What's the worst demake of all time?

Silent Hill 2 was much more egregious.

>>713989805 (OP)
>ubisoft open world
>Cloud is still a grunting cringe piece of shit
>a lot of boring fillers
>the military was unbearable and not even remotely believable
this game is truly the word Demake

>>713989805 (OP)
>ubisoft open world
>Cloud is still a grunting cringe piece of shit
>a lot of boring fillers
>the military was unbearable and not even remotely believable
this game is truly the word Demake

>>713990161
*the military parade
goddammit

>>713990007
Haven't played it yet but from what i saw it turns the levels into combat arenas or something.

I can't speak to much else, but Re3make butchered Jill's character to a headspinning degree. Generic PS4 protagonist woman has bsolutely nothing in common with the actual character

>>713990161
>first game gives you the biggest dicktease in history by keeping the opening cutscene from the original where Cloud steps off the train, leading you to believe it will be a faithful remake
Told me everything I needed to know when it took so fucking long to get to Don Corneo in the remake

>>713989805 (OP)
RE3 Remake was terrible but RE4 Remake was worse.
RE2 Remake was tolerable, RE1 Remake was quite good but the original is still better.

>>713989805 (OP)
You posted it. R3make is Re3 turned into a theme park ride which sucks because besides that it is one of the better videogame depictions of a city experiencing an apocalyptic event.
>At the start of the game, the city is in absolute chaos as fires force civillians out onto the streets right into the hands of the growing zombie hordes
>Helicopters in the sky. Gunshots everywhere. PSA's blaring over the speakers trying to bring some semblence of order to the chaos.
>After the nemesis rooftop fight (which was cool but i hate how you run up the building so fast you don't even notice you're in the OG's newspaper office), you find yourself in the street behind the RPD and the city is absolutely quiet
>All of the chaos which ravaged through the city a few hours ago is gone. Only a few scattered survivors still remain, police radios still lighting up with the occasional chatter from patrols who haven't realized that command has already collapsed
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DjPM8om2Eyw
>Did you enjoy those four and a half minutes of excellent atmosphere? We hope you did because SIKE HERE'S ANOTHER SCRIPTED NEMESIS CHASE DO YOU LIKE HOW WE COMPLETELY GUTTED HIM????
I hate how much I love the few parts of this game which were actually good.

>>713990007
Amen to that. I actually forgot it existed, they fucked it up so much it's not even really a matter of it being good or bad, it's just a complete fucking miss that doesn't understand the original at all.
Bizarre game

>>713990846
They wanted a TLOU audience filled with women

The thousand year for remake was intolerable.

Warcraft III reforged?

>>713989805 (OP)
Persona 4 R

>>713990681
Nemesis was always entirely scripted. He would only show up at specific places at specific times. You were also supposed to beat him like a pinata for goodies.

>>713989805 (OP)
re3 was my fav original and was gonna ask why you's didnt like it but after reading >>713990681
like wow. so glad i havent spent a dime on any of these remakes

>>713989805 (OP)
Capcom always does this tho. When they remake a game they always completely change or just straight up remove the one central aspect that made it great.

>re1 change pic related to "give barry his gun? y/n"
>re2 no b scenarios and no zapping system
>re3 no rng, live selection or branching events
RE4 is the only game that got the proper treatment.

>>713989805 (OP)
definitely the one that opened my eyes at how horrible nu-capcom had become. shame those fucking niggers ruin games when they get greedy, even dd2 and mhw suffered for it

>>713992440
RE1make still has different events happen depending on your choices. The Barry y/n is the exception.

>>713992724
Like what? Richard? He dies anyway. Saving Becca? Same as in the OG. Everything else is the same.

tony hawk by robomodo and it's not even close

>>713992910
Yes?

You posted it OP.
>You start at the train already skipping about 30% of the game
>City segment is short
>Power station area is absolutely terrible with a gimmicky enemy
>Nemesis goes down to a single grenade
>Clock tower entirely skipped
>Park skipped
>Final nemmy battle is a putrid pile of shit with push the levers gameplay to fire the giant railgun that Jill can somehow lift easily
And don't even get me started on Nu Jill's personality.
And now all new Jill porn is ruined because its the ugly remake 3 one.

>>713993091
Richard makes up for >>713992440 ?

