Is it good or is it trash?

the 7th gen ports are actually trash, the pc port fixes it, except for level design

Trash
>medals
>hubworlds
>tornado QTE sections
>werehog existing at all
>night stages take too long
>boost and homing attack are the same button

>>716459306 (OP)
Sonic isn't trash. Trash is sonic.

it's overly ambitious and held back by mandatory collectibles and RPG stat grinding, but if you can get past that it's good

PINGAS

>>716459306 (OP)
its one of the top 9 games ever made

They delayed the PS3 version, and it still turned out worse than the 360 version

>>716460656
a mandatory hard drive install and 30fps cap with adaptive vsync would've fixed 90% of the problems
they had no idea what they were doing but that the game is still playable and just runs kind of shittily is an accomplishment under the circumstances

>>716459306 (OP)
It's fucking Sonic.

>>716459306 (OP)
Magically both. It's as bad as everybody says it is while also being just as fun as everybody claims.
Since people always talk about different parts of the game.

It's bad. People jerk off the normal daytime sections but it's still extremely mid. Everything after the Adventure games have been mid.

I just beat the game on PC a few days ago, and it is my second time ever playing through the game since I was a lot younger.

Objectively, it is good, and it is one of the better Sonic games out there. Yes, it has flaws. The tornado sections, which there are literally only 2 of, are just kind of shitty, but that's miniscule. The werehog sections being bad are severely overblown. The only bad stage overall is Arid Sands and the final stage of the game.

>716463380
To add on to this as I posted early, the extra stages are very well designed. The werehog needed stages to be slightly less lengthy and combat music to be different for every region. Some better movement options would have been welcome. But it's far from the trash people like to call it. Daytime stages are just challenging enough with great level design and graphics overall are very good which brings the overall score up. Towns are decent little hubs, and finding the sun and moon stones wasn't an issue until Adabat, which you can easily just go back to the hubs and stage hubs to find most of them you'd missed. It's a very packed Sonic game and it does have soul. People are just being retarded.

The last boss is shit though and the daytime stages could have done without the short quickstep sections for the robots.

>>716459306 (OP)
Play the PS2 version instead

>>716461582
What the fuck is a Sonic?

>>716459306 (OP)
It's trash. Even if you argue the day stages are good, if you look at the moment to moment gameplay most of your time is spent in night stages.

>>716459564
>medals
skill issue
>hubworlds
Not big enough
>tornado QTE sections
Literally 2
>werehog existing at all
skill issue
>night stages take too long
SKILL issue
>boost and homing attack are the same button
Skill issue

>>716464127
The night stages are good though. The only issue is all the fun is locked behind needing to unlock all your combo moves