon braphog

Never played this game but Jas is cute.

Year 3 of my first ever run, I went in knowing nothing about this game. I ended up with Leah, although Haley was a close second (i may get a divorce and go for her eventually)
I removed the childrens beds from my house before i got married.

>>713540618 (OP)
Mara because she won't chear on you because she's ugly.

>>713540618 (OP)
>Which one is the best for marriage and procreation
Jas.

>>713540618 (OP)
Emily's shirt looks like it's made out of the most itchy, uncomfortable material imaginable.

>>713540618 (OP)
>Thinking about going with Emily this time

You'd think correct! Emily supremacy!

>>713540732
>>713541253
Yeah, I'm thinking Jased.

>wine takes two months in the cellar to be maxed out
>mfw its only worth 480g after waiting

>>713540618 (OP)
NotRobin is the easiest one to get hearts with to get a year 1 max rated farm
She's the bachelorette equivalent of the hobo who gives you the sashimi recipe

>>713540703
Canonically true.

>>713540703
Girls don't fart, dumbass.

>>713540618 (OP)
>Which one is the best for marriage and procreation, and who did you choose and why?

Haley, i pick her every time.
Outside of her kind of being a bitch at you the first time you meet her she warms up to you and becomes the best waifu.

Emily is the ugliest and cringiest. Canonically the worst choice. If you chose her, you suck: FACT

>>713541740
Tell that to the girl who gave me a dutch oven one time.

>>713541581
>He aged wine to iridium
Bro cheese is way better because get gold grade from cows and better yet goats and after a single week it's iridium grade.

Its just way more efficient to use basement caskets for cheese then wine

>>713540618 (OP)
if you're looking to start a family, you can immediately get rid of Maru, Abigail and Leah. Maru because she's autistic and would constantly be comparing you to her father, Abigail because she'd run off into the mines without you looking for adventure but getting smacked down by a void creature or a swarm of bats, and Leah because she intentionally lives outside of town to be free from the pressures of society, so a relationship would be 'trapping' her.

now, these individuals are all young and could change, but that doesn't happen in pelican town

that leaves Penny, Haley and Emily. Penny is a teenager who wants to be a mother and does actually take an interest in educating the three kids that live in the valley. She comes with baggage though, with her mother. Pam is a nice enough lady in public but I could see Pam and Penny arguing about things in front of your kids.

Haley is immature in that she marches the beat of her own drum, doing what she wants. But she is capable of change and growth. Her teasing when you're new to town quickly changes from being face value to just how she talks to her friends. She also has an actual hobby in photography which is a good sign. while Penny is what people think trad wives are, Haley actually becomes one when you marry her.

Emily I feel is the best choice for starting a family with. All her weirdness aside she contributes heavily to the festivals that go on in town and organizes many get togethers for the women of pelican town. she is also an accomplished tailor and actually holds down a job, though she admits its more for entertainment than money. I feel her biggest flaw would be having arguments about her forcing veganism on your kids

/v/ is an Emily board.

Penny was born to bear and raise my children.

>>713542147
yea i realized that after the first batch finished, now i'm doing mostly cheese and a few barrels of ancient fruit wine. i'm rich anyway, none of it matters any more and i'm adventuring now

>>713542148
>Penny is a teenager
Is she? I imagined she’s like 20.

>>713542148
>Leah because she intentionally lives outside of town to be free from the pressures of society, so a relationship would be 'trapping' her.
i punched her ex in the face and shes been all over my dick since, thoughever

>>713542385
i never said Leah wouldn't be good for a fuck. i wouldn't raise kids with her though

>>713542148
>the three kids
who is the third kid?

>>713542462
shes an okay wife, but i will never know about how she raises kids. dont want them in real life, dont want them in the game.
i'm curious about what it changes in game though, do you get additional chores or something? does it ever grow up to be a kid or just stay a baby?

>>713542503
Leo joins Jas and Vincent's little group when he moves to the mainland, including getting tutored by Penny

>>713542569
your kids start out as infants, take 1 season to turn into toddlers. they stay as toddlers for the rest of the playthrough. they also have relationship bars like your animals and pets do, but nothing comes of it

the fact they never grow beyond toddlers means i can never have kids in stardew again. trapping my children in an eternal state of infancy feels far crueller than them never existing. the only way to free them from that hell is to give their souls to an evil spirit who haunts you

>>713542742
>spoiler
lmao. i've also been wondering if the ancient couple ever die, but i guess time is kind of frozen for valley inhabitants, huh

>>713542148
Why type all those words when you could've just said 3 letters?

>>713540618 (OP)
Haley is literally the best choice and the one with the best character development, no other candidate can compare.
And picking penny is lame.
>>713540732
Like 90% of jasfags.

