Why exactly couldn't a single subsequent mascot horror game surpass the original FNAF?

>>714651138 (OP)
that one furby game did a decent job the difference is that the devs didn't try to milk the series.

the issue is that those who try it put the cart before the horse. so the stories are non-existent but at the same time the reason this shit bevame popular is because of the story.

>>714651349
Tattletail?

>>714651138 (OP)
>just right
>acary for adults
i find it sexy though

>>714651465
yeah that's the one.

>>714651138 (OP)
>scary for adults
1)fiction isn't scary, ever
2) that's just horny art. there is no way that isn't meant to arouse.

>>714651138 (OP)
The creator was always good at making stuff that was unintentionally creepy, and applied that to fnaf
Everyone else is trying too hard

>>714651608
>>714651513
the rightmost one is obviously drawn by a furry degenerate who's never seen an actual animatronic back in the day
made a quick edit to show what they actually looked like

>>714651138 (OP)
fuck fuck marry fuck

>>714652538
Yeah, the idea for FNAF came to him after reading scathing reviews for his failed children's mobile game chipper & son's lumber co. where a reviewer said that the design of the main character looked like a creepy chuck e. cheese's animatronic
Though he WAS already making creepy robotic designs in the desolate hope, which came before chipper

>>714652615
based chucke cheese enjoyer

>>714652615
It doesn't look like furshit. It actually does like something one of those old mascot brands would've use back in the day, just not like one of their animatronics. Its too stylized. Its the kind cartoon they'd have on their marketing material.

>>714652615
Based drawfag

>>714652615
Both are whores

>>714651138 (OP)
Red guy looks like an absolute riot, I'd love to see more of him. Goofy + scary is the best combination (see Pennywise). Weed dragon looks too stoned to want to be dangerous. I bet he sounds like Tommy Chong.

I'd definitely play a game with both of them in it.

>>714653162
Red guy would do great as a Smiling Reddit character
I like smiling friends

>>714651138 (OP)
I dunno but I think there needs to be 5th one in this group that is
>Too... Wait a minute you are just showing off your fetish to children and masking it as horror!

>>714653591
I thought grey guy looked like Smiling Friends character
>spoiler
You don't have to hate things just because they're popular anon. Some people would act like drinking water is bad because reddit did it.

>>714651138 (OP)

>>714652615
Left is a character I'd see from a 90s cartoon and right would be the animatronic of said character.

>>714651138 (OP)
ah yes
the 4 chaos gods
blue, grey, red and green

>>714653965
left is a 90s kids show character, right is the modern cgi remake.

>>714651138 (OP)
I've never really been on Newgrounds, but the red guy is just the average NG OC.

>>714651138 (OP)
where is the one that is clearly made for porn

>>714653934
He looks like he lives by the sea and frolics in the autumn mist.

>>714657139
If by the sea you mean a shitty neighborhood near LA and by autimn mist you mean him hotboxing the bathroom in the 7/11 he works at, then sure.

>>714652615

>>714651138 (OP)
yeah, "just right" is for furries. idk something about scott's original fnaf1 models, it was clear he wasn't in it for the furry bait (that came later)

>80s kids games: normal mascot
>90s kids games: too cool for school mascot
>2000s kids games: edgy mascot
>2010s kids games: killer mascot
What’s the next logicial step

>>714661610
Safe horny mascot

>>714662302
>geargrit
>pseudoregalia
>lightspeed lina
Pretty sure there are some other ones too but yeah this does seem to be becoming a genre of sorts

>>714652615
righto still doesnt stop me, you are right about it obviously being furshit though

>>714651138 (OP)
Fuck your mascot horror. Give me 2, but make him darker, thinner, slightly transparent and remove the whites from his eyes.

>>714662985
That's an awfully specific fetish you have, anon

>>714652615
>I just made it sexier
Task failed successfully.

>>714663257
I'm describing something that unsettled me around two nights ago.

Red guy looks like a one night at flumpty’s character

>>714651138 (OP)
You can't stay scared of something forever, Fnaf 1 did it first and it did it good enough.
No matter how much you improve on it, it'll still give diminishing returns.

>>714652682
Desolate Room/Hope is peak Scott.

>>714665708
He has an incredible knack for mechanical designs and I'm surprised I haven't seen many people recreate it, he's like the sole representative of a whole artstyle and he's already retired

>>714651138 (OP)
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MWF-39qPi8o
FNAF is a reference to the Rockafire Explosion whereas a lot of these copycats are a reference to Five Nights, a copy of a copy, the first copy over emphasizes certain aspects in order to pump up the design but then the copy does this again resulting in a kind of flanderization due to iteration.
And I am basing this entirely on nothing.

>>714652615
It's the bedroom eyes.

>>714661610
Pedophile mascots.

>>714651608
>1)fiction isn't scary, ever
*unless it's a black person in a bideo game

>>714661610
>>714662302
This.

Imagine some fat fluffy female dragon mascot that makes fun of her weight and size just a little too much to where you suspect she gets off on being so big.

>>714651138 (OP)
>mascot horror game
terrible