Thread 713807625

Does it still deserve its position as #1 rated game of all time?

>>713807625 (OP)
You've got the wrong pic right?

>>713807686
FPBP

>>713807686
Close but not quite.

>>713807625 (OP)
I don't think so, but it's the best JRPG of the last 15 years.

>>713807775
BASED spoink enjoyer

>>713807816
Kek, we all know why. Too white for him probably.

>>713807816
How bad does your taste have to be to enjoy Midsidian slop over this game

>>713807625 (OP)
This is the most overrated game I've ever seen. It's an 8/10 being heralded as an 11/10 second coming of gaming. I'm not sure if it's shills or just the fact that most zoomies have literally never played a JRPG before.

>>713807816
Ex33 is overrated as fuck but avowed is just bad.

>>713808219
Whats your 10/10 then?

>>713807625 (OP)
it's easily the goty, boredom strangling has nothing to this masterpiece

>>713808334
DS2 has Buck Brokeman dancing though.

>>713808219
>This is the most overrated game I've ever seen
You must be pretty young senpai.
Something like Bioshit Infinite was labeled the Citizen Kane of gayming when it's a 3/10 game.

It’s not a bad game, but definitely overrated from what I’ve played so far. I feel like some of the fellating it gets is because it’s a very forgiving game and because of the story aspects. You don’t have to worry about losing progress when you fail a fight, you don’t have to worry about resource management when you explore, it’s very convenient. It’s the kind of game people would say respects your time. But it also makes the game less interesting.

I can’t think of a game that I dropped quicker than E33.
The blurriness, the way the character runs, everything about it is gay as fuck and unbearable

>>713807625 (OP)
E33 has a great story, soundtrack, character designs but the combat is ass how it's solely focused on parry and dodge it should have been a secondary thing not a primary thing. That and the dark souls bouts to rest flags is ass and having estus flask healing system is ass the qte is cool like the legend of dragoon but the parry dodge system sucks it should have visual cues like vagrant story with its risk breaker chain combos if they did all that the game would be a 10/10 as of now I give it a 8.5/10 because it's combat just sucks

>>713808608
By the gaming media, but gamers didn't have the same reception. That's what is different. Gaming media overrating games has always happened. But with Expedition 33, it's gamers going nuts for a game that, to me, seems pretty much just 'good' and not 'amazing'.

>>713808330
The last game I'd consider close to a 10/10 is Elden Ring.

>>713807625 (OP)
They did spend 2 billion dollars to market and shill it everywhere possible

>>713808957
It was 6 billion actually

>>713808656
>"It's overrated. Why?"
>*Proceeds to list negligible qualities that apply to all classic RPGs*

>>713808882
Elden Ring has tons of problems, you have no credibility

kek the shills for this game are insufferable

>>713807625 (OP)
It's a a 8/10 game honestly, but it has great music, probably the best OST since Bloodborne, so that's a +1 bonus point making it a 9/10.
And a 9/10 3D game made by 40 people is a great achievement, so there's a lot of goodwill around it, I can understand why.

>>713809129
Yeah it has problems, but it's a lot better than Expedition 33.

>>713807625 (OP)
nah, recency bias is over, most are saying it was 7/10 now

>>713807625 (OP)
It's been 2 months, retardo.

>>713809331
How is it better?
Elden Ring has bad story, bad characters, bad graphics, bad gameplay and terrible music.

>>713807625 (OP)
It depends on the person and the genres they like but it's definitely in the conversation for best jrpg of all time.

>>713808882
>A bloated open world that lacks the variety to warrant a map 1/5th its size at best
>Some of the worst bosses they ever made, flooded with uninspired duo fights
>Jump heavy spam is so poorly balanced and implemented, it renders the optimal way to play all melee builds the same, even after the nerfs

The irony of calling E33 the most overrated, then giving Elden Ring a 10/10. Elden Ring's not even a top-3 From game.

Nah, it's a 7/10.
MAYBE a 8

>>713809690
E33 is better than every Fromsoft game ever made

>>713809294
>probably the best OST since Bloodborne
What? is this a joke?
Bloodborne soundtrack is mediocre and is nowhere near Expedition 33 marvelous soundtrack.

Are you diagnosed with shit taste syndrome by any chance?

