← Home ← Back to /v/

Thread 724577362

178 posts 60 images /v/
Anonymous No.724577362 [Report] >>724578330 >>724579049 >>724579072 >>724582428 >>724584485 >>724585247 >>724585756 >>724585769 >>724586418 >>724588152 >>724588423 >>724592629 >>724593113 >>724593390 >>724594582 >>724596423 >>724597514 >>724598117 >>724599025 >>724599707 >>724602604 >>724602783 >>724603153 >>724609828 >>724610153 >>724610702
Harvest Moon has hit Rock Bottom.
Anonymous No.724577926 [Report] >>724585956
what's wrong with it
Anonymous No.724578330 [Report] >>724585756 >>724587073 >>724609515
>>724577362 (OP)
no shit, the ones called Harvest Moon are by natsume, they're all soulless cashgrabs, the real games are labeled story of seasons (not that they are much better but at least they suck comparatively less)
Anonymous No.724578504 [Report]
looks fine
Anonymous No.724578674 [Report]
because that's not Bokujō Monogatari
Anonymous No.724578865 [Report] >>724579024 >>724579918 >>724583024 >>724594228 >>724599994
not even an extra ten turnip seeds can make this game sell
Anonymous No.724579024 [Report]
>>724578865
thanks for the warning. i'll wait until special offer is over because i don't want starting cheats
Anonymous No.724579049 [Report]
>>724577362 (OP)
harvest moon had the perfect concept but went full jew and let another less jew brand take over the farming game scene (stardew valley)
Anonymous No.724579072 [Report] >>724579197 >>724587073
>>724577362 (OP)
Thats not really Harvest Moon anyway, since 2014. Its a game waring a Harvest Moon skin.
Story of Seasons is the real "Harvest Moon"
Anonymous No.724579197 [Report] >>724579729 >>724587073 >>724595875 >>724596821
>>724579072
story of seasons has reclined so
Anonymous No.724579565 [Report] >>724581832 >>724595561
I like these games but I never feel like marrying anyone.
Anonymous No.724579729 [Report]
>>724579197
It's insane that a multimillion dollar company can't be arsed to make a better farming game than a single fucking dude.
Anonymous No.724579918 [Report] >>724593316
>>724578865
this the lamest pre-order incentive that i can recall
Anonymous No.724581832 [Report] >>724582668
>>724579565
because none appeal to you, or because you don't feel like you're worthy of being loved?
Anonymous No.724582428 [Report] >>724582668 >>724582740
>>724577362 (OP)
Despite how generic this looks, it still has better art direction than whatever the fuck they've been doing with the SoS games.
Anonymous No.724582668 [Report] >>724582740
>>724581832
Not that anon, but the systems for it always seem to be shit busywork instead of having anything meaningful to them.

>>724582428
Graphics aren't everything, but clearly they have no excuse since the Doraemon SoS games manage to look good.
Anonymous No.724582740 [Report]
>>724582428
>>724582668
grand bazaar looks good as well, so maybe there'll be hope for the next proper sos if they ever stop pumping out remakes
Anonymous No.724582912 [Report] >>724583041 >>724583843 >>724583979 >>724585028 >>724596269 >>724597619 >>724598220 >>724598509 >>724606718 >>724610030
>wanted to, and still want to make a harvest moon clone
>the dread of having to compete against stardew valley and stand out amongst the 5000 clones
Just feels like a dead end overall
Anonymous No.724582949 [Report]
Stardew Valley raped this series into irrelevancy
Anonymous No.724583024 [Report] >>724589497
>>724578865
When I play games like this, I want to build up from having NOTHING. I don't think I'm alone in this line of thinking either. I guess they don't understand what their fans want out of these games. Saying that you'll give me free gold and seeds to start off with that I wouldn't have otherwise makes me not want to get the game.
Really though, I stopped playing Harvest Moon type games once I started raising my own garden IRL.
Anonymous No.724583041 [Report]
>>724582912
just do something le wacky reddit with it like making it ps1 horror themed roguelite deck building
Anonymous No.724583843 [Report]
>>724582912
if you have no shame you could pander to foids bigly and make a hentai farming sim inspired by morning glory milking farm. you'd have to read some of those popular monster sex books to actually learn how to appeal to them. and also I'm not sure how you'd get more than just semen from the various monster men you'd keep on the farm, but I'm just the initial ideas guy
Anonymous No.724583979 [Report]
>>724582912
Focus entirely on the farming and light life sim aspects. No mine. No combat. A few leisure activities like fishing, but they shouldn't be a viable alternative to farming.
Build in small production chains, similar to what SV has with canning, wines, etc.
Focus on the selling. Okay so you made honey, now you need to bring to a.local farmers market to sell. Trends come and go, in some seasons flowers might be in more demand than honey.
Crops can get ruined. Too mich rain? Some of your plants have root rot. Disease mechanics, crop rotation.
It should be just close enough to realistic autistic farm simulation but still be comfy and approachable.
Anonymous No.724584261 [Report] >>724584946
that looks like steam greenlight shovelware, what the fuck went wrong with natsume
Anonymous No.724584485 [Report] >>724584872
>>724577362 (OP)
The only good Harvest Moon games were from SNES to GBA. The series has been shit far longer than it's been good.
Anonymous No.724584872 [Report]
>>724584485
Nah. Magical Melody on the Gamecube was peak Harvest Moon.
Anonymous No.724584946 [Report] >>724587073
>>724584261
Natsume never made them, just published and localized. They split from Marvelous (the devs) and took the name with them. Story of the Seasons is the actual HM, though its only marginally better.
Anonymous No.724585028 [Report] >>724585149
>>724582912
Literally just add attractive waifus (and husbandos if you want extra cash by adding the fujo audience). Most western clones have really butt-ugly designs in both bachlorettes and bachelors.

