Is this accurate SMT chads?

>>715423986 (OP)
P5 should be much lower.

only hipsters and jeets like DDS

>My favorite SMT non-mainline? Digital Devil Saga 1 & 2 of course.

>brownoid meme
kek

Drop Persona 3 to a 90%, replace Persona 3-4 with Devil Survivor games

>>715423986 (OP)
P2 is fucking garbage. Innocent Sin had decent story, absolutely garbage gameplay even for its time. Eternal Punishment had way better gameplay (at least some difficulty) but the writing is nowhere near as good as Innocent Sin.

persona 3 was 60% running around doing tedious chores that you don't even do you just pick an option from a menu then watch a 5 second scene of you doing it, 30% talking to children, and 10% running around in a dungeon with party members that constantly fuck you over
it's a really bad visual novel and barely a game

>>715424243
>persona 3 was 60% running around doing tedious chores that you don't even do you just pick an option from a menu then watch a 5 second scene of you doing it, 30% talking to children, and 10% running around in a dungeon with party members that constantly fuck you over
Persona 2 is the only game in the series with actual gameplay

>>715423986 (OP)
Not bad, i'd go: DDS2 > DeSu1>Persona 2 IS > Persona 2 EP > DDS1 > SMT VV > SMT III > SMT II > SMT IV > SMT SJ > Persona 4 > Persona 3 > Persona 5

>>715424465
metaphor was ok
very childish but it wasn't awful

>>715424616
SJ is better than Nocturne easily, otherwise this is fine. Vengeance could have been the best since Devil Survivor if it wasn't open world and had more interesting enviroments

>>715423986 (OP)
There's literally no motherfucking way Vengeance is worse than Nocturne and SJ

>>715423986 (OP)
All these games are garbage except P3-4-5 and I'm tired of people pretending that is not the case.

I'm playing SMTV and that game is RNG bullshit that promotes save scumming. Even the game itself tells you to save often. Early on you just play Simon Says targeting weakness and then on second half you go full monkey with physical and that is all there is to it. Story is garbage, characters are garbage but music is decent and the only good thing about the game.

Before SMTV I beat YS X and low key is better than all of these games, except P3-4-5.

>>715423986 (OP)
>persona and avatar tuner
>SMT

>>715423986 (OP)
no, remove persona and add smt 2 and soul hackers

>>715423986 (OP)
Drop all personas by maybe 20% and then yeah. Also dds1>2

>>715423986 (OP)
Where are all the other smt games, why is dds on a list of smt games. Why are shitsonas even there. Brown hands created that image

>>715425604
Just say you’re tasteless

>>715425604
>I'm playing SMTV and that game is RNG bullshit that promotes save scumming.
I have literally never save scummed in vv kek. It's the most open ended game in terms of how it allows you to build your party and how creative you can get
>All these games are garbage except P3-4-5
Nevermind, you're just allergic to gameplay

>>715425604
>Early on you just play Simon Says targeting weakness and then on second half you go full monkey with physical and that is all there is to it.
If this is the case, why do you still struggle and savescum?

>>715423986 (OP)
Fuck no.

DDS2 is infinitely worse than DDS1. P1 and P2 are also super mediocre. The rest are fine, although I'd put VV, Nocturne, SJ, DDS1 and IV over P3-P5

>>715423986 (OP)
These aren't smt rankings. These are incomplete megaten rankings. If you're going to rank them all then dds 1 should be above 2. Persona 3-5 should be within 60-75% range and you're missing a ton of smt games

>>715423986 (OP)
>persona 3 at 94
sorry but that game is liquid dog shit, it’s boring as fuck, poorly paced, every dungeon is the same, bosses are just bigger normal looking enemies, structure is fucking shit
The music and menus are nice tho, but we need to stop pretending it’s a good game because some faggots played it on the ps2 when they were 15 and the message of the game made them cry and think or something

>>715423986 (OP)
Both Persona 2s are way too fucking high. Dogshit games

>>715429062
P 3-5 are all basically the same game with little to no deviation that live off of vibes and ost with little to no user input. They're all dogshit

DDS is carried entirely by its aesthetic and music but its a fucking shit game to play, a chore frok start to finish with some of the laziest boring dungeons ever.

>>715429186
This but for all personas. Worst part about dds was encounter rate

>>715429169
Persona 5 at least had the metaverse and every dungeon had unique gimmicks, still i enjoyed it, but i can’t imagine replaying these fucking games

>>715423986 (OP)
Can we stop pretending persona 2 and nocturne are good games? Most of you faggots haven’t played them

>>715423986 (OP)
But 4 is the worst in the series.

>>715429325
Worst part of 5 was being able to beat every dungeon in 1 day and then you're just back to either watching social links or, even worse, crawling mementos.

>>715429528
>dogshit dungeons if you can even call them that
>fun story
>smirk is great
>str, mag, luck all great with their own unique styles
>making good demons is easy
>great music
can't complain too much

>>715429410
I beat nocturne on ps2 and am replaying hd currently with quality of death mod. It's fantastic then and it's fantastic now

Strange Journey should be highest, but DDS duology is a solid choice. Only Persona that should be close is 3 FES. Vanilla 4 is also acceptable. All else need to be well towards the bottom.

>>715423986 (OP)
I know this bait and is missing most games but was anyone else disappointed with soul hackers 1? I loved the atmosphere but demon loyalty system basically pushed for me to always use 'go'

>>715423986 (OP)
Nah. SMT4 Apocalypse should be #1

>>715429410
I played P2 IS only for Jun. 10/10 game

>>715423986 (OP)
VV>SJ>Nocturne>DDS Part 1>SMT IV>P5=P3>P4>DDS Part 2>P1>P2 IS