← Home ← Back to /v/

Thread 725499091

168 posts 70 images /v/
Anonymous No.725499091 [Report] >>725499147 >>725499193 >>725499258 >>725499263 >>725499340 >>725499485 >>725499490 >>725499917 >>725499918 >>725500324 >>725503769 >>725506578 >>725508617 >>725509550 >>725514421 >>725518724 >>725519449 >>725519884 >>725522347 >>725522778 >>725523102 >>725523570 >>725525623 >>725525876 >>725526507 >>725527041 >>725531057 >>725539330 >>725540315 >>725542463 >>725545589 >>725547675 >>725548518 >>725550074 >>725550730 >>725561841
How come we never got a Legend of Zelda RPG or something like that? I feel like it’d fit right in just like Mario did.
Anonymous No.725499147 [Report] >>725550707
>>725499091 (OP)
Because.
Anonymous No.725499193 [Report]
>>725499091 (OP)
nintendo are retards
they managed to ruin paper mario and the mario & luigi rpgs
pretty impressive honestly
Anonymous No.725499258 [Report] >>725524967 >>725553559 >>725554452
>>725499091 (OP)
I convinced Miyamoto that it would be destroy the integrity of the franchise.
Anonymous No.725499263 [Report] >>725499347 >>725500568 >>725531925 >>725550479
>>725499091 (OP)
inb4 some retard says Zelda is already an RPG because "you play the role of Link."
Anonymous No.725499340 [Report] >>725503435
>>725499091 (OP)
RPGs sell than Ubisoft sandboxes.
Anonymous No.725499347 [Report] >>725499820
>>725499263
>Inb4 some retard says objective fact
Lol
Anonymous No.725499348 [Report]
Nintendo is but a humble indie company, please understand
Anonymous No.725499485 [Report] >>725500673 >>725507386 >>725525019
>>725499091 (OP)
Legend of Zelda is creatively bankrupt.
Anonymous No.725499490 [Report]
>>725499091 (OP)
>Majora's Mask settings
>Toon Link
>Linkle
>Jpg image because OP is a retarded mobilefag
What an awful image. I'm glad Zelda didn't go the route of a full-on RPG. Zelda II was fine enough and of course the casuals shamed it for not being topdown and we never got a follow-up on that style since.
Anonymous No.725499820 [Report] >>725558072
>>725499347
My favorite RPG is Microsoft Flight Sim, because you role play as a pilot.
Anonymous No.725499917 [Report] >>725503905 >>725507270
>>725499091 (OP)
They'd never make a SRPG out of it because that'd step on FE's toes.
They COULD make a traditional turn based RPG out of it but that's been solidly Mario's territory since the SNES, not even mentioning Pokemon.
I think the most ideal option would be a Dungeon Crawler. Maybe like SMT, where finding your way through a cast of sprawling dungeons is the most important part of it, but without the monster capture parts. Or Etrian Odyssey where you have to map it yourself, if they felt so bold.
Anonymous No.725499918 [Report] >>725504149
>>725499091 (OP)
We would have if 90s-00s culture/economy lasted a while longer.
Anonymous No.725500324 [Report] >>725522979
>>725499091 (OP)
>Deku coming out of the water
Whoever made this isn't actually a Zelda fan.
Anonymous No.725500541 [Report]
make it a shiren mystery game with an in-universe resurrection/time travel mechanics and loads of puzzles dungeons.
Anonymous No.725500568 [Report] >>725522854 >>725531925
>>725499263
Actually, Zelda has had RPG elements ever since Adventure of Link.
You don't know because you've never played it. Get out of here, fake geek girl.
Anonymous No.725500673 [Report] >>725504563 >>725531925 >>725545498
>>725499485
Actually, Zelda is thriving more now than ever.
Anonymous No.725503435 [Report]
>>725499340
Kek
Anonymous No.725503769 [Report] >>725506257
>>725499091 (OP)
>WW Link
>Termina
>Kafei
Retarded image.
Anonymous No.725503905 [Report] >>725526340
>>725499917
That makes the most sense, not wanting to create redundancies in their IPs, but I still think a new Zelda that focuses on side scrolling sections would be cool.
Anonymous No.725504149 [Report]
>>725499918
Economy sucked in the 2000s.
Anonymous No.725504392 [Report] >>725504712 >>725505160 >>725505230 >>725531395
I would argue Zelda is an action rpg
Anonymous No.725504563 [Report]
>>725500673
I want to cuddle with him
Anonymous No.725504712 [Report] >>725505959
>>725504392
That's because it is.
Anonymous No.725505160 [Report]
>>725504392
Yes but there’s no JRPG
Anonymous No.725505230 [Report] >>725531652 >>725550074
>>725504392
The action-adventure label is accurate in this case. You'd have to squint and say "well heart containers are kind of like stats, it's kind of like levelling up"--yeah but it isn't.
Anonymous No.725505959 [Report]
>>725504712
Baste
Anonymous No.725506257 [Report]
>>725503769
Don't forget that trash from HW instead of Zelda or even Tetra given the art style.
Anonymous No.725506578 [Report] >>725507220 >>725530562
>>725499091 (OP)
Konjak never finished his Zelda parody, huh? Shame, Noitu Love 2 was actually pretty stellar.
Anonymous No.725507220 [Report] >>725507834
>>725506578
Damn what’s this?
Anonymous No.725507270 [Report] >>725511407
Why do zelda fans feel the need to argue that it's an RPG? Not being an RPG is fine, there's nothing wrong with being a pure action adventure game.
That being said >>725499917 has the right idea, a DRPG zelda spinoff could be awesome.