Also harvest moon clones suffer from lack of post-marriage content. Even Stardew doesn't have much child raising shit.
Anonymous No.724585149 [Report]
>>724585028
Stardew doesnt go in enough on post-marriage because you can just undo it. Stupid mechanic IMO.
Anonymous No.724585247 [Report] >>724585567 >>724596619 >>724602783 >>724609625
>>724577362 (OP)
i just got one of these from Humble choice, is it one of the good ones?
Anonymous No.724585567 [Report]
>>724585247
That's what I've heard.
Anonymous No.724585756 [Report]
>>724577362 (OP)
Harvest Moon isn't Harvest Moon you fucking retard. See >>724578330
Anonymous No.724585769 [Report] >>724585841 >>724586107 >>724587073
>>724577362 (OP)
Time to talk about the Harvest Moon situation:

The original name of the series, in Japan, is Bokujō Monogatari. They were originally created by Victor Interactive, which later got bought into Marvelous and that's who still produces Bokujō Monogatari to this day.

When they (Victor Interactive at the time) wanted to localize the game to NA, they worked with the company Natsume. The localized name of the series was Harvest Moon. This went on until the 3DS era, where the company (now Marvelous) wanted to start publishing games on their own, and wanted to break with Natsume. However, Natsume had trademarked the name "Harvest Moon" under their own company and refused to give it up.

Natsune then turned around and hired mobile developers and Farmville developers to make some random games, slapping the name "Harvest Moon" onto the products. Marvelous, meanwhile, ended up using the title "Story of Seasons" for the new games they produced. It's why the latest remakes are called games like Story of Seasons: Friends of Mineral town for the old GBA game, using the new title but with the old familiar subtitle and (obviously) the old gameplay.

So yes, "Harvest Moon" has gone to shit, because Natsume stole the name and has been hiring any incompetent idiot they can to pump out titles and grab them some attention. But the Bokujō Monogatari / Story of Seasons games are still being made and still going strong, along with the spinoff titles like Rune Factory.
Anonymous No.724585841 [Report] >>724586214 >>724587871 >>724588194 >>724593028
>>724585769
I still can't get over how the company with the japanese name is actually the one that does the localization and the company with the english name is the japanese one
Anonymous No.724585956 [Report]
>>724577926
They need to remake the game in unreal engine 5 using the same stock assets as everyone else
Imagine how much better the game would be with good gwaphics
Anonymous No.724586032 [Report]
Is that tranny code for an all time high?
suck it nintendo
Anonymous No.724586107 [Report] >>724587073
>>724585769
this really needs to be updated because the harvest moon games have gotten better and the story of seasons and rune factory games have gotten worse
it's grim all around honestly
Anonymous No.724586214 [Report]
>>724585841
Natsume can't even spell their own name right half the time, so I wouldn't put too much value in how they name themselves.
Anonymous No.724586418 [Report] >>724586675
>>724577362 (OP)
Thought it was renamed to Tales of Season?
Anonymous No.724586675 [Report] >>724587073
>>724586418
Story of Seasons

