How am I supposed to know which one to play?

>>716328884 (OP)
You forgot Limbus Company.

gachafags never learn

Who the hells plays a fucking Madoka Magica gacha?

>>716328976
Fujoshit
>>716328884 (OP)
Uma > BA> Madoka
Even Madoka fans saying to stay away from it because it's egregiously bad as a cashgrab.

>>716328884 (OP)
lmao no one cares about meguka

>>716328884 (OP)
top is shit
middle is extremely shit
bottom is decent

The actual three horsemen of /v/ gacha is 1999, arknights and genshit
>b-but my sales reports
irrelevant

>>716329157
That madoka game is the most generous of all 3 listed easily.

It's not perfect but better than BA at least

>>716328884 (OP)
can they just let madoka die already
whats with japs and milking something popular as hard as they can
i like madoka and steins gate but theres no need to a remake and hundred of movies

>>716329153
my girlfriend but I told her even people who love madoka admit the gacha is terrible even for gacha standards

>>716329305
>That madoka game is the most generous of all 3 listed easily.
you're either retarded or shitposting
it is one of the least generous gachas you can find. They add a ton of new banners/characters and give pretty much no pulling currency
If I remember the numbers correctly it takes four years of daily login rewards for the highest rank pull

>>716329157
>Fujoshit
Explain how.

>>716329498
Gem economy is irrelevant when you get constant free rolls.

Every banner up to now has had a free daily roll, and there is currently a free TEN roll each day that contributed to the pity, which is DOUBLED

I don't know what more you could want

Why are there tourists here pretending Madoka isn't quintessential /v/core

>>716329515
Type moon games are riddled with Ikemen instead of cute girls there's nothing to explain it's a fujoshit game.

>>716328884 (OP)
well exedra and ba's dailies both take like 2 minutes each so you don't really have to pick one

>>716329498
Your impression is outdated, the game started out extremely jewish but now they've pulled back on that hard. They've given out like 200 free rolls in the past month. If anything it's concerningly generous now.

>>716330570
You haven't explained anything. There isn't a focus on male characters. It's about 50/50, actually. Are you perhaps expecting that gacha "default" to the player character interacting mostly with women?

Blue Archive has the best girls

Magia Exedra has the best story

Uma is the best mechanically

>>716330880
>no focus on male characters
>50/50
If there's any men in the game at all it's fujoshit. Only faggots and women want to roll for men in their gacha games.

>guns
>magic
>horses
pick one

>>716328884 (OP)
Exedra is fun now that they've made changes to make the game more generous.

>>716330954
I prefer Madokas girls, but mostly due to the nature of the story which makes them all feel much deeper and well written than other gachas I've played.

Both other games still beat it out if you're looking for a simpler Teenage Girl Collector

>>716331158
Alternatively, you could be rolling for reasons entirely apart from sexual attraction.

fgo forgotten...

>>716328884 (OP)
Blue Archive if you want a decent story with mediocre gameplay and develop a chibi fetish

Uma Musume is you liked spending 20 hours a week in FFXIV doing Chocobo breeding

>>716331287
FGO needs a sequel or a relaunch or something. I can't believe it still makes so much money despite feeling so awful and outdated to play.

Young girls should not drink alcohol

>>716331281
Ok so either you're a fag or a metafag either way you're choking down penis likr a fat nigger at an all you can eat buffet. It's fine you like the game but it's fujoshit none the less.

>>716332328
>hey maybe my sole reason for being here isn't because the game makes my dick twitch
>HUH YOU MUST BE A SUPER DUPER FAGGOT THEN
Projecting retards should think before they speak.

>>716332497
>plays a gacha game
>spends precious rolls on a male character instead of female
>I...i...I'm not a faggot I j..just like men ok!!!

>>716328884 (OP)
>The three horsemen of /v/ gacha
actually close but switch Madoka with Nikke.
BA and Nikke are the gacha games I see /v/ discuss the most. Uma is the current FOMO but I can see it last too

>>716332998
>precious rolls
>having to choose who to get
Sounds like you don't know anything about the gacha you're trying to shit on.

>>716334505
Nobody actually gives a shit about Nikke, it's just to jerk off to

>>716334682
>jerking off by discussing the story
weird kink

>>716334682
Anons here jerk off to Doro? I hope not

>>716329498
Girls enter the standard pool in a month and they give us free pulls and keys all the time. Like I am literally top 30 in score attack because all the shit they gave us allows me to have a team that can compete with whales.

>>716330485
Madoka ruined shaft for like a decade and made a bunch of people leave.

>>716328884 (OP)
i liked the madoka anime but the game is total garbage, do not put it on the same level as BA and uma which are top of the industry right now
no idea about the newest im@s so if you need a third entry then likely Azur Lane, everything else on the global market is pretty shit

>>716328884 (OP)
>madokafags pretending they're relevant
LMAOOOOOO

>>716328884 (OP)
>that top one
Is that the supposed "FGO KILLER"i keep hearing so much about?

Chinese and Korean gacha are so intolerably bad I almost missed out on Umamusume because I assumed they were all terrible. If not for the anime I would not have tried it and completely missed out on this excellent game.

