Do you prefer silent Isaac or FUCK SHIT FUCK Isaac?

Reminder that EA forced 3 to be a co-op bro shooter and still wasn’t satisfied because it didn’t sell 10 gorillion copies so they killed the franchise and obliterated the studio and then 10 years later they cobbled together a bunch of nobodies to make a pozzed remake of the first game for some quick cash and then got rid of those poor bastards too and killed the franchise again.

>>715026613 (OP)
Silent, I don't need another Leon from RE quipping about being full of bad ideas.

Dead Space 1 is probably the best over-the-shoulder action horror game out there. Definitely better than RE4.

I was fine with both DS1, DS2 and Remake Issac. But DS1 definitely allowed me to be more immersed.

voiced
gunner wright is a pretty good VA for isaac and his voice sounds cool through the filter, glad they brought him back for the remake and also never again fuck EA

>>715027228
Gameplay wise, it lacks the depth compare to RE4.

But it does the horror and exploration aspects far better that RE4.

I love RE4 for its replayability. I like dead space for the experience.

Silent Isaac made no sense in the first game.

Still spookier than any of the silly monsters in Dead Space.

>>715031648
>grey guy with monster teeth
Resident Evil kids really never grew the fuck up.

>>715031736
timmy tough knuckles over here

>>715031648
nah

>>715031736
>>715031736


14 year old me shit my pants at this

>>715026613 (OP)
Both DS1 and 2 are good.

>>715031925
more disgusting looking does not mean spookier.

>>715026613 (OP)
If you're making a very story heavy game, with tons of voiced dialogue and characters constantly talking to you, making the protagonist a fucking mute is always the dumbest shit. He needs to talk back in some capacity at least.

Feels weird calling it a horror game when every enemy drops more ammo for me to effortlessly slaughter them with

I prefer him talking because it was too autistic the way everyone talked to him in 1 and he didn't answer back

>>715032508
you'd shit your pants in fear if you saw that thing moving in a dark alleyway

This things guttural howl and how it ran at me in the mining basement is easily one of the scariest things in video games besides some System Shock 2 monsters and Abstract Daddy

The only thing I didn't like about remake was the changes to Mercer, from religious zealot to some b tier horror movie villain. Also the voice change was unnecessary and I say this only cause the original actor was kino in Legion

>>715034527
The Mercer and Hammond changes are just blatantly worse than the original. A shame, because as a whole it was an ok enough remake.

>>715034825
>Hammond changes
Hammonds guilt and death by "Chen" is the only part of DSR that was improved. He went from dying to generic boss I fought once to someone who I did care about, and whose death actually meant more than "I got killed by crab"
DS1 is a better game but Hammond was an improvement

>>715035396
Oh sure that stuff is ok. I'm mainly speaking on the level of voice actor quality and model changes

Isaac gaining a voice meant he went from having to be constantly told what to do by the characters who could actually announce the problems for the player's informing to being able to take charge and initiative himself because that can come all from his mouth instead. Hence I think it was a good change