>https://store.steampowered.com/app/978780/STORY_OF_SEASONS_Friends_of_Mineral_Town/
Anonymous No.724587073 [Report] >>724589306 >>724599725
>>724578330
>>724579072
>>724579197
>>724584946
>>724585769
>>724586107
>>724586675
>on steam
deader than harvest moon. applealing to pcfags ruins every franchise. just look at halo, god of war, gta, red dead, yakuza, everybodys golf, minecraft, terraria, danganronpa, persons, shin megami tensei, raidou remastered, metaflop, final fantasy, the list goes on
Anonymous No.724587502 [Report] >>724609489
Anonymous No.724587871 [Report]
>>724585841
Same
Anonymous No.724588152 [Report]
>>724577362 (OP)
Any game that's on Steam has reached rock bottom.
Anonymous No.724588194 [Report]
>>724585841
>natsume is an offshoot of a japanese company named natsume
>when they went independent they both kept the name natsume
>since then the japanese natsume has merged with its subsidiary atari to become natsume atari
>their atari is a pachinko company
jesus
Anonymous No.724588371 [Report]
>724587073
>mass reply to say the dumbest niggerbabble ever
Anonymous No.724588423 [Report] >>724588915 >>724589080
>>724577362 (OP)
Only ever played the SNES and the PS1 version. Is it even worth playing one of the newer ones?
Anonymous No.724588915 [Report] >>724590067
>>724588423
Honestly, I felt like the series went downhill a bit with the Gamecube or Wii games. They'll still keep you busy, but it feels more like the games are chewing up all your daylight time with activities in different places. It felt like with the SNES/PS1 games, you could just give yourself as much work as you like (between crops and animals) and it was up to you to manage if you wanted to spend all day watering crops, or just plant enough to make some money and then have time to go into town and talk with people. (which required managing time for that) With the most recent Story of Season games, you get a small area to farm and raise animals, but you have a hundred little side activities that chew up your time if you want to interact with them.

I'm not sure how much Story of Seasons: Pioneers of Olive Town (the most recent one) is at this, but that's been my experience with the most recent SoS games over the original ones.
Anonymous No.724589080 [Report] >>724589150 >>724590067
>>724588423
The post 2014 Harvest Moon games are not the real Harvest Moon.