>>713991891
>Nemesis was always entirely scripted. He would only show up at specific places at specific times.
I'm fairly sure he could show up at random sometimes too, but even if I'm wrong about that, he still appeared more often than he does in the remake. Making him so scripted was a massive step back after they already made X a persistent stalker in 2's remake. What made Nemesis so cool in OG 3 was how intimidating the idea of being hunted by him was, the fact he'd chase you through multiple rooms, etc.He should have gotten the same treatment as X. Reducing him to scripted encounters was incredibly lame.

>>713989805 (OP)
XIII. Nothing else compares.

>>713993214
No, everything else is the same except for the way Barry dies/survives.

>>713992724
It also cuts half of Rebecca's interactions because you can't meet her in the serum room anymore.

>>713993587
>except for the branching events of jills story

>>713993927
Are you rage baiting? The branching events are still here. The shotgun room, the bee room, forest, first zombie,...

>>713994163
And the only thing that affects the ending is whether you give barry his gun back.

>>713994410
Also if you save Chris or not.

>>713989805 (OP)
Re3 demake
Re4 demake
sh2 demake

>>713991891
His encoutners in the remake are much more limited, and the few where he can follow you for a short time between different spots are trivialized by a single grenade. A number of his enounters like the highrise before his first true boss fight is just a chase and his rocket launcher sequence is a single alleyway where you dodge it followed by another 1 area where he tries to crush jill and chases her to the gas station to get blown up in a cutscene and then another single room/hallway where jill gives her you want stars line before slipping into the sewers. The encounters don't have the same sense of a battle with him than just booking it to the next cutscene and safe zone. Then before you know it he is a dog monster for the second half of the game what I remember being 2 similar arena fights with the seconding adding in some zombies and an enviormental hazard to help fight him + him getting a few new attacks. Then you have the final blob fight which is a dodge fest waiting for the super weapon but on inferno with no coins you basically get either 1 hit killed or stumbled to then get one hit killed meaning you have to perfect the fight from start to finish. The RNG acid spray makes it even more annoying. It's a step down from his last blob/dog form in the original.a04nt

>>713994410
Ok i haven't played RE1 in a while and looking at it now there are more endings in the OG. But REmake is still an excelent experience that improves on the gameplay.

>>713991891
In Ps1 original he shows up at scripted moments (although there’s way more and a bunch of mutually exclusive depending on how you’ve progressed) but the key difference is that in Ps1 game when he shows up nothing else changes, you still have to complete whatever objective you were doing, just now Nemisis is after you while you do it. You can run from him until he leaves (but doing this causes surprise spawns in a ton of possible locations) or you can fight him, which is extremely difficult but gives rewards.

Remake when he appears the only objective you have is “run forwards along linear path” there’s one tiny section at beginning where you can technically go find some collectibles while he’s chasing you, and technically fight him, but you shoudve already grabbed those collectible anyway, and they are super optional even if you didn’t, and by “fight Nemisis” I mean throw a singke grenade at him. It’s also possible to have proper fight, but why the fuck would you when a singke grenade does same job as all your bullets? And after that first encounter every future Nemisis encounter is either a scripted “run forwards through hallway with nothing else to do” or a boss fight where you have no choice to fight him.

>>713992440
Wtf i've been told forever that re1 was the perfect remake so that's the only way i've played it. Is the original actually better?

>>713992440
Another remake change is that the Plant 42 outcomes are simplified. Barry always shows up with the flamethrower if you use the V Jolt on the roots, so you can kill it without firing a single shot. If you don't use it, you have to fight both phases.

>>713995404
No. Its just typical /v/ contrarians.
The OG Resident Evil is just a novelty, good for a playthrough to see how it all started but the remake is better in every single way.

>>713994723
>his first true boss fight
It's also really dumb that they threw those mandatory damage sponge fights at you
Sure there were a few times in the original where you had to fight him (IIRC, the clock tower yard; protecting Jill on the return from the hospital; the waste room with the acid pipes; and then the final encounter with the beam cannon) but those encounters didn't feel like they fucked with the flow of the game so much.
Not only is it much less interesting to have these set piece fights instead of a persistent threat, It makes resource management boring too because they make him a massive fucking damage sponge but then they just give you tons of ammo immediately before/during the fight anyway.

>>713995404
>>713995601
>>713994741
REmake is, all in all, the better game but it did turn the mansion from a proper 1960s modern art villa(which it apparently is supposed to be) that looks like it was recently abandoned into a 100 year old mansion that has been empty for decades.

