Thread 58097585 - /vp/ [Archived: 22 hours ago]

Anonymous
8/9/2025, 9:55:34 PM No.58097585
Pokemon-item-elemental-gems
Pokemon-item-elemental-gems
md5: 7eadfc03313839f4cf2404dfd178ff20🔍
Did gems deserve to be removed after gen 5?
Replies: >>58097604 >>58097622 >>58097664 >>58097707 >>58097714 >>58097797
Anonymous
8/9/2025, 9:59:05 PM No.58097595
Yeah
Anonymous
8/9/2025, 10:00:19 PM No.58097604
>>58097585 (OP)
I understand removing them in favor of Z-Moves, but now that we have neither it doesn't make much sense.
Anonymous
8/9/2025, 10:01:16 PM No.58097610
Gamefreak realized how broken they are before competitive players and removed them themselves
Replies: >>58097712
Anonymous
8/9/2025, 10:03:39 PM No.58097622
>>58097585 (OP)
Aren’t they banned with smoggies
Anonymous
8/9/2025, 10:16:41 PM No.58097664
>>58097585 (OP)
Coal decision.
Anonymous
8/9/2025, 10:26:51 PM No.58097707
>>58097585 (OP)
Normal gem is still in the game
Anonymous
8/9/2025, 10:27:48 PM No.58097712
>>58097610
They were nerfed and then removed later on. The nerf was compounded by later gens having strong defensive checks.
Replies: >>58097720
Anonymous
8/9/2025, 10:28:26 PM No.58097714
>>58097585 (OP)
so why do people pretend mega evolution is the first regional gimmick again?
Replies: >>58097725
Anonymous
8/9/2025, 10:29:57 PM No.58097720
>>58097712
The nerf might've been just an effect of a lot of moves having their base power lowered coming into Gen 6
Replies: >>58098815
Anonymous
8/9/2025, 10:30:44 PM No.58097725
>>58097714
Where Gems even revealed before release? A big part of a gimmick is it being attention grabbing, and the gems very much aren't that. They're great items but they're not something that would excite anyone but the competitive playerbase.
Anonymous
8/9/2025, 10:48:50 PM No.58097797
>>58097585 (OP)
Yes. The gems and the sound effects in that gen's pokedex reminded me too much of Spyro, who I love from the bottom of my heart, but it nonetheless took me a bit out of my immersion.
Anonymous
8/10/2025, 3:30:06 AM No.58098815
>>58097720
The gems were nerfed from 1.5x to 1.3x but they were not removed from the gen 6 games' code. They were just never made obtainable, other than the normal gem. There was also a fairy gem in the games' code.