The real Harvest Moon is now called Story of Seasons
Anonymous No.724589130 [Report] >>724589362 >>724589484 >>724594205
Why are the graphics on these type of games so bad now? They look worse than how they did in the gamecube/ps2.
Looks at the demake, its downgrade in every way.
Anonymous No.724589150 [Report] >>724589275 >>724603617
>>724589080
and story of seasons hasn't been good since the 3ds
Anonymous No.724589275 [Report] >>724597225 >>724609392 >>724609686
>>724589150
The Grand Bazaar remake looks pretty good though
Anonymous No.724589306 [Report]
>>724587073
Here is that (You) you desperately crave for :)
Anonymous No.724589362 [Report] >>724591115
>>724589130
kek
Anonymous No.724589447 [Report]
The Doraemon one looked comfy but I didnt want to play Doraemon
Anonymous No.724589484 [Report]
>>724589130
I get the feeling that Marvelous is trying to remake their own games (to make the Story of Seasons name more familiar) and has been standardizing the art style as a result. So rather than have a bunch of random attempts at making a 3D character on different hardware, they now have one engine that they're using with all the remakes.
Anonymous No.724589491 [Report]
Harvest Moon and Pokemon should team up to dethrone Palworld.
Anonymous No.724589497 [Report] >>724590283
>>724583024
Anon, you don't get it.
If you buy the game now when you press 'new game' you'll actually be sent to the ending screen and see the credits!
Anonymous No.724590067 [Report]
>>724588915
>>724589080
Thanks, anons. Guess I'll look into the Story of Seasons games then.
Anonymous No.724590283 [Report] >>724594465
>>724589497
Oh thank goodness. The last thing I want is to actually have to play a game.
Anonymous No.724591115 [Report]
>>724589362
Nice.
Anonymous No.724592313 [Report] >>724593049 >>724593359 >>724593372 >>724603352 >>724606918 >>724609538 >>724610557
>all the Stardew Valley mentions ITT
I don't get it desu, I tried Stardew Valley like 3 separate times and fucking hated it every time. Meanwhile I like most Bokujou Monogatari entries aside from Olive Town and the remakes, but half of Olive Town's problem is that it fell for the Slopdew meme just like every other modern knockoff farming sim and focused on retarded tedium mechanics and the "freedom" to fill your farm with ugly clutter. The minute they returned to form with Grand Bazaar they massively improved. Not to the standard of their older titles, obviously, but enough to where it's actually playable with a few mods to mitigate the babby's first vidya marketing they've been doing in Japan.
Anonymous No.724592629 [Report]
>>724577362 (OP)
Can you marry the horse?
Anonymous No.724593028 [Report]
>>724585841
like when the dragon ball budokai tenkaichi games in the west were called dragon ball sparking in Japan
Anonymous No.724593049 [Report] >>724594536
>>724592313
sorry dude but if You don't like SDV I'll fucking kill You
Anonymous No.724593113 [Report]
>>724577362 (OP)
>"""harvest moon"""
Anonymous No.724593316 [Report] >>724603151
>>724579918
>this the lamest pre-order incentive that i can recall
nothing will ever beat TWO HUNDRED POTIONS
Anonymous No.724593359 [Report] >>724594536
>>724592313
sorry man but you just have shit taste, Stardew Valley literally set the new standard on what farming life games should be like, just look at how many clones it spawned in the last decade trying to have a slice of the success the game had.
Anonymous No.724593372 [Report] >>724594536
>>724592313
Keep on sperging and coping, Marvelous tards. SoS and RF will never be relevant again.
Anonymous No.724593390 [Report]
>>724577362 (OP)
how does a nigga spend 700 hours in stardew valley
Anonymous No.724593398 [Report] >>724601457
immortal life is ok for being chinkjank
Anonymous No.724593918 [Report]
Hi Eric, how is HC coming along? 2026 release?
Anonymous No.724594205 [Report]
>>724589130
from the tech side they don't seem too far off, but from an artistic side left looks way better
Anonymous No.724594228 [Report]
>>724578865
Before 2010 this would have been a cheat code on the start menu, today it's paywalled content.
Anonymous No.724594465 [Report]
>>724590283
nowadays thats a blessing honestly, i wish i could have started borderlands 3 and just skipped the entire story so i could shoot randy pitchford in the face
Anonymous No.724594536 [Report] >>724595423 >>724599293 >>724607012
>>724593049
>>724593359
>>724593372
What's the appeal, legitimately? I appreciate that the dev seems like he's got a good head on his shoulders, but the game itself was profoundly unpleasant to play imo. Unpleasant art style, shitty time economy, unappealing NPCs (as far as I played, anyway), iirc there were a handful of permanently missable events with retarded requirements as early as summer of year 1, just a lot of bad decisions overall. It didn't feel relaxing or productive to play, just tedious, like it was trying to force you into one really specific playstyle. Its ripoffs are even worse since they concentrate hard on all the things I disliked about SDV.
Maybe he fixed it in the years since I've tried it, it's been a few years, but it's just not for me.
Anonymous No.724594582 [Report]
>>724577362 (OP)
>Women operating machinery
Holy fucking wokeslop
Anonymous No.724594934 [Report] >>724595389
What's the best farming game other than Harvest Moon BTN (or the GBA version) and SV? I'm thinking of getting Rune Factory 3 or 4 next
Anonymous No.724595389 [Report] >>724595838
>>724594934
RF isn't as good of farming. It's selling point is that it has fighting and action with a side of farming.
Anonymous No.724595423 [Report] >>724596940
>>724594536
>permanently missable events with retarded requirements as early as summer of year 1
You can't permanently miss anything, at worst you'll just have to wait another year. The NPCs are a matter of taste and opinion, but I thought some of them were pretty good, and most were about on the level of similar games. It's as relaxing as you want it to be, you can really push hard to get as much done as possible in year 1 but like I mentioned, there's really no rush because there's no time limit and you won't ever miss out on anything, you might just have to wait if you miss the deadline in a year. If you played it a while back then yeah it's changed a fair bit, lots of huge updates. Another nice thing about it is that it's very moddable, which I really like but I understand not everyone is interested in that kind of thing.
Anonymous No.724595561 [Report] >>724607823
>>724579565
Same, I'm always too busy with my farm.
Which is a shame cause I actually like HM girls.
Anonymous No.724595838 [Report]
>>724595389
The selling point of Story of Seasons and Stardew Valley is not farming. In fact farming is a very secondary aspect of these games.

The selling point of these games are characters.

There are far more complex farming games in the market but they don't focus on characters like SV and SoS.
See: Don't Starve Together, Project Zomboid

