>>713888189 (OP)
I've only played two but he makes boring games with mediocre stories and some good points here and there. Both Detroit and Heavy Rain have decent concepts but both fumble at making sense of important plot twists, the games practically lie to the player and contradicts themselves several times for the main plot twists to work and even then it doesn't make much sense. There are even plot points that are completely out of place and make no sense at all like the psychic stuff because it was leftovers from an old script that Cage didn't bother modifying.
But I think the bigger problem with his games is that he's not creative. There are better ways to tell stories than with QTEs and simon says. There are more ways to present a cinematic than trying to emulate western movies. The poor writing isn't even the main problem, it's the fact that it's written by a pseudo-intellectual that is trying to grab an audience of normalfags using the most conventional methods of storytelling in the medium. People meme him as a Kojima-like figure but in reality he's more like Sam Lake, Kojima at least subverted expectations multiple times throughout his games and used the features of the medium (like buttonmashing in the MGS1 torture scene) to actually convey the emotions of the characters to the player. Cage's characters are just completely flat because that's what his games are, flat and boring.