>>713809925
no, Sekiro and BB are 9/10s, DS1 is an 8/10, E33 is 7.5/10

>>713810178
DS1 is a 10
Sekiro and E33 are 9
BB is a 8 and I'm being generous

>>713809925
They literally created a whole genre everybody is bend into copying since a good while now, even ex33 would be nothing without them since the dodge / parry mechanic in this game is doing the heavy lifting.

>>713809925
Why are you comparing an action / adventure game with a turn-based RPG, retard.

So do I get this or NEO TWEWY

>>713807625 (OP)
I don't know but I want to nut in Sciel

>>713808219
>I'm not sure if it's shills or just the fact that most zoomies have literally never played a JRPG before.
It's pseuds who are ready to jump at anything that's vaguely conceptual. But there's a problem if your avantgarde story was better executed by an alt rock band 20+ years ago. Which isn't to say Coheed and Cambria's comic is particularly good, but rather that E33 is nothing special, even under the limited ambit of nerd culture.
And if you take just a half-step out of jerkoff culture, you can easily see E33 is just a shittier Nolan movie. It's like a 20 year old kid's take on Inception.

>>713807816
>Avowed
never heard of her, but i'm sure expedition 33 could top her.

>>713810448
I don't even know what NEO TWEWY is supposed to be, get Ex33

>>713807816
He had to post it two months later for the praise to die down. What a fag

>>713807625 (OP)
>Does it still deserve its position as #1 rated game of all time?
It's not.
>B-but my metacritic user scores
Those are easily manipulated.

I'm sure it's great but I'll never spend hours of my life playing glorified geometry dash

>>713809925
Demon's Souls is literally the perfect videogame

>>713810693
https://www.resetera.com/threads/backloggd-releases-its-official-list-of-the-top-100-games-of-all-time-according-to-its-users-as-of-today-anyhow.1229301/

Cope

>>713807625 (OP)
No, it's just 2025's top because every other game released in 2025 so far was either mediocre or dogshit
This isn't even particularly good anyway

>>713807625 (OP)
Yes.

>>713808219
>I'm not sure if it's shills or just the fact that most zoomies have literally never played a JRPG before.
I played quite a bit of JRPGs, all (or almost all) the classics and a good amount of the more niche stuff and E:33 is comfortably among the top of the genre

It is not a 10/10 game, but it has 10/10 characters, story and immersion.

>>713810598
Not making a strong case that the E33 hype isn't entirely people who don't actually have any JRPG experience at all

>>713812021
I'm fairly certain this is the case.
It's the RPG for people that hates RPGs

>>713807625 (OP)
finished it this afternoon. act 3 was a mess, just like bg3 on release. still highly recommended.

>>713810529
I felt people cocksucking E33 and how deep it is were just like those idiots unironically claiming you need a very high IQ to understand Rick and Morty. And E33 really does fall apart after Act 2 and just retorts to masturbatory "sad deep derp" shit and dry unengaging writing. Maybe I'm too bitter and harsh about it but that's only because I really wanted to love this game since the moment it was first announced.

>>713811742
Nah, it's for fake fans of the genre. Surface level similarities while being very steamlined and digestible. It's like when Takahashifags pretend Xenoblade 2 is just like classic old 90s shounen, or Imaishifags pretend to like old mecha anime.

>>713813314
Jarpigs are the epitome of streamlined zoomzoom.

>>713813373
>zoomzoom
Stop trying so hard, underage thirdie. I play more games than you across all genres.

>>713807625 (OP)
I keep thinking its recency bias but another week goes by and I still think about the game. Easily one of the best I've ever played. Chink lovers raging so hard is just a bonus.

>>713809084
Except you can just look at Final Fantasy 1, which isn’t exactly hardcore for a classic RPG and it still has those aspects. If you die in a dungeon, you have to do it all over again. You don’t get easy free healing, free replenishable potions or anything like that. Even in old games that do allow you to save anywhere, you don’t typically get that stuff, at least not baked into the games systems on a core level.

>>713810178
Very wrong.
Sekiro is their best game and its 7.5/10
Bloodborne has objective problems like frame stutter and its gameplay gets lame so fast, no good bosses and level design becomes bad in 2nd half.
DS1 is clunky, has bad gameplay, is too easy and the 2nd half is unfinished

E33 is way better than any Fromsoft game.
E33 has no flaws and its gameplay and bosses are better with even better music and thousand times better story and characters

>>713815998
>>713810178
You both are smoking crack

>>713807816
>Schreier