>Tails, Knuckles and Shadow have had their own game.
>Amy has been around since nearly the beginning of the franchise and still has no game of her own
Pitch some ideas for an official Amy Rose game.

>>715898856 (OP)
Fuck off retard

Nobody except the bottom-of-the-barrel fans of the franchise genuinely cares for Amy Rose.

>>715898856 (OP)
It plays just like a normal sonic game, but you play as Amy, and between stages you get to do girly things in the hub world.

>>715899087
Calm down, edgelord. Just because you can mash your greasy fingers on a keyboard doesn’t mean you gotta seethe every time someone brings up Amy. A character getting her due after 30+ years ain't exactly heresy. Pitch an idea or hit the bricks.

>>715899186
Amy rose has been habitually mislocalized. Sonic has too, but it's more noticeable on Amy.

NOT UNTIL THEY FUCKING RESTORE ROUGE'S DESIGN!!!

Love interests will never get their own game. Because their motivations and goals or personality are saddled to the MC. Knuckles doesn't need Sonic to thrive, you can easily bullshit some more Echidna lore or Master Emerald heist shenanigans. Tails can do his own thing too. But Amy? Her goal is to catch Sonic and convince him to marry her. Shes somehow a 13 year old who can summon magic mallets and smash robots to bits in fits of anger, but they don't do much else with her past that.

>>715899524
Make a game about her catching the Hedgehog. Even if it's a dream.

I don't want Amy to get a game unless a group of talented developers decide they specifically want to make a game about her because they have some cool idea for it.

And even then I don't wanna see that shit unless it's written in-house or they keep people like Ian Flynn the hell away from it. Don't need kids to be dealing with his mealy mouthed shit in their Minnie Mouse game.

It's 2025, any game she gets would just be a feminist pander-fest about how Amy is LE STRONK WOMYN WHO DON'T NEED NO MAN

no thanks

Amy can't carry a game unless it's specifically a weird ass game, and Sega cares too much about making Sonic mass market friendly to take big risks anymore. She's decent protagonist material, but she's so wrapped up in Sonic that he has to be focal for a game starring her to work.

If Sonic isn't there, she's just boring and we're staying away from the point of the character. If Sonic is there, it's usually better to make a Sonic game and have Amy be a player option.

>>715900228
Superstars had Trip as its focal character and her whole deal was being a friendly klutz. Amy even got a nice scene of being gal pals with her. People really overstate stuff like this: it's more that big budget stuff tries to skew that way.

>>715900458
The issue is that the power to decide lore and story-direction of Sonic at the moment was given to xhem

>>715900923
I can't think of anything Evan's done so far with the girls that's bad. Shit, she actually lets Amy be girly and dote on Sonic, unlike Ian. Feels like a handful of people just shit on her because of her politics instead of the actual stuff she makes.

>>715898856 (OP)
Luigi's mansion but Amy. Give her her playstyle from adventure 1 and have her wander around a set of horror themed open zone areas leading to a few levels each. A spooky forest, an old decrepit mansion, then a secret underground eggman base thats torn apart and malfunctioning rather than actively hostile like his stuff normally is. Have the enemies be weird goopy ghost like creatures that poses busted mechs or trees or even animals and turn them into scary aggressive versions of themselves and attack you.
The plot is that Sonic went off to beat Eggman again in another adventure recently, but he didnt come back. And Eggman seems to be both excited that Sonic seems to be gone, but also wary of whatever happened between them. Amy gos in to try and find Sonic as she is want to do and ends up having to brave all of these scary environs on her own. Maybe running into some of the other characters making their own way around along the way.
Eventually its revealed that the adventure sonic went on was much like previous ones: Eggman tried to harness the power of some evil entity, Sonic went to stop him, but this time Eggman actually listened and realized that what he was messing with would likely destroy the world/take over his empire/etc. and should probably be left sealed... right at the last second. As a result the entity was partially unsealed, managed to capture Sonic, Eggman paniced and initated a self destruct of his base and high tailed it out of there. All the enemies Amy has been facing have been minifestations of the entities possession trying to guide her into unsealing it fully using Sonic as bait. The final boss is either a fight against Sonic's possessed body as she tries to take him back from the entity or a fight against some powerful avatar while Sonic is trapped in a magical cage or something.

True final boss can be a super sonic style boss fight where amy gets to tag team with sonic to beat it once and for all.

Amy's whole identity is "normal". She's not fast, she's not strong, she can't fly.

>>715898856 (OP)
Knuckles has never actually had his own game, the "Knuckles" in Knuckles' Chaotix was just a Western localization thing to try to sell more copies.
Anyways nobody really wants an Amy game.

The "obvious" answer would be to have a game where Sonic is captured and Amy rescues him. But they kinda killed that one already with Forces by having the entire supporting cast being useless after Sonic was captured in that game. It's not believable anyone but Shadow can function without him anymore.

>>715898856 (OP)
There's a sizeable portion of Sonic fans who don't like Amy, so you'd just be cutting your potential audience for no gain

>>715901152
She's faster and stronger than Knuckles

>>715899186
Faggotry like this is what got us into the irony-poisoned shitshow with useless supporting characters that Sonic games are now

>>715901915
I thought it was the constant mockery of anything kinda weird and the fandom insistence on being "like the old days." Plus Sega being a shithole.

>>715901039
OK, but Surge is largely her creation and she is such a "Mary Sue Insert" character I can't fucking stand it.

>>715902336
Sonic fans are their own worst enemy. Complaining about bad games and their direction but buying each and everyone. Complaining about things being too samey which leads to new changes which makes them mad, and leads to an even more sterile status quo. Can't decide on if they like or hate the comics, can't decide if Sega should burn or stay afloat to ensure their favorite rodent still exists. Its like a wolf that walked into a bear trap and after gnawing off its own leg, walked into it again but this time decided to keep the bear trap on the leg currently mangled to hell.

>>715902483
That's not even kinda true. Ian came up with them and Mauro kept pushing for Surge in particular to move out of being a Scourge copy-paste. She first wrote them like half a year after their debut.

>>715902742
>Can't decide on if they like or hate the comics
This one's a combination of a couple things. A lot of the "comic fans" are only reading Sonic for brand masturbation, so they get in conflict with the people who read them because they like comic books. The American books have been all over the place for years and a lot of the pushback in recent years is because the main creatives are stuck in a rut and refuse to actually make big changes in how they write. They'll do small concessions for a month or two, based on common criticism, but not in a way that actually addresses the issues people have.

Also a shitload of the comics opinions online are kids and autists just grabbing any good argument they see and repeating it, regardless of if it makes sense in the context of what they're talking about.

>>715902336
>Being like the old days
>Characters are hollow bastardizations of what they used to be
I would give you that if it wasn't blatantly untrue

>>715903508
Didn't say Sega delivers, just that the current state of the franchise is informed by everyone and their mom thinking "Sonic used to be cool..." for over 20 years now. That's why they do so much cheap fan service. That's why they can't come up with new shit anymore. The brand is consumed with chasing its past.

Beat em up.

As in, you just beat her up.

>>715898856 (OP)
A dating sim where she dates human men only