Survival games in general have more complex farming mechanics than drop seed, water, fuck off from the farm.
Anonymous No.724595871 [Report]
Stardew is fucking boring I don't get it the appeal
Anonymous No.724595875 [Report]
>>724579197
Grand Bazaar is very good, though
Anonymous No.724595950 [Report] >>724596113 >>724597090 >>724597529 >>724597829 >>724597968 >>724602979 >>724603140 >>724609710 >>724610808
Didn't see any thread on it, but what are we thinking?
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1005170304/farnia-village/
It's being headed by the main programmer for RF3 and director for RF4.
Anonymous No.724596113 [Report]
>>724595950
Looks like it's pretty much RF3/4 with the recipe bread and shit
best of all, it has the romance toggle that these games should have
Anonymous No.724596269 [Report]
>>724582912
Do a Gordon Ramsay of farming sim. You are in a consultant role visiting multiple dismal farms. Real time part is salvaging and fixing up things, job sim type of stuff like powerwasher sim. Strategic layer is optimizing layout and planting schedule, so the client gets cash quicker for more projects, or provides referrals for more missions. The clients can be all kinds of goofy or spooky weirdos with odd requirements: preppers, witches, luddites, serial killers, recreational druggies.
I'll accept my cut of gajillion dollars in the form of lewd Taokaka commissions.
Anonymous No.724596423 [Report]
>>724577362 (OP)
>THEY ARE LE USING LE WRONG GAYME ENGINE!!!
No! One! Cares!!!
Anonymous No.724596619 [Report]
>>724585247
It's an alright one, though it has some annoying stuff to it and feels like a major step back from the previous one in the franchise, Trio Of Towns.
Anonymous No.724596821 [Report]
>>724579197
Not the last game. Grand Bazaar is amazing.
Anonymous No.724596940 [Report] >>724597271
>>724595423
>You can't permanently miss anything, at worst you'll just have to wait another year.
This must've been fixed in later updates because the events I'm talking about were exclusive to a specific time frame in year 1 and year 2 respectively. One had to do with visiting a grave or a shrine or something and either bringing something to it or having progress in some specific area to trigger it? I don't remember the details, but they were pretty important to the story afaict.
As for the other stuff, fair enough. I found the NPCs pretty samey compared to some of the better BM titles and the gameplay weirdly fragmented, but if the game's changed that much who knows how many of my complaints got patched up kek. I think the last try I gave it was on like 1.4.x or 1.5? If he's done any major rebalancing or at least reduced the mandatory point-and-click shit I might give it another shake down the road.
Anonymous No.724597090 [Report] >>724597305 >>724607586
>>724595950
There was a very short lived thread yesterday, and that's where I found out about the game existing, and when I decided to back it.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VES59jhfk3Y

The preview video didn't look terrible. You look at it and can immediately tell that it's DS/3DS Rune Factory. It's also less than $20 so if it turns out to be average or terrible I wont feel like I got ripped off too badly.
Pic related is the Ventuswill btw. Can't have unless things change in development.

It's a 2 man team however. One programmer, one writer, and the artists and composers are freelance? So this game will take its time to get here. But the lead dev has been programming since the GBA days so I suppose he has enough experience to actually make something.
They also got the RF composer Tomoko Morita back to make some music. Not all the music, but some of it.
Anonymous No.724597225 [Report]
>>724589275
It's pretty good, they fixed a lot of the time gate stuff that was going on with the original version of Grand Bazaar. I was able to reach World Rank bazaar and get married by the end of the first year pretty easy and have all sorts of different animals, an extra barn, three mushroom logs, level three bee keeping, three outdoor fields and one underground field, the most improved soil quality, crazy sized storage, a super bath, and orichalcum tools by the end of year 1 as well.
Really all I have left is having a child and maxing out everyone in town, making the ultimate tools, making the Summer, Autumn, and Winter sunstones for the underground field, winning some more competitions all the way thru to gold a bunch of times, and getting the bazaar to rank 99 thru donations now that I've hit World rank and finished the story part.
It's also nice because at least for the Switch 2 version it, like Rune Factory Guardians of Azuma, actually comes with a little manual in the box when you buy it physical.
Anonymous No.724597271 [Report] >>724597780
>>724596940
>One had to do with visiting a grave or a shrine or something and either bringing something to it or having progress in some specific area to trigger it? I don't remember the details, but they were pretty important to the story afaict
You're probably thinking of when your grandpa's ghost shows up in the beginning of Year 3 at his shrine/grave, and judges your progress so far and rewards you dependingly. But it doesn't really matter if you disappoint him the first time, he'll show up on New Year's Day every year afterward and you can ask him to take another look. Basically he just wants you to have a wife and a decent farm, and be friends with some of the villagers.
Anonymous No.724597305 [Report] >>724597389
>>724597090
They're already almost double their goal in about 72 hours, I imagine by the end they will probably hit all their stretch goals so maybe they can hire an extra body or something to help out.
Anonymous No.724597389 [Report]
>>724597305
I at least hope they reach the children stretch goal. Odd that it's a stretch goal in the first place but with how they hype up the quantity of writing maybe it's necessary.
The game would just feel incomplete without them though.
Anonymous No.724597491 [Report]
I wish these games stopped looking luke they are made for babies. At least that new chink one is getting rid of their superdeformed style
Anonymous No.724597514 [Report] >>724597943 >>724598021
>>724577362 (OP)
The name change fucked this series for me, I dont know whats what anymore
Anonymous No.724597529 [Report]
>>724595950
>premium backing
>Fish Request (魚リクエスト) You can request your favorite fish be added to the game!
>¥50,000
Based as fuck.
Anonymous No.724597597 [Report]
Here is the real story cut down

