Funny how people stopped hyping this game up as soon as it became available to play on anything

just like bloodborne and pretty much every other console exclusive game

People stopped hyping a game 15 years after it's release?

>>716483154 (OP)
But they didn't, and whenever we get an RDR thread anons still discuss how good a game it is?

>>716483154 (OP)
My problem is I played it on my 360 back in like 2012 and absolutely loved it. Then over the years, I closely monitored its status on emulation and routinely tested it, even beating it on both RPCS3 and Xenia (with a weak i7 7700k and 1080 Ti, it was rough.) Then after the ports to modern ish systems launched, I tested them on Ryujinx and observed the coverage of the PS4 and PC ports. What I came to realize is these ports, and even the original PS3 version are all trash. Only the Xbox 360 version shows this game with the soul it should have. The best way to experience the game today is on the Xbox One X or Series X where it runs the native 360 code without any involvement from poojeets mucking things up. Their shitty ports completely ruined the legacy of this legendary game. It's a shame Xenia is dead in the water with 0 progress because it was the only promising means of getting that perfect experience on PC. One day I'll pickup a Series X most likely just to continue experiencing this masterpiece as it was intended.

Nigger it's like 15 years old

>>716483769
What's wrong with them.

>>716483769
Dude it's all spaghetti code but the re-releases run well enough. And they didn't do typical R* fuckery like removing effects or anything in one platform. It's soul on all platform.
>But Multiplayer
We'll get mp on PC. They already make a mod like that.

>>716483154 (OP)
its GTA4 with horses and even less things to do in the world, no shit it sucks

>>716483769
What's bad about the ports exactly, other than the high launch price? Because I played the ports on the piss5 and the only problem I had with it was that sometimes your horse sinks into the ground a little going too fast on certain roads. If it's about the bugs, that game's always been a buggy mess.

>>716483154 (OP)
Anon, it's moreso that RDR2 is clearly the superior game in virtually every aspect. It makes RDR1 look bad by comparison because they were clearly struggling trying to make "GTA but in the wild west but also not really".

Although the Dutch scenes in RDR1 are great.

>>716483902
Reduced grass density, color grading is all fucked up, doesn't use the Xbox 360 lighting and shadowing code so interiors have messed up sun lighting coming in through doorways (watch the intro cutscene when John wakes up at Bonnie's ranch and watch the sun shadows coming in behind her.) And of course as other anon said no multiplayer. They're not genuine ports, and I would always advise people play some variety of the original 360 version, whether it's on an actual 360 or the newer Xbox higher tier consoles so it's at 4k.

>>716484228
Absolute brainlet take

>>716483154 (OP)
It's still great.
Lightyears better than that boring walking sim RDR2 is.

>>716483154 (OP)
wdym?
After it became available I saw many people praise it as better than the sequel.
Which is true.

>>716483381
>every other console exclusive game
opposite happened with TLOU 2 - people realized it's actually great

>>716485278
>people realized it's actually great
It's so bad that even the show crashed and burned when it reached its equivalent story point.

>>716485764
No. People are actively making fun of how bad the show is by comparing it to the game. Most haters, who tried the game, changed their minds. Obviously those who haven't played the game still hate it.

>>716484228
RDR1 was made because they wanted to make it
RDR2 was made because they felt like they had to make it
One of them feels like a love letter to westerns and the other feels like a pretentious slog wannabe simulator that forgot how to be a game along the way
But feel free to cream yourself because Arthur has different dialogue depending on if he's high or low honor or slightly tilts his head to cover his eyes with his hat on low honor or stands with a straighter back in high honor if you want
It won't change the fact that RDR2 one of the most railroaded games Rockstar have shit out, and sadly one of the most boring and bland open world games too that goes out of its way to actively punish you for having fun

>>716485880
No. People are actually making fun of defenders of the game due to the exact same thing happening with a different demographics, therefore proving that the game was always terrible and the astroturfed narrative about muh sexism and muh antisemitism weren't the reasons 2 failed.
Druckmann even had to flee back to Israel after the monumental failure of the show.

>>716486039
>80 million copies sold
>failed

I pirated it from fitgirl and windows said it was a virus which freaked me out so I never played it.

>>716486039
>People are actually making fun of defenders of the game
you are talking about /v/, that's pretty much irrelevant. And even here many people like the game now. Look outside your bubble for a bit

>>716485453
that aged like sour milk. call of juarez gunslinger is the only game in this genre that is fun to play.

>>716486073
>not including the cost
Lol
>>716486163
It's okay to cope anon.
The game and show both failed. Move on.