>>713542948
Jas wasn't included in the criterion

Though I am not a Jas-lover myself I do appreciate and support the C-team

>>713542957
I got something for you, bro.

>>713541935
Haley is the best wife and it's not even close.
>>713542209
Mud's characters are so expressive.

I've married Penny, Emily, and Haley.

>Penny
She's poor and lives in a trailer with an alcoholic mother so I felt sorry for her and wanted to rescue her. She's bookish and wants a big family, both of which were pluses for me.

>Emily
Wasn't originally a marriageable NPC, but I married her as soon as the change was made. She's got a nice butt and is a fun, welcoming person. One of the few NPCs in Pelican Town who was genuinely nice to you from the moment she met you. She's kind of a weirdo but given that magic is real in SDV her new age wackiness probably isn't nonsense.

>Haley
Once I got past her rudeness she proved to be by far the best girl. She has an actual character arc. It's not that she completely changes her identity, her identity expands as you become more important to her. I find it hard not to pick Haley whenever I replay now.

>>713541935
I don't even think she's kind of a bitch to you. I probably DID smell, having toiled in the field all day clearing brush, and my shoes probably DID suck, as I hadn't even upgraded them from my dusty noob boots yet.
Best character arc of the whole group, and there's something nice about the simplicity of her loving sunflowers. She even likes daffodils! <3
You can base your entire farm around her loves and it'll be pretty comfy:
>sunflowers
>coconuts
>fruit salad (blueberry, melon, apricot)
>pink cake (wheat flour (wheat), sugar (beets), melon, egg (chickens))

>>713542209
>those proportions

Reached the 10th day of winter 1st year, havent progressed much as ive been busy play other games.
Did my first trip to the island place and got lots of expensive mushrooms and fruit trees from mobs, that place is super profitable but takes the whole day to explore, beat the crap outta Willy on the fishing contest and i am currently starting to fill my greenhouse with ancient fruit plants.
Next goal, gather tons of seeds for the parrots and catch the legendary winter fish.

Is jasmod complete yet

>>713545705
Technically, yes. All the main marriage content is there. We're still waiting on the finished lewd events and bonus stuff though.

>>713542948
Kill yourself

>>713540618 (OP)

All are gay, I'll fuck my farm animals

As usual, Jasfags insert themselves where they are not wanted. They're just like troons.

>>713545962
>this scares the normalfaggot

>>713540618 (OP)
Never played Stardew Valley, can I get qrd on all 6 female characters?

Pam
I can repair her

>>713546456
>Stardew Valley waifufaggotry thread
>"where they are not wanted"

>>713540618 (OP)
Girl here, I choose Shane.

>>713546578
Doesnt Pam become a functional member of society after you repair the bus?

>>713546952
She does. She becomes a driver

There isn’t too much good SDV fanart so I've had to generate images of my wife until I learn how to draw.

>>713540618 (OP)
BB

>>713540618 (OP)
The only correct answer

>>713546498
From top left to bottom right:
>rebellious gamer girl
>quirk chungus
>mean blonde
>cottagecore bitch
>black nerd
>bookish tradwife

>>713546906
>girl
that obvious lie aside, why? he seems like the biggest loser out of everyone

>>713540618 (OP)
Shane, because he is a lovable loser and also hot.

>>713547312
The farmer makes everyone's life better on relationship increase and farm progress, but what do you do for Clint? I actually have never befriended him.

>>713547984
NTA, but I just imagined Shane as a girl and honestly, I get it.

>>713548705
He gathers courage and asks Emily out if you aren't dating or married her.

>>713549081
Ohhh, nice.
Emily deserves better tho.

>>713541253
based

>>713540618 (OP)
Haley. Turning her from a wannabe city bimbo into a proper country girl is the best concept. Abigail is a fa gamer, emily will probably slit your throat and sacrifice you while you sleep, leah has too much baggage, maru is ugly and brown and well penny is the second best choice.

>>713547546
Kill yourself pedophile

>>713540618 (OP)
Abby because she's a fat fuck who eats rocks and stuff. Amusing enough to warrant my choice when I played it.

Jodi

Completely honest answer, anyone who doesn't say Emily is a closeted cuckhold.
>Abigail
If you stop giving her attention after marriage, instead of actually discussing her troubles with you, she thinks she should have choosed Sebastian. This means Abigail would rather cheat on you than discussing any marital problem, no matter if it's your fault or not.
>Haley
Let's be fucking honest. Haley was getting fucked by everyone at high school and she would be the first one to whore herself out with an onlyfans.
>Leah
She is a woman with a problematic ex. This shows her weakness at the time of choosing lovers, this is the type of woman to date a drunk retard that will molest her children and she will miss every sign. You are getting sloppy seconds.
>Maru
Daddy's girl, submissive to higher authority and who knows if she is autistic. If a man hits on her and he doesn't take a no for an answer, instead of slapping him away or blocking him his calls, she would let him get his way on her because she can't say no. If you come across a man who really wants a piece of her and flirts constantly with her as your wife, she WILL let it pass.
>Penny
Another submissive partner and same weakness as Maru. Even if she and Sam never fucked against a tree, the incorrect mental implication will always be stucked in Penny fags mind.
>Emily
You will think she is a bit crazy, but giving the game's world and context all of her believes are actually justified. She properly communicates her feelings with Haley with chores of the house and almost confessed her feelings during one heart event, this shows her as being emotional mature. Not only that, but she has the most wonderful romantic heart event on a campsite.