Anonymous No.725507386 [Report] >>725507648 >>725540602
>>725499485
It really feels like it these days.
Anonymous No.725507648 [Report]
>>725507386
Facts. ToTK was a disgrace
Anonymous No.725507834 [Report]
>>725507220
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XhLNyHkAdNM
Anonymous No.725507890 [Report]
why do you fags want a franchise to be everlasting and consist of every single genre and to see the same setting and characters forever? Just try something new for christ's sake.
Anonymous No.725508617 [Report] >>725508940
>>725499091 (OP)
A lot of it is novelty factor.
A Mario RPG was a novel idea because Mario was, in both gameplay and setting, very unlike an RPG.
Zelda was the opposite. Hyrule was a very RPG-esque setting and Zelda's gameplay was already typically RPG-adjacent.
I wouldn't say Zelda was an RPG to begin with, as some would, but to pretend it wasn't originally butting shoulders with games like Ys and Dragon Quest would just be reductive.
Anonymous No.725508940 [Report] >>725509426
>>725508617
This. A turn-based Zelda RPG would just feel like a generic RPG. Maybe if you kept the focus on puzzles in dungeons it might kind of work as its own thing, but at the same time, random encounters makes solving puzzles a pain in the ass because you forget what you were doing (happens in Golden Sun).
Anonymous No.725509426 [Report]
>>725508940
Eh I guess
Anonymous No.725509550 [Report]
>>725499091 (OP)
I'd guess they feel like it'd be too close to the main series. Note the developers of the original Hyrule Warriors wanted to do a structure closer to an actual Zelda game (with exploration areas and dungeons), but with the musou combat, but were told to just do a standard musou with Zelda spice.
Anonymous No.725511407 [Report] >>725512620 >>725522289
>>725507270
>Why do zelda fans feel the need to argue that it's an RPG?
New argument that's been generating a good amount of engagement lately. Currently in open testing before the bots get trained to use it.
Anonymous No.725512620 [Report] >>725513026
>>725511407
Fag
Anonymous No.725513026 [Report] >>725514209
>>725512620
You should be proud, generating engagement for Hiro and the advertisers is the most useful thing you've done since you came to this website.
Anonymous No.725514209 [Report]
>>725513026
I ghess
Anonymous No.725514421 [Report] >>725516678 >>725518196
>>725499091 (OP)
Miyamoto hates turn based games
Anonymous No.725516678 [Report] >>725518196
>>725514421
Miyamoto seems even less involved with zelda than he does mario
Anonymous No.725518196 [Report]
>>725514421
>>725516678
Miyamoto literally JUST said he doesn't do anything with Mario anymore so long as he likes the first 30 minutes.
Anonymous No.725518724 [Report] >>725518857 >>725522513 >>725525401
>>725499091 (OP)
Legend of Zelda barely has a story. It's like the most generic hero quest ever.
>Ganon is bad, zelda is captured, go collect the collectables, get the holy sword, and beat him.
Anonymous No.725518857 [Report] >>725519313 >>725520180
>>725518724
>replies to image portraying a Zelda game where none of that is true
Anonymous No.725519313 [Report] >>725519461
>>725518857
I don't remember MM having RPG combat. With a party system. Or the unique Deku enemy that you fight in the Laundry Pool. Or the Tingle Mask. Or Linkle.
Think, anon, THINK before you call someone else stupid. Even if he is retarded.
Anonymous No.725519449 [Report] >>725526419
>>725499091 (OP)
Real answer: Miyamoto liked RPGs like Wizardry and Ultima of the time, but he never liked the concept of magic (he thinks of it as a shortcut) or progression systems. That's why you have magic items, and the only reason why Zelda 2 even has a progression system is because Dragon Quest 1 came out between Zelda 1 and Zelda 2, and he had a mostly new team. I suspect that when he went back to 1's style in ALttP, he cribbed its notes, and when he passed it off to Aonuma around MM, he probably conditioned Aonuma to be disgusted by the idea of it through upending the tea table and regular beatings.
Anonymous No.725519461 [Report]
>>725519313
I bet you really thought you did something here.
Anonymous No.725519884 [Report] >>725523401
>>725499091 (OP)
anon, zelda is an rpg
Anonymous No.725520180 [Report] >>725520343 >>725525447 >>725525501 >>725550661
>>725518857
>I want a Zelda RPG but want it based on a cult spinoff game that is nothing like any of the other games.
Plot was still generic and boring.
>Mask kid is bad, moon is falling, go collect the collectables, get the holy super mask, and beat him.
There is nothing to make an RPG about. Link has no character or character development. No plot complexity. No party, Midna was the closest, fairies are an annoyance who do nothing. No characters in the world with any personality beyond generic NPC.
Mario RPGs also sucked.
Anonymous No.725520343 [Report] >>725521809
>>725520180
Guaranteed this is the same faggot that was arguing that Zelda had no story or worldbuilding in the timeline thread the other day.
Anonymous No.725520869 [Report]
>Zelda was never a RPG

