>>714538703 (OP)GCN. What a stupid question.
>>714538783Why is it stupid? I thought people liked the wii version because the motion controls make it smoother to play
>>714539103the wii version is for chad original hardware users and the gcn version is for poors who can only emulate
>>714539103You can only appreciate those controls after becoming acquainted with the original.
>>714539247That being said the switch version is more or less identical to the wii version except higher res
>>714539803You dont mean that anon, you just like pikmin 1 a whole lot and got caught up in your emotions. we both like the game
>>714538703 (OP)I think all 3 of them are fine. motion controls on wii are definitely nice, and presumably the switch has them too, but gyro aiming is always a little more finicky than a nice pointer. pikmin 2 is the only one where the switch version isn't great because of odd censorship and expired licensing stuff, but even then that's fairly minor
>>714539247or someone older than 20 or who has like 500 bucks lying around.
>1
GCN = WII < SWITCH
>2
GCN > WII > SWITCH
>3
WII U > SWITCH
>4
SWITCH (2!!!1)
>>714538703 (OP)Switch has all the Pikmin games (except for the 3DS game and mobile "game" nobody likes or cares about). And 3 was fixed for Switch 2. Pikmin 4 might be rereleased within a year for a "Switch 2 Edition".
>>714538703 (OP)If you're willing to play romhacks, Pikmin Squared. Otherwise Switch unless you REALLY like the Wii pointer controls.
>>714538703 (OP)The Switch re-release isn't bad. I played it.
Gamecube was fine though.
>>714546357yea but its new and new is bad though?????
>>714538703 (OP)I had fun with the Wii version but desu any version will do. Timeless game (s)
Original is best, wii version has easier controls but worse combat for it and a ton of unacceptable bugs, like Pikmin falling through the floor and randomly dying. Switch version is better than the Wii version but replaced all the brand items with generic items, which is surprisingly worse but not by much. The controls in switch are debately worse/better so it's hard to say.
1 and 2 are great games though so however you can, it's worth playing
>>714542394Switch version is censored and has worse gameplay implementation. It's the worst version
>>714538703 (OP)Wii version has better throw and that is it, but the Switch is the same version as the Wii.
Switch version removes brand names and censors gendered language in the collections
>NOOO MY HECKING CORPORATE BRANDS
The final boss sucks on the original controls. Never played the others.
1 and 2 on Dolphin with mouse and keyboard
3 with the true spice mod on Ryujinx
4 on Ryujinx
Source: I've replayed all of them recently
>>714543651 Yeah, but it still kinda sucks that Pikmin 2 lost the charm of the real-world branding. Seeing a Duracell battery or a Pepsi cap made the world feel weirdly grounded in reality. Now it's just "Energy Cell" and "Fizzy Lid" or whatever. Still, for accessibility and just having everything in one place, Switch is hard to beat. Just a shame about the little things being scrubbed.
>>714538703 (OP)Wii for the first two. Wii U for 3 (this is important, you need the gamepad)
>>714549207NINTENDO, THIS ANON IS PIRATING PIKMIN. TAKE THEM OUT!!!
>>714551514You really donโt need the gamepad. The switch port proved that it works perfectly without it.
>>714551821it's not zelda so nintendo don't care
>>714538972>>714547372Squared feels janky in its own way which is funny cause the whole point was to make it less janky
Louieโs quest is still cool
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hUPYDkiu6Lg
>>714538703 (OP)dolphin
think you can play the wii version with mouse controls
if not, then play the gamecube version
>>714538703 (OP)Wii has the fun bonus of being able to throw Pikmin further with removes the need for Yellows on particular pieces.