>>716335574
Worth it

>>716335856
Uma is a jgacha

>>716335856
>i almost missed out on japanese gacha be cause ive been fed shit by chinks and gooks
???
brain issue

>>716336036
I know, which is why I'm specifically bringing up Korea and China, as most gacha spammed here is from Korea and China and its all awful. It's no wonder BA and nikke and girls frontline shower you with pulls, because the games are such unholy levels of bad that outside of pulling there is nothing of value. It's shocking really, I managed to play BA for 15 minutes before I couldn't stand it any more. It's a night and day difference between it and umamusume. Genshin was a huge piece of shit non-game too.

>>716329661
>that contributed to the pity,
the game has no pity. only sparks which go away at banner end

>>716336903
You're information is outdated. Current banner has both a spark system and a standard pity system

>>716328884 (OP)
>Autobattle
>Autobattle
>Actual game

>>716335856
How is it any better? It's the same menu clicker game as Azur Lane and the rest of outdated 2010 gachas.

>>716337074
>actual game
What's the gameplay? Is it clicking on highlighted buttons in the menu

>>716337306
>How is it any better
Finding the right combination of cards and making the optimal choices in career is enjoyable. It's ultimately very simple once you figure out how everything works, but there's a lot to figure out, especially when you consider that every horse has different styles and campaigns. So for a free game I could see someone totally disinterested in gacha easily sinking 50 hours into it and that still being time well spent, especially when there's an accompanying manga and anime that's actually really shockingly good. It's a fun sports simulator mechanically, with a great accompanying franchise, and it made me really think about Japanese horse racing which I never would have done previously.

With other gacha I find the typical "gameplay" is either
>your input only matters superficially and you progress until you hit a power brick wall
Or
>Endless crappy busy work bolted to a terrible VN

Neither of these apply to umamusume. (At the moment)

>>716338506
>Endless crappy busy work bolted to a terrible VN
>Neither of these apply to umamusume

>>716339069
Why did you post the reddit frog

>>716339598
he's a funny little character

>>716328884 (OP)
>Meguca

Least lewd game here yet somehow manages to be the most erotic

we need more fun gachas like arknights and umamusume

>>716337074
>>716337380
The game is watching cutscenes. Dumb shill just hasn't actually played it.

>>716328884 (OP)
There’s only 1 “horsemen” in that pic

>>716328884 (OP)

I play.Blue Archive cause after you are done with the story dailies only take like 10 minutes.
Also raids have difficulty levels so you don't have to care about meta.

>>716331158
Anon of youre playing Limbus and weren't already a fan of project moon's series of games, you're a fucking retard and a tertiary.

>>716335856
>Troonimai
WTF, I LOVE Korea and China now?!?

>>716341461
That's how madoka is set up as well

>>716328884 (OP)
Remember FGO?

>>716331736
Have you seen how tiny the fanbase is? it's just a few dedicated whales, but I rarely see it top charts.
https://arch-img.b4k.dev/vmg/1752476558647.jpg
That image shows it losing to Blue Archive in terms of votes in China. The image is from somewhere in July. But at the same time, people exaggerate what Fate makes as if no game can make more.

>>716331158
only degenerate coomers want to only have women in gacha games

>>716328884 (OP)
Eh? Is Madoka still a thing?

>>716341627
Keep liking awful things to spite your superiors and see where it lands you.

>>716334682
>Nikke
>Shizo lesbian summer in rate up
>like 3 pay costumes
>only one girl that is pure sexo
I'm kinda dissapointed

>>716328884 (OP)
This is the second Madoka gacha. The first one was closed suddenly and people lost everything. You'd have to be mad to put effort into it.
Uma is okay but it's extremely time intensive, only if you don't mind very grindy dailies.
BA has the most fanart by orders of magnitude, is very generous and takes little of your time each day. It's a VN though so it has very little gameplay outside of select events, like the one that ended recently.

>>716343360
>it's extremely time intensive
It's 15 minutes a day, why would you play a game you don't want to play for 15 minutes

>>716343441
Everyone I know that plays Uma says they spend a ton more time than that.

>>716330570
It's not Type Moon

>>716329281
>1999
Kill yourself reddit tourist

>>716344053
Pls understand, Legend of Ruina is their most popular game.

>>716328884 (OP)
>How am I supposed to know which one to play?
Just play the one with the cutest fanarts

>>716328884 (OP)
None, you're supposed to know this because they're gacha.
>>716328976
If you like a gacha game (or any game for that matter), you should be glad when gachafags forget/overlook it.

>>716343360
The first madoka gacha lasted 7 years and only closes because the engine it was built on was no longer supported

>>716341587
Then there's no reason to talk about it in a general gacha thread, now is there?

>>716343521
>they spend a ton more time than that.
Yeah because it's fun to play. The daily is literally 15 minutes long and it doesn't even give you anything good.

>>716344408
Featuring Ronald, the Black Man

>>716348720
>The daily is literally 15 minutes long and it doesn't even give you anything good
I-is this supposed to be a positive?

>>716349584
Yeah, the game not shoving fomo down your throat is a positive