...
Anonymous No.725521809 [Report] >>725522172
>>725520343
>Guaranteed this is the same faggot that was arguing that Zelda had no story or worldbuilding in the timeline thread the other day.
Nope. It has minimal lore to tie games together which relies heavily on fans and external info that is not in the actual games.
Sorry to shit in your cereal. It is a fun game but the story is generic shit and only the bare minimum meant to move the gameplay along.
You probably think Dark Souls is some amazing story as well right?
I doubt you actually play any significant number of RPGs so why ask for one? It is fine being an action/puzzle game.
Anonymous No.725522172 [Report] >>725522281
>>725521809
You are an engagement farmer.
Anonymous No.725522281 [Report] >>725522401 >>725525569
>>725522172
>You are an engagement farmer.
Anonymous No.725522289 [Report]
>>725511407
>new
You seem to be the only new thing around here
Anonymous No.725522347 [Report] >>725523168
>>725499091 (OP)
Better question: why have we never gotten a smash bros rpg?
Anonymous No.725522401 [Report] >>725522518 >>725525569
>>725522281
>bumped the thread about a series he doesn't care about
Thanks for confirming this is a farming thread.
Anonymous No.725522513 [Report] >>725523236
>>725518724
>rpg needs story
And other ways to out yourself as a midwit
Anonymous No.725522518 [Report]
>>725522401
>Thanks for confirming this is a farming thread.
Feel free to fuck off at any time and take your valuable engagement elsewhere.
Anonymous No.725522778 [Report]
>>725499091 (OP)
Mario RPG 2 he will wake up and join the party