>>716485453
Came here for the obligatory
>Gun lets you shoot injuns
post

>>716486261
ehh, remember this post when the next game comes out

>>716486261
>show
what?

>>716486286
so does CoJ gunslinger and you play as a white man

>>716486326
I doubt it will since that next one, Heretic something is bound to fail.
>>716486331
>anon doesn't know about the tv show

>>716486629
there was never a tv show planned, it's all fanfic speculations

>>716483154 (OP)
max payne 3 is the only good game rockstar has made

>>716486286
You kill a lot of injuns in RDR1
>>716486398
As a white man

>>716486286
Gun takes the injuns side in the end as well.

>>716487057
they were all gang members

>>716486189
When did you last try Gun?

>>716483154 (OP)
>he didn't have a xbox 360 or ps3
lol. lmao

>>716487224
literally in the middle of my first playthrough, im still stuck in dodge city after i helped those chinks.

>>716487360
I guess I'm in the middle of CoJ Gunslinger, myself. Quit out of boredom.

as soon as it goes for less than 25 bucks

>>716486861
>there was never a tv show planned, it's all fanfic speculations

>>716487195
That doesn't detract from my point.

where the fuck does rockstar get off charging 50 bucks for this
it should be 10

This was my problem with the game
>normal game you go to this one area and you enter the DLC
>RDD DLCs are spread out all over the fucking place breaking the immersion
>friends want to play it
>I see a bounty board
>cool lets check this out
>WELCOME TO THE DLC BOUNTY BOARD THIS WILL COST 10$

>>716486163
>you are talking about /v/
no he means everyone else as well
> Look outside your bubble for a bit
VERY ironic comment

>>716488417
i don't know wtf your talking about
do you mean rdr2 multiplayer?

>>716488651
>do you mean rdr2 multiplayer?
yes

>>716487816
>Making it about the money

>>716485907
Yeah I'm sure the Housers spent 8 years on the autistically detailed RDR2 because they "felt forced to do it"

>>716488752
Why would anyone play RDR online?

>>716483154 (OP)
It's the typical shiny object shit you see in software
I deal with it with customers all the time
they really fuckin want a feature and are really fuckin angry it's not there
I make it
instead of shutting the fuck up and moving on they just shift to something else and when I look at usage metrics the thing I just wasted time on isn't used at all
so you just ignore them and look for actual proof that something will sell
either that or take a gamble
but don't assume interest = someone will buy
lots of people like fancy cars, doesn't mean they'll buy one when you put it in front of them with the price tag

>>716485278
>opposite happened with TLOU 2 - people realized it's actually great
kek true. abby's part was my fav

>>716486073
>>716486261
>>716486331
>>716486629
>>716486861
I think one chud is talking about RDR2 and another about Last of Us 2. Bunch of brainlets

>>716488832
friends wanted to play it and shit was on sale

*siiiiiip*

>>716483154 (OP)
Both red dead 1 and 2 are boring. Large empty world. Boring missions with most are literally go from place to place and very little action

>>716489468
Aren't all videogames just "go to place from place"? I mean isn't that also just the totality of human existence? You from place to place till you finally die and stop.

>>716489858
Cope. When ubisoft does fetch quest, it's bad. When half of rdr1 is just fetching for farmer or snake oil salesman , it's high art.wtf

>>716489971
>ignores the question
Hmmm

>>716485278
I don't know who your trying to convince but last of us 2 is like universally hated even by secondaries now that the show covered Joel's death

My biggest disappointment in gaming is the absence of Undead Nightmare 2.
I was so surprised R* released RDR2 with so much focus on single player after GTA Online that it gave me hope they would do a single player DLC... but no... Fuck R*

>>716485453
I think rdr 1 is better but Gun is still awesome, makes Red Dead Revolver look like janky kusoge.

>>716488959
Exactly this. People act like adding feature X is some magic bullet and when it finally drops, it barely moves the needle. Remember when everyone screamed about wanting first-person mode in GTA V on PC? Devs busted ass to implement it, and 90% of players turned it off after 30 minutes. The loudest voices don’t always equal the paying crowd, they just echo more.

>>716490170
You're the one who ignored most of my comment. I said my biggest problem is the lack of action. F.e.a.r. 1 is going thought a building, but there is a lot of action. In rdr1 and 2 half of missions are literally just gallop from custcene to custcene.

>>716485278

>>716490428
There's always a shootout involved. Or ranching.

>>716484276
what does "reduced grass" have to do with the world being boring and empty and every mission just follow talking npc to point b then shoot 10 mexicans behind cover with slow motion then ride back to point a and repeat