thoughts? I always remap my buttons this way when I can

i just put my thumb in the center and roll to all 4

Yes OP that's what I try to do whenever it makes sense

>>713635735 (OP)
it doesn't matter.

captcha: 08p00

>>713635735 (OP)
>4 buttons
>one dumb thumb

>>713635735 (OP)
what industry standard? controllers are still a wild west

>>713635735 (OP)
>industry standard
Are we still in the SNES days? The right image has been the standard for almost 3 decades now.

>>713637223
Nintendo does that. Xbox is similar but A swapped with B (and Y with X). And I'm not even gonna talk about Sony cause their buttons are made up shapes with no meaning.

>nintendo layout
retarded, Y should be on the Y axis and X on the X axis.

>>713637441
>The right image has been the standard for almost 3 decades now
Um, no. It takes a second to google.

The only Nintendo controller that doesn't do the thumb rolling is N64.

>>713635735 (OP)
how fucking tiny are your hands if your thumb is only 11mm wide. You put your thumb between A and B in the first image and should easily be able to press both buttons by pressing down in a slightly different direction

swap X and Y on your remap because games are designed for you to be able to press X and A simultaneously

>>713637464
Sony's buttons are the only ones designed with meaning
What do X or Y mean?

>>713638345
It's not like I CAN'T do that, nor is it difficult. It's just not as natural. With the right side layout, I can fully cover both buttons. With the left side, it's like I'm pressing into the middle gap between the buttons, each button only being pushed on half a side. Feels weird. And not every controller is sized the same so they could have bigger gaps.

My thumb is 20mm wide thank you

>>713637880
The fact that they change every generation proves Nintendo consoles are for toddlers. You only need consistency if your playerbase is consistent, and obviously nobody should be playing Nintendo games after 10 years old (i.e. 1 generation).

>>713638687
this also X being on the X axis and Y being on the Y axis makes more sense than nintendo’s random layout

>>713635735 (OP)
that "industry standard" is only for nintendo games, except the snes. Picture from the right is indeed better

>>713637464
>cause their buttons are made up shapes with no meaning
>circle to select
>cross (fork) to cancel
>square looks like a page menu
>triangle for alerts

im pretty sure anyone not retarded does like on the right

>>713636904
consolefats eternally RAPED by keybros

>>713635735 (OP)
Left side made Kirby games on 3DS and OOT/MM on 3DS unplayable. Why doesn't Nintendo just add button mapping to their games? You need to hack your 3DS just to button map.
https://gbatemp.net/threads/wip-buttonswap3ds-remap-buttons-on-your-3ds.460891/

i think it's fine if circle is "back" in menus but square is like a power attack or whatever in gameplay.

>>713635735 (OP)
Look at an Xbox controller. Most games bind X to attack and A to jump for this very reason.

>>713640906
Sony had the same layout with Maru and Batsu until they started localizing games for the west and changed it for no reason in most games

>>713637464
>"made up shapes"
>shapes present in every society, fun, unique, recognizable, memorable
>xbox and nintentdo: sterile abcdy letters, which majority of the world doesn't use

>>713638687
What game requires you to press A and X at the same time

>>713646226
Paper Mario, TTYD on the Nintendo Switch. You will hold X to hold Koops in front of a switch and jump up a flight of stairs in Hooktail Castle.

I do A and Y.
Horizontal Finger.

>>713647768
owie hand hort :(

The right is better for fighting games the left for platformers where you're mainly just jumping

>>713647821
I don't know why I did it like that naturally when I first used a controller, but it worked. I eventually learned it was super unorthodox despite the NES controller kind of encouraging it, so I swapped to the diagonal stance for a bit but I still don't really like that.

>>713635735 (OP)
I claw grip my controller, learned this technique from melee it lets me be faster with the imputs.

>>713635735 (OP)
Left when I don't have to press the right shoulder button

right if I do have to press the right shoulder button.

>>713649730
???

what does the shoulder button have to do with anything?

>>713635735 (OP)
Industry standard for what? I never seen a game need A and B except to accept and cancel stuff (usually rpgs), and you don't want to overlap your finger over accept and cancel risking pressing one of them by mistake.
Usually action games use Y and X for attacks, and you hold them exacly like the second picture.
Fun fact, if you play super metroid with the original button setup, ideally your thumb would be hovering above X (fire), A (jump) and B (run) so you can press the three simultaneously

>>713635735 (OP)
When I see some faggot talk about MORE MOVEMENT in regards to moving their thumb a fucking third of an inch I am sickened to my core at their abject laziness.
Cunt I hope you wind up quadruplegic. I mean, just think of all that movement you wouldn't have to do anymore, you indolent cocksucker.

>>713651453
Humanity shouldn't have invented the wheel. They should have been content pushing shit in mud. Those lazy fuckers.

>>713644201
>leaving out sega and arcade cabinets

>>713635735 (OP)
This is why 6 face button layouts are awkward and shit.