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JavydMqBUds
Anonymous No.725522854 [Report] >>725523487 >>725539271
>>725500568
>be young stud
>grew up playing hand-me-down N64 and Gamecube
>I fucking love zelda
>read up on the older titles
>"ZELDA 2 FUCKING SUCKS, IT'S TOO HARD!!!"
>decide to play it
>it's one of the greatest games I've ever played
I will never understand the hatred, yes it's much different from Zelda 1 which I prefer, but I still love it to bits!
Anonymous No.725522979 [Report] >>725523284 >>725523535
>>725500324
Happens in Majora's Mask.
Anonymous No.725523102 [Report] >>725525657
>>725499091 (OP)
The only thing Ninty roll Zelda out for besides their once-or-twice a decade obligatory new entry is to promote some shitty piece of tech. Remember when they expected you to actually know 4 people who all have gameboy advances AND connector cables? Fuck you, Nintendo. Start actually caring about this franchise.
Anonymous No.725523168 [Report]
>>725522347
That's dumb. That would just be a Nintendo crossover, not "Smash."
Anonymous No.725523236 [Report] >>725523347 >>725523472
>>725522513
>My modern western hack/slash parryslop slapped an "RPG" label on it to boost sales, therefore RPGs never needed stories or characters.
The normalfagification of the genre is sad.
If everything is an RPG might as well just call botw an RPG then and be done with it.
Anonymous No.725523284 [Report]
>>725522979
No it doesn't, retard.
Anonymous No.725523347 [Report] >>725551419
>>725523236
BotW isn't an RPG because they didn't add the rockets until TotK. At best it's cluster munition.
Anonymous No.725523401 [Report]
>>725519884
It's really not. Unless you think being able to write your own name qualifies.
Anonymous No.725523472 [Report]
>>725523236
I know you're underage so I won't call you a retard but I want you to research a little game called Wizardry.
Anonymous No.725523487 [Report] >>725523580
>>725522854
Getting into a swordfight in that game is still one of the most thrilling things that can happen to you in any video game.
The block low/block high/attack low/attack high gameplay gives it some of the complexity of a fighting game without unnecessary complication.
If they made another game in the same style, they could easily do circle inputs to pull off special moves, and it wouldn't feel out of place.
Anonymous No.725523535 [Report]
>>725522979
You're thinking of the Big Octo in the swamp
Anonymous No.725523570 [Report]
>>725499091 (OP)
retro proposed one and it was going to be dreadfully bad
Anonymous No.725523580 [Report] >>725525757
>>725523487
Unfortunately you are not the ideas guy at Nintendo, instead we get remakes and ports of games we already played
Anonymous No.725524365 [Report] >>725547430
If it was going to be an RPG, I would prefer if it was an SRPG so that there could potentially be some crossover with Fire Emblem.
Anonymous No.725524967 [Report]
>>725499258
Based
Anonymous No.725525019 [Report]
>>725499485
You've been saying that for 30 years, nigger
Anonymous No.725525401 [Report]
>>725518724
>>Ganon is bad, zelda is captured, go collect the collectables, get the holy sword, and beat him.
And that's exactly why it's good and still is 40 years later, kill yourself
Anonymous No.725525447 [Report]
>>725520180
>MM is a spin-off now
lmfao at you "people"
Anonymous No.725525501 [Report]
>>725520180
>It's a TP nigger who doesn't understand Zelda
Anonymous No.725525569 [Report]
>>725522281
>>725522401
You both can die
Anonymous No.725525623 [Report]
>>725499091 (OP)
>Termina
>WW Link
>Linkle
>Kafei
>Water scrubs??
I don't even give a shit about the thread topic. This image infuriates the shit out of me.
Anonymous No.725525657 [Report] >>725525738 >>725526106
>>725523102
>Friendless faggot still seething because he couldn't play four swords 11 years after the fact
Impressive
Anonymous No.725525738 [Report] >>725525968
>>725525657
yeah yeah I'll bet you played 4-player all with your own link cable, you fuckin poser
Anonymous No.725525757 [Report] >>725535345
>>725523580
>Making games available in modern platforms is... le bad
>You're supposed to pay $500 for a discontinued 25 year old hardware, goy
Fuck off retard
Anonymous No.725525876 [Report]
>>725499091 (OP)
retro(the american metroid guys) were making one at one point, but it got canned.

