Why'd they replace him with Tympole? - /vp/ (#58003690) [Archived: 394 hours ago]

Anonymous
7/16/2025, 5:26:49 AM No.58003690
beta_snail_pokemon_evo_line_by_nintenpatri_difesad-pre
Replies: >>58004305 >>58004484 >>58004514 >>58004523 >>58004534 >>58004841 >>58004853
Anonymous
7/16/2025, 5:39:48 AM No.58003713
Too much design overlap with two, maybe three other Pokemon they liked better. Like the water starter having a shell is bad enough, but there's also a shelled bug type they liked as well, on top of a shelled water type fossil that's slightly shield like and probably only knocked it out of contention by being a water type and them wanting to not have a billion water types because Gen 5 was the first time they gave a shit about type balance remotely. Not surprised they cut it, but I'm also not surprised they kept it around and tried to make it work for a little bit before giving up.
Anonymous
7/16/2025, 11:05:28 AM No.58004305
>>58003690 (OP)
his coolness was unnerfable
Anonymous
7/16/2025, 1:36:35 PM No.58004484
IMG_0277
IMG_0277
md5: 61f3df4a30c3db3a8022314993973f03๐Ÿ”
>>58003690 (OP)
>Thereโ€™s like two water type lines that utilize shells
>Escavalier covers the snail knight concept while providing type balance

Not surprised it became tumor toad
Anonymous
7/16/2025, 2:01:09 PM No.58004514
>>58003690 (OP)
because the oshawott line also uses shell design motiffs
Anonymous
7/16/2025, 2:08:03 PM No.58004523
>>58003690 (OP)
Tympole line is way better, betafags are drooling retards.
Replies: >>58004718
Anonymous
7/16/2025, 2:10:59 PM No.58004534
>>58003690 (OP)
Honestly one of the only beta lines I think had good potential with some design tweaking, better starter potential than the rejected gen 2 water starter line.
Anonymous
7/16/2025, 3:48:28 PM No.58004718
>>58004523
>betafags are drooling retards
This. The only beta leak that had some good designs that got cut/reworked was gen 2 and even then people way overblow it.
Anonymous
7/16/2025, 4:56:42 PM No.58004841
>>58003690 (OP)
because unova is a kanto rehash, and they didn't need slowbro 2.0 they needed poliwrath 2.0
Anonymous
7/16/2025, 5:00:27 PM No.58004853
>>58003690 (OP)
the pool toy that can't use his swords stole his spot
Replies: >>58004861
Anonymous
7/16/2025, 5:02:50 PM No.58004861
>>58004853
>can't use his swords
Nice fanfic
Replies: >>58004864
Anonymous
7/16/2025, 5:03:44 PM No.58004864
>>58004861
>even sagefag agrees it's a pool toy now
kek