> Make farming game for Men, sells so well that it attracts women
> Make the game appeal to women to try hit both markets, men stop playing
> Ok, we still got women lets fully appeal to women, women drop it
> 1 guy makes a farming guy focused for guys sells well and women play it to
> Still can't figure out the problem
Anonymous No.724597619 [Report]
>>724582912
Make the waifu sim engaging at least.
Stardew Valley bachelorettes are a bunch of generic ugly roasties
Anonymous No.724597780 [Report] >>724598237
>>724597271
I don't think it's that because the event was pretty explicitly somewhere in the middle of year 1, but it might be the same grave. You had to be there at a specific time of the day, and you had to either bring something or have some progress in a specific area. It was one of things you had to go out of your way for, not really normal farm progress. I could be remembering wrong, but I know missing it and then finding out it would never trigger again in that playthrough pissed me off enough to drop it, so I dunno. It's been too long kek.
Anonymous No.724597829 [Report] >>724597928
>>724595950
The two-tone hair and the gachaslop character designs are seriously putting me off.
Anonymous No.724597928 [Report]
>>724597829
man frosted tips must have been a nightmare for you
Anonymous No.724597943 [Report]
>>724597514
Story of Seasons=Proper series
Harvest Moon=Natsume being faggots.
I don't think there has been one good entry for Harvest Moon since Natsume hijacked the series
Anonymous No.724597968 [Report] >>724598330
>>724595950
>just putting in legally distinct vtubers
lmao
Anonymous No.724598021 [Report]
>>724597514
All the games on SNES, N64, PS1, PS2, Game Boy, GBA, and DS are the original series. Tale of Two Towns (DS/3DS) is also official Harvest Moon.

Harvest Moon: A New Beginning (3DS) was the last official game to use the Harvest Moon game. The rest of the 3DS games were named Story of Seasons.

Everything after that has been named Story of Seasons. Anything after the 3DS named "Harvest Moon" are the Natsume knockoffs made by cheap mobile developers.

As for remakes and re-releases, all the remakes are named Story of Seasons. So we have SoS: Friends of Mineral Town, SoS: A Wonderful Life, and SoS: Grand Bazaar as remakes of older games.
Anonymous No.724598117 [Report] >>724605774
>>724577362 (OP)
Who gives a fuck about harvest moon while story of seasons exists?
Anonymous No.724598220 [Report] >>724598305
>>724582912
The worst thing about Stardew is that the townpeople are so lifeless.
There's such a lack of dialog for their day to day activities that you either stop talking to them entirely or resort to fanfiction mods to give them more things to say.
The community has to project what they want from these characters because the actual game gives you very little to work with when an event cutscene is not going on.