i don't think turn based combat and stat managing fit zelda.
Anonymous No.725525968 [Report] >>725526191
>>725525738
I just played the anniversary edition on 3DS
The original four swords also came with ALttP so it's not like you didn't have anything to play without 4 other friends
Anonymous No.725526106 [Report]
>>725525657
I fucked up, it's been 21 years not 11
Anonymous No.725526191 [Report] >>725526238 >>725526418
>>725525968
The whole draw is the new game on the disc, fucknuts. Otherwise it would just be a port.
Anonymous No.725526238 [Report] >>725526305
>>725526191
>disc
Anonymous No.725526305 [Report] >>725526538
>>725526238
Yes, the original game was on cube, fucknugget. The game I was talking about.
Anonymous No.725526340 [Report]
>>725503905
Adventure Of Link should've gotten a 16-bit or a 32-bit (DS) remake, or both
Anonymous No.725526346 [Report]
I have Zelda fatigue, make a turn-based Metroid instead. Mario + Rabbids style.
Anonymous No.725526418 [Report] >>725526536
>>725526191
Give me a break, anon. Four Swords amounts to being a multiplayer mode, it's such a nothingburger of a game standalone you might as well pretend it's just an ALttP port
Anonymous No.725526419 [Report]
>>725519449
how many cigarette burns do you think Aonuma is hiding?
Anonymous No.725526507 [Report]
>>725499091 (OP)
That'd be a downgrade.
Anonymous No.725526536 [Report] >>725526619
>>725526418
My original point was Nintendo just carts Zelda around to sell hardware gimmicks. Saying "just focus on the 12 year old game (at the time)" doesn't really feel like you proved me wrong.
Anonymous No.725526538 [Report] >>725526628
>>725526305
That's Four Swords Adventures and it came out later than the GBA one
Anonymous No.725526619 [Report]
>>725526536
What Nintendo IP doesn't? Metroid?
There's nothing to "prove wrong" here because it's not an issue
Anonymous No.725526628 [Report] >>725526919
>>725526538
The Gamecube game used the GBA systems and link cables.
Anonymous No.725526919 [Report]
>>725526628
Disgusting how they demanded you to buy additional hardware to have access to the content that was already right there on the disc.
Anonymous No.725527041 [Report] >>725527785
>>725499091 (OP)
The series already has light "RPG" element in the form of the heart system and an actual leveling up system with Zelda 2 so it's kind of silly to make a full on RPG.
Anonymous No.725527785 [Report]
>>725527041
"Leveling up" in 2 is hardly substantial enough to call the entire series "RPG." Adventure of Link is an oddball, not the standard. You may as well not even cite it.

Also, you wouldn't call Metroid or Megaman X an RPG for having extendable health bars.
Anonymous No.725530562 [Report]
>>725506578
i'm glad the fucker at least posted the demo instead of letting it rot on his desktop for all eternity
so much of the early indie tigsource crowd gatekept the shit out of their work it's annoying how the few things they did share publically are gone now that the site is half dead and most links are broken
Anonymous No.725531003 [Report]
Not sure honestly. Nintendo do loan out Zelda for spinoffs, hence why we have the Warriors games, Candence of Hyrule and the Tingle games (which believe it or not were actually damn good games. We just hated Tingle so much we never got them).

Maybe they feel a full RPG could clash with their main series games (They have some RPG elements) so shut down any pitches for one.
Anonymous No.725531057 [Report] >>725531454 >>725532515 >>725540760
>>725499091 (OP)
>How come we never got a Legend of Zelda RPG
what the fuck do you think the zelda games are? a colony sim?
Anonymous No.725531395 [Report]
>>725504392
And you'd be wrong.
Anonymous No.725531454 [Report]
>>725531057
Action-RPG is not exactly the same as a plain traditional RPG.
Anonymous No.725531652 [Report]
>>725505230
>mana khemia isn't a jrpg because there is no levels
Anonymous No.725531925 [Report]
>>725499263
genuinely hate those retards
RPG is such a shitty term
everybody SHOULD know RPG is 4 niggas in a row TURN BASED combat
>>725500568
>you can le raise your stats so it's an Role Playing G-ACK!
>>725500673
the turbosissy post SNES link vs the chad VRIL elven bottle nosed zelda 1-3 + GB lunk even CDi hell
if you want to be a fag and fuck link at least be based and fuck dark world rabbit boy link
Anonymous No.725532515 [Report] >>725533583
>>725531057
Zelda is different to a traditional RPG and you know it anon. Even Zelda 2 which leaned in more heavily with an exp system and a different gameplay battle phase was distinguishable from traditional RPG's.