>>713550298
That gossiping hag? She would tell everyone immediately how how you got your ass whooped at the volcano dungeon,

For me, it's Sandy

>>713550526
Your assessment of Haley sounds like a mix of projection and surface-level judgment. Her character is deeper than might initially seem, and she grows as a character, becoming less childish and vain upon spending time with you. Haley at 10 hearts is easily the sweetest and most loyal female love interest.

>>713540618 (OP)
Best mod to make the girls actually physically appealing?

>Stardew girls thread almost at 70 replies
>best girl still hasn't been posted yet

>>713552854
marnie sexo

>>713552854
>Best girl
>someone with set events to show multiple times she had sex with the mayor

>>713554902
Like this one?

>>713555460
kek

>>713540618 (OP)
Robin

but haley or abi would do

>>713540618 (OP)
Baz!

>>713541740
>he doesn't know
someone post it

>>713549549
Based fatfag, she's always my choice for that.
>Stardew Fatty is dead
sad. pretty sure that dialogue is directly from that mod

>>713559671
it

Are all the bachelorettes used goods?

>>713559671

>>713540618 (OP)
I went with Maru mainly because she's the only nonwhite bachelorette. I do like her personality though (what little there is, but most of the girls are kind of one note beyond Haley and her admittedly basic character arc). On a side note I kind of wish her 6 and 8 heart events got switched around; Maru nearly confessing to you after stargazing together feels more appropriate for an 8 heart event than the robot thing.

>>713540618 (OP)
Jas. Obviously.

>>713542957
>Like 90% of jasfags.
One of them 100%'d the game within the week the mod dropped.

>>713540618 (OP)
I choose Sen, he is chill, awesome and very cute nice guy I love talk every day when I see him

Also I have a weird attraction over shadow/monsters creatures so yeah

>>713566795
I would ask "how the heck" but i have learned to never underestimate the conjoined power of degenerancy and autism.

>>713541935
The Jas pedos and the self inserts will choose anyone else besides Haley. If you insert as a chad you feel totally at home with Haley, plus is turns out to be helpful and loving with zero baggage.

>>713540618 (OP)
maru>

>>713545705
No it's not. It's a mess and downloading it puts you in a watchlist

>>713545705
Depends on what you mean by complete. It's perfectly playable from start to finish but more content is hopefully coming. Jasanon isn't dead yet, but it's pretty clear there were blows to his motivstion since 1.6

>>713567994
i kinda get the feeling that Emily would suffer a little bit having to live alone. not that she would go full empty nest but she seems like the type who needs a roommate

>>713540618 (OP)
Emily or Hailey and its hardly a choice. Maru is rubber up if you want a career woman with a fat ass. Abigal is useless and fat, penny is incel bait, leah is a mess

Marnie should've been an option without the whole Lewis subplot.

>>713568176
Based fellow Marufag. Also thanks for your contributions to the black girl threads on /gif/

>>713566961
Terrible taste and you should feel bad. This mod is garbage, Sen has zero personality whatsoever besides "heckin' wholesomerino monster that just wants friends", which is fitting given that it was born from the FtM troon author's Undertale OC.

>>713571226
Blame Emily twitterfags for this.

>>713542148
>she contributes heavily to the festivals that go on in town and organizes many get togethers for the women of pelican town. she is also an accomplished tailor and actually holds down a job
This is an argument AGAINST Emily though
I want the woman raising my kids to be focused on, you know, raising my kids - not some upcoming festival or getting a client's suit alterations done

>>713540618 (OP)
which one of them is based on devs wife?

>>713564360
They all have been paired off before you even arrive. Jas is the only pure maiden.

>>713574925
Jas

>>713568176
what uh... whats goin on down there?

>>713576309
i cant even find the edit, so i cant confirm. either futa bulge or diaper
the original doesnt have her with a schlong. its AromaSenpai

>>713576309
>>713577175
nevermind, found it
it's futa
https://wimg.rule34.xxx//images/2923/d6221d6149339c879df69b5244348437.jpeg

>>713577258
Thread ruined.

>>713577258

>everyone ITT was lusting after a futa
>now they try to recoil as if they arent permanently gay