If you're going to make a farming game then focus on the characters and the town. The farming has to be passable, and people will want multiplayer and mod support, but what will make the game stand out is the actual immersion of that rural life.
A likeable cast of characters and the freedom to do whatever you want on your plot of land. I'd say the goal to shoot for would be the Night Market in Stardew. That's the gold standard for aesthetic and immersion.
It's either that or pandering to autists that want spreadsheet farming.
Anonymous No.724598237 [Report] >>724599483
>>724597780
Oh, maybe you're talking about reaching the secret master Qi really early, and he's basically just surprised to see you because you don't meet him usually until you're well into the late game stuff. Nothing happens if you find him early, it's mostly just a cool little easter egg that you'll only ever find if you know it's there and work specifically towards it, and get lucky with a couple things
Anonymous No.724598305 [Report] >>724598591
>>724598220
all the complaining about stardew yet no one has been able to top it
Anonymous No.724598330 [Report] >>724598554 >>724598650 >>724599050 >>724599795
>>724597968
>legally distinct vtubers
Fuck lmao, you're right
Anonymous No.724598509 [Report] >>724598701
>>724582912
You just need to bring the genre somewhere that's actually fresh and interesting. Like make a HM clone that takes place in a tiny galaxy and your "farm" is your AI-powered space ship, and you use the long travel time between celestial bodies to do your farm work.
Anonymous No.724598554 [Report]
>>724598330
damn i wonder if there's more, or if the dog one in the trailer was based on that one dog vtuber
Anonymous No.724598591 [Report] >>724598821
>>724598305
And no one ever will because it was babby's first farming game and no future game will have that untapped market desperate for more.
Remove that mod support and you get a pretty average game that happens to have lots of content thanks to years of support.
Anonymous No.724598650 [Report]
>>724598330
kek no way
Anonymous No.724598701 [Report]
>>724598509
Deiland: pocket planet exists and is pretty underwhelming
Anonymous No.724598790 [Report] >>724599780
Still can't be topped and even killed itself
Anonymous No.724598821 [Report]
>>724598591
not like there's much to do for farming games, they all play exactly the same
Anonymous No.724598961 [Report] >>724599061
Is Harvestella any good?
Anonymous No.724599025 [Report]
>>724577362 (OP)
>sell game on pc
>don't add keyboard support
this should be punishable
Anonymous No.724599050 [Report] >>724599097 >>724599114
>>724598330
They have a programmer and a writer. Art was not a factor.
Anonymous No.724599061 [Report]
>>724598961
I heard it's okay but the character interaction is lacking (no relationships)
Anonymous No.724599097 [Report]
>>724599050
They hired the atelier Yumia artist iirc
Anonymous No.724599114 [Report]
>>724599050
Maybe if they raise enough money, they can get Minako Iwasaki for the art
Anonymous No.724599293 [Report]
>>724594536
The appeal is that it is the perfect game to play while recovering from bottom surgery. 90% of the NPCs are also trans, so you'll feel a special connection to them knowing that they also dilate.
Anonymous No.724599483 [Report] >>724599698
>>724598237
It could be? I'm not sure since I don't know what actually happens in the event other than that it was important, but the
>you'll only ever find it if you know it's there and work specifically towards it
sounds about right. If it really was that then me of 5-6 years ago was a massive retard.
Anonymous No.724599698 [Report]
>>724599483
>If it really was that then me of 5-6 years ago was a massive retard.
happens to the best of us lol
Anonymous No.724599707 [Report]
>>724577362 (OP)
>52 moosebucks
That's probably still at least $40 real people money, which is egregious given how badly Stardew dunks on the series.
Natsume has always sucked ass, even back when they were localizing (read: adding a ton of game-breaking bugs, deleting items, half-assing the translations so bad that characters randomly break into moonrunes, etc.) the classic games
Anonymous No.724599725 [Report]
>>724587073
Did you really have to reply to 8 different people with this lame fucking comment? Hardly even relevant. Just waaah waah waah.
Scrolling down the thread and you made it unbearable. Every reply was just you. Dickhead
Anonymous No.724599780 [Report] >>724599827
>>724598790
What was it called again?
Anonymous No.724599795 [Report] >>724600304 >>724601379
>>724598330
>Rune Factory where you fuck vtubers
Mildly interested.
Anonymous No.724599827 [Report]
>>724599780
...farmville?
Anonymous No.724599994 [Report]
>>724578865
>tfw no childhood farm village to subsidize me with land, cash, and even bonus seeds in the hopes I will breed them a new population
Anonymous No.724600304 [Report]
>>724599795
I dont know anything about vtubers, but I like her the best so far.
Anonymous No.724601379 [Report]
>>724599795
Tummy sexo
Anonymous No.724601457 [Report]
>>724593398
did they ever make the combat not mobile/flash tier dogshit? I played the demo when it was on next fest, and that was my one complaint about it. I really liked the cultivation jank, but calling the combat half baked would be generous. I'm pretty sure I remember it being super floaty and I think you just held down the mouse to throw daggers or whatever in the direction you were looking.
Anonymous No.724602604 [Report]
>>724577362 (OP)
I want to like other farm sims but stardew valley seems to btfo all/most of them
Anonymous No.724602783 [Report] >>724602951
>>724577362 (OP)
Individual crops = good