Honestly though I'd like them to do a new Zelda 2 inspired game rather than a full-on RPG. If making it a spinoff is the only possibility of that, then so be it.
Anonymous No.725533583 [Report] >>725534115 >>725534117
>>725532515
are you trying to say that a roleplaying game is a game with EXP? or that a role-playing game must be turn-based?

zelda is the quintessential rpg
Anonymous No.725534115 [Report]
>>725533583
It's more of an action adventure game than a rpg.
Anonymous No.725534117 [Report] >>725534445
>>725533583
I'm saying what OP means is a turn based RPG in the vein of something like Final Fantasy or Chrono Trigger (turn based or real-time), which Zelda, even Zelda 2 definitively is not.

They definitely could make one though, particularly as a spinoff.
Anonymous No.725534445 [Report]
>>725534117
well you're thinking of what i'd call "dragon quest-likes". isn't that just what we call JRPGs? zelda isn't a jrpg.

role playing games (RPGs) are much broader, even if they are made in japan. for example kings field is an RPG according to fromsoft.
Anonymous No.725535345 [Report] >>725536340
>>725525757
No, there's nothing wrong with making old games readily available, there's however something wrong with making old games readily available at the same price of new games
Anonymous No.725536340 [Report]
>>725535345
Facts
Anonymous No.725539271 [Report]
>>725522854
Seeing Link(s)’s face in your pic reminds me of Miyamoto from Baki
Anonymous No.725539330 [Report]
>>725499091 (OP)
Too interesting
Anonymous No.725539506 [Report]
I think Zelda is better as an action-adventure rather than a full-rpg. I think they could bring back RPG-like elements though, given how soulslikes are basically the same thing.
Anonymous No.725540246 [Report] >>725540517 >>725545219 >>725552852
Zelda spin-offs I want
>Metal Gear Shiek
>CUH-RAZY Character Action/Beat-em Up starring Ganondorf
>Zelda Maker
Anonymous No.725540315 [Report]
>>725499091 (OP)
Nintendo experimented a little with Zelda II, decided it wasn't really for the series (the CD-I games that tried to copy that gameplay afterward didn't help), and gave Mario the RPG treatment instead lol.
Anonymous No.725540517 [Report] >>725552852
>>725540246
>>CUH-RAZY Character Action/Beat-em Up starring Ganondorf
>Stranger of Hyrule: Legend of Zelda Origins
More of a Nioh and less DMC. Do it Nintendo.
Anonymous No.725540602 [Report]
>>725507386
>these days
You mean since forever? Majora's Mask was the first and only hint of creative originality in the entire series
Anonymous No.725540760 [Report]
>>725531057
action/puzzle
Anonymous No.725542463 [Report] >>725544243
>>725499091 (OP)
TLOZ *is* an RPG you magnificent retard
Anonymous No.725544243 [Report]
>>725542463
Source: the Jews told me so
Anonymous No.725545219 [Report] >>725552852
>>725540246
After the success of Echoes of Wisdom, we might get more games starring Zelda and her various personas.
Anonymous No.725545498 [Report] >>725545841
>>725500673
>now associated with crossdressing and troonerism in generic uibsoft style open world slop
That's like saying someone who has HIV from fag sex is thriving because they have to live off a cocktail of drugs instead of dying to a cold.
Anonymous No.725545589 [Report] >>725554520
>>725499091 (OP)
Because Nintendo only has to put the bare minimum work and it will sell millions
Making a game in a whole new genre is too much work especially a genre that is unpopular (TBS)
Anonymous No.725545841 [Report]
>>725545498
Except the series is more successful now than it's ever been.
Anonymous No.725547430 [Report] >>725547479 >>725547625 >>725548034 >>725552683
>>725524365
>Fire Emblem
You want Zelda to be a dating sim?
Anonymous No.725547479 [Report]
>>725547430
Boy do I.
Anonymous No.725547625 [Report]
>>725547430
Yes but with men only.
Anonymous No.725547675 [Report]
>>725499091 (OP)
How would you even make one that doesn't make it Zelda but you get interrupted randomly by turn based combat? The mainline games already do dungeon exploring and Link is pretty much an silent RPG protag already.
Anonymous No.725548034 [Report]
>>725547430
Yes, but that has nothing to do with what was posted.
Anonymous No.725548518 [Report]
>>725499091 (OP)
>How come we never got a Legend of Zelda RPG
........... what the fuck do you think Legend of Zelda is, exactly?
Anonymous No.725549202 [Report]
Are you all taking crazy pills? Zelda isn't an rpg and the only one that came close was Zelda II, and even that was stretching.