>>713995042
>but the key difference is that in Ps1 game when he shows up nothing else changes, you still have to complete whatever objective you were doing, just now Nemisis is after you while you do it.
>Remake when he appears the only objective you have is “run forwards along linear path”
That's a really good point anon. I didn't think of it that way, but that's why his implementation in the remake sucks so much.
That's a very important element in that it gives you the feeling of being harassed and hunted instead of just having the occasional scripted Nemesis scene.

>>713995404
I personally like the original better. It's a fairly close race, but it flows better without the nonsense they added to the remake, and your character choice affects the early game more substantially, because Jill can open some doors Chris can't.
It also feels less sluggish to control, and imo, as beautiful as the graphics in the remake are, the mansion is a bit more interesting and ironically creepy in the original because it actually has some color in it.

>>713995601
>remake is better in every single way
People who say this don't understand what thy're talking about.
I understand preferring the remake but there are some things the original does better.

>>713995404
RE1 remake is better by far. Whoever says that OG Re1 is better than remake is a contrarian faggot or didn't even play the game. OG Re1 aged very badly. RE1 remake is better than the original in every single aspect

>>713997961
>RE1 remake is better than the original in every single aspect
see >>713997961 and realize that what you view as contrarianism is in fact people understanding the game better than you do

>>713997961
>>713998183
I meant to say "see >>713997068"
I made an embarrassing blunder but I am still correct about your lack of understanding.

>>713989805 (OP)
REmake 3 absolutely MOGS Demake 2 and 4 THO

>>713995404
The music in the original is definitely better. It's synth heavy and straight out of a 90s horror movie vs. the forgettable ambient slop in the remake.

>>713998446
I prefer the remake but I'm 100% with you on this one, all the remakes fucked the music, especially Remake 2.

>>713989805 (OP)
RE3 remake is definitely up there, considering how good the original is.
Adding more to what most anons already mentioned regarding the RE3 remake.
>Nu-Jill design and personality
>No Clock Tower and Park maps
>No mercenaries mode
>"You want STARS??.." line completely ruined by mentioned it earlier in the game killed it.
Overall way shorter than the original. It actually felt like a DLC from RE2 remake.

>>713995404
They both have their merit. I think the RE1 remake tries too hard at some points, between a bunch of the lit candles and shit making the atmosphere seem a bit too unbelievable at times. I think the corny cutscenes in the OG 1 add a fair bit, but there are some almost equally as corny cutscenes in the remake as well. Crimson Heads are an amazing mechanic though, and it adds a level of tension that has yet to be paralleled in the rest of the series.

RE1 also has the benefit of Arranged mode

>>713991752
This, you can't even play the original because of it.

>>713996275
>>713995042
Nemesis was annoying as fuck in the original, so I'm fine with him only being specific parts. Just like how Mr.X was annoying in the 2 remake while not in the OG for the opposite reason

>>713999808
>Crimson Heads are an amazing mechanic though
I agree, but I'm surprised to see someone else express this opinion
I thought I was the only person on the planet who prefers the original RE (or is, at least, willing to criticize the remake) but still loves the Crimson Heads. Nice to know I'm not alone!

>>714000328
>This, you can't even play the original because of it.
Well technically you can if you can find it, but I get your point anon. Remasters/remakes causing the originals to become unavailable is disgusting

>>713997961
>RE1 remake is better than the original in every single aspect
The original is more violent.

>>713998446
>It's synth heavy and straight out of a 90s horror movie
Specifically the 1990 NOTLD remake. The mansion also feels a lot like the house in that version.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pTp6A1SxtCo

>>713990161
awful combat too fraid so

>>713998332
>>713997068
You didn't even make any points literally just
>PEOPLE WHO SAY THIS DON'T KNOW WHAT THEY ARE TALKING ABOUT
>THERE ARE TOTALLY THINGS THAT THE ORIGINAL DOES BETTER YEP
Like?
>W-WELL HOW ABOUT [repost of a meme image "comparison"]
>U-UH I-IT JUST IS BETTER IN A LOT OF WAYS REALLY

God I hate remakes. They come along, shit up my nostalgia and sour my day.

>>713989805 (OP)
It’s this abomination and nothing else comes close.

>>714000875
Yeah, a lot of people bitch that crimson heads are tedious or stressful, but they are supposed to be. It adds another layer of horror and preparation, especially since classic RE1 especially gives you way too much ammo

>>713990007
Silent Hill 2 remake was fine
t. silent hill enjoyer since 1999

>>714005425
but where be spooks?