>>724585247
3x3 plots = bad

Why does Story of Seasons look like the knock off of Harvest Moon now? What happened?
Anonymous No.724602951 [Report]
>>724602783
>Why does Story of Seasons look like the knock off of Harvest Moon now? What happened?
The latest one (Grand Bazaar) looks really nice. A whole lot better than POoT.
Anonymous No.724602979 [Report] >>724603140
>>724595950
Might be good
Anonymous No.724603140 [Report]
>>724602979
>>724595950
I don't like the abstracted, high fashion everyone is wearing. It feels like they just plopped random anime characters into a farm sim. I want a cozy rural aesthetic. And bitches dressed like they're from the Shibuya fashion scene are out of place.
Anonymous No.724603151 [Report]
>>724593316
ZA did 100 pokeballs lmao
Anonymous No.724603153 [Report] >>724603934 >>724603941
>>724577362 (OP)
Are these games actually bad or are people just bitter about how the split between Natsume and Story of Seasons went down?
Anonymous No.724603352 [Report]
>>724592313
i agree. stardew valley is boring. i hate how you have to spend so much time collecting resources to do anything
Anonymous No.724603504 [Report]
minecraft has comfy farm mechanics. i kind of wish it was a farming game
Anonymous No.724603617 [Report]
>>724589150
The Grand Bazaar remake is literally the best farming game ever made.
Anonymous No.724603934 [Report]
>>724603153
I think OP is mad about the lack of KB&M, actually.
Anonymous No.724603941 [Report]
>>724603153
They are mobile-tier trash
Pirate one of the 3DS ones and see it for yourself
Anonymous No.724605774 [Report]
>>724598117
some people still don't know about the split
Anonymous No.724606718 [Report]
>>724582912
I've played Stardew Valley to completion and single player games can have other games in the genre without being forced to compete.
The problem is that your game would probably not be worth playing even without SDV existing.
Anonymous No.724606918 [Report]
>>724592313
>returned to form
nice try
Anonymous No.724607012 [Report]
>>724594536
Not sure what you felt forced to do as the game never ends.
Personally, I just like setting ingame goals and carrying them out. Planting a certain number of a specific crop, reaching a certain floor in the dungeon, seeing my farm grow outwards.
Anonymous No.724607039 [Report]
I'm a nigger, nobody will read this.
Anonymous No.724607095 [Report] >>724607186 >>724608841
I know it's not quite the same, but thoughts on Sakuna?
Anonymous No.724607173 [Report]
Has anyone been getting that retarded captcha asking for only characters under circles, but they put fucking diamonds and pretend those are circles?
Anonymous No.724607186 [Report]
>>724607095
Sakuna is a good game. I don't have much to say about it other than it feels good to play, is charming, and deserves every bit of success it got but doesn't deserve to be milked by gacha like what marvelous is going to do.
Anonymous No.724607586 [Report] >>724608821 >>724611094
>>724597090
Well you couldn't fuck Ventuswill despite how hard they pushed it in a game where you could fuck all the inferior options and then they made a dlc VN where they dangled that fact over your head.
So yeah, never backing anything like this ever.
Anonymous No.724607823 [Report]
>>724595561
Popuri SEX
Anonymous No.724608821 [Report]
>>724607586
This. Why do this other than to be dicks about it?
Anonymous No.724608841 [Report]
>>724607095
Sakuna is great, love the detail that went into the rice farming and the gameplay otherwise is very fun too. I hope they expand on it someday and start adding other grains to care for in as much depth as the rice farming was.
Anonymous No.724609392 [Report]
>>724589275
It's great. They did really good with that one. Looks so pretty, music is excellent, characters are great (best mayor in any farm game), and preparing for and participating in the bazaar is so much fun.
Anonymous No.724609489 [Report]
>>724587502
his next game will be even better
Anonymous No.724609515 [Report]
>>724578330
Story of Seasons are also soulless garbage nowadays.
Anonymous No.724609538 [Report]
>>724592313
very bad post
Anonymous No.724609625 [Report]
>>724585247
It's not the best but you can have some fun with it. Grand bazaar, the most recent one, fixes almost all the problems Poot had.
Anonymous No.724609686 [Report]
>>724589275
This year's releases have been a great turnaround for both the story of seasons and rune factory games. They were really at deaths door before this.
Anonymous No.724609710 [Report]
>>724595950
New purple waifu acquired.
Anonymous No.724609828 [Report]
>>724577362 (OP)
I heard winds of anthros is actually not too bad all things considered.
Anonymous No.724610030 [Report]
>>724582912
Just add tits.
Anonymous No.724610153 [Report]
>>724577362 (OP)
Its time to return white man
Anonymous No.724610557 [Report]
>>724592313
I've been playing harvest moon since back to nature on ps1. I also can't get into stardew valley. It just feels like indie slop to me. I don't like hollow knight either if that makes any difference. I think those people can enjoy it, but they're like a different generation from me. I'd rather play story of seasons on the ds/3ds.
Anonymous No.724610702 [Report] >>724611173
>>724577362 (OP)
Harvest Moon hasn't been good since the Gameboy game.
Anonymous No.724610808 [Report] >>724611130 >>724611832
>>724595950
Obvious soulless kickstarter scam. If all you need is your name attached to the rune factory series, then this would have been good.
https://store.steampowered.com/app/2904100/Elrentaros_Wanderings/
Anonymous No.724611094 [Report]
>>724607586
Retard, those people were fired when Neverland was dissolved
They had nothing to do with Special
Anonymous No.724611130 [Report]
>>724610808
The difference being that the RF people behind that game you posted are not responsible for how the games actually play. They are idea people that need to recruit a team to actually make the game. And so they get the bottom of the barrel newbies on a limited budget to make a game and to no one's surprise it's not good.

Whereas the kickstarter game has the guy that actually made the RF games play that way working on it, and needs the idea people to help him. They are not the same.
Anonymous No.724611173 [Report]
>>724610702
For a long time, I thought when people said they liked friends of mineral town, I thought they were talking about the gameboy game.
Anonymous No.724611832 [Report]
>>724610808
>Look good
>Review : Negative (16)