It would be more reasonable to call it a Metroidvania
Anonymous No.725550074 [Report] >>725550679
>>725499091 (OP)
Zelda as a series takes the best elements of RPGs, does those things much better than almost every actual JRPG by making everything fully integrated into the world (no separate 'battle system' nonsense), making the worlds highly interactive and dynamic and able to change and react to everything you do, allowing you to discover things that uniquely change what your abilities are, and just generally being incredibly immersive and making used of creative and original kinds of storytelling, and does this whlie throwing away most of the things that suck about RPGs, like all the grindy non-interactive garbage and meaningless fluff mechanics that waste your time.

A 'Zelda RPG' would be completely pointless because it would be just like a shittier version of what Zelda normally is, with no advantages because JRPGs rarely have interesting, strategic combat or anything that isn't essentially overcome by getting more powerful and in combat abilities can't be used consistently outside of that.

>>725505230
Heart Containers are a great example of something Zelda handles in a way that is flat out superior to what RPGs normally do. Having to do unique things to gain power and life beats grinding in every possible way.
Anonymous No.725550479 [Report] >>725561982
>>725499263
It was advertised as an Action RPG. Miyamoto also referred to it as an ARPG many times
Anonymous No.725550661 [Report]
>>725520180
>No characters in the world with any personality beyond generic NPC
I have no doubt you're actually serious when you say this about MM, because this kind of thing would just sound too ignorant for someone deliberately trolling to say. But I'm kind of honestly not surprised a hardline JRPGfag would be this incapable of noticing basic things about a game and unaware of any nuance not completely spoonfed through forced cutscenes.
Anonymous No.725550667 [Report] >>725551415
I don’t want Zelda to be an RPG. They ruined Castlevania by making them RPGs.
Anonymous No.725550679 [Report]
>>725550074
>Having to do unique things to gain power and life beats grinding in every possible way
Very well said.
Anonymous No.725550707 [Report]
>>725499147
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/hhwSCa-RKl0
Anonymous No.725550730 [Report]
>>725499091 (OP)
Zelda would translate beautifully to an RPG setting.
I always wanted a Paper Zelda
Anonymous No.725551415 [Report]
>>725550667
What, you didn't like Symphony of the Night?
Anonymous No.725551419 [Report]
>>725523347
Booooooooooooo
Anonymous No.725552683 [Report] >>725561504
>>725547430
Yes but only lolis
Anonymous No.725552852 [Report] >>725553363
>>725540246
>>725540517
>What if a [other franchise] but Zelda
lol fuck off
>>725545219
I liked EoW but that's a dangerious precedent
Anonymous No.725553363 [Report]
>>725552852
Dangerous? In what way?
Anonymous No.725553559 [Report]
>>725499258
where were you for SS and Botw?!
Anonymous No.725554452 [Report]
>>725499258
Tanabe… You haven’t worked on a Zelda game since 1998.
Anonymous No.725554520 [Report]
>>725545589
Except they often put in so much work that it baffles those in the industry.
Anonymous No.725555119 [Report] >>725555295
jap nintendo suits seethe at dragon quest being more beloved and embraced in japan.
Anonymous No.725555295 [Report]
>>725555119
I highly doubt that.
Anonymous No.725555391 [Report] >>725557008
>snoy falseflagging with Gerudo twink images
Anonymous No.725557008 [Report]
>>725555391
I'm a Gerudo enjoyer.
Anonymous No.725557763 [Report]
Zelda RPG with romanceable Tulin
Anonymous No.725557921 [Report]
the whole point of zelda is it's an adventure game not an rpg, rpgs are cancer compared to zelda, it's a point of pride it hasn't succumb to rpg insanity.
Anonymous No.725558072 [Report] >>725559719
>>725499820
that's fallacious, "pilot" is just "player one" not a person with a name and story.
Anonymous No.725559719 [Report]
>>725558072
Unless you want to consider Zelda games 'Link Simulators'.
Anonymous No.725560475 [Report]
Anonymous No.725561504 [Report]
>>725552683
We love lolis.
Anonymous No.725561841 [Report]
>>725499091 (OP)
>why doesn't Nintendo make games that compete against Nintendo's games that are currently selling for 60 dollars?
Anonymous No.725561982 [Report]
>>725550479
Telltale marketed their post-Walking Dead "games" as point-and-click adventures. Doesn't mean shit.