>this terrified millions in 2013

Pretty scary

Funny fact: For a certain period of time, Sonic.exe was considered such a shitty and low-quality creepypasta, that it was deleted from the "official" creepypasta wiki and moved to a "fanmade OC" creepypasta wiki

>this terrified trillions in 2009

>>715811206
Long long ago this was my wallpaper on PSP.

>>715810856 (OP)
>AND THEN YOU KNOW

>>715810856 (OP)
All creepypasta material was peak faggotry to me

EAT
YOUR
ARRM

>>715810856 (OP)
HYPER
REALISTIC
BLOOD

>>715811357
SCP was an interesting and novel concept in the beginning but very quickly turned into shit.

>>715810856 (OP)
The Freezer in Saints Row 2 that bricks your console is the best creepypasta because it's actually real.

>>715811206
gave boners to trillions*

>>715811651
That's disproven.

>>715811206
>Tails is just pissed his evil Eggman clone is a shitty doll with a a shitty creepy story and not a based metal version

I know it's not exactly a rare trope to make "le children's character is actually le heckin eldrich monster" but does this sonic shit really just stem mostly from that weird sonic CD easter egg?

>>715811651
i'm happy no one has deboonked this yet. now content farmers snipe stuff like this before they can even become a thing.

>>715811163
was anybody ever actually scared by it? it's the most low effort thing I've ever seen as far as creepy pasta goes, and the entire idea was already like 10 years too old.

>>715811748
>mysterious and unexplained doll instead of an eternal jobber faggot like Metal Shitnic
Sounds based to me.

>>715811520
I wonder what was the point where it turned to shit? If only there was some defining change to the website that could clue me in...

>>715810856 (OP)
Man, I know I'm gonna get hit with "You must be over 18 to post here", but I miss the late 2000s and early 2010s

>>715811985
>I wonder what was the point where it turned to shit?
SCP 3000 and beyond

>>715810856 (OP)
Millions of retarded children?

>>715811651
>>715811730
>>715811869
While there is some evidence to suggest the actual silhouette is a real glitch relating to console memory/map load issues there's nothing to suggest it has any impact on your disk or Xbox beyond what any other hard crash would have.