>>11775350 (OP)I've played
1 (nes emu): still think this holds up really well, it feels way more obviously ultima and D&D the others and I like being able to pick different class load outs for a different game experience 7/10
1 (gba): maybe I'm a casual but I actually enjoy this version more, it's the one I replay at least. Cool QoL and cool visual update. 8/10
2 (gba): despite getting shat on for the weird stat and magic leveling mechanics I quite liked this, story is very 80s Hollywood in a fantasy setting and some of the characters are cool. The rebirth of souls bonus game in the gba version is sick. 6/10
3 (DS): I hated this. The guys all feel like literal who's and the class changing is so clunky. Doing anything feels like a slog and I just couldn't be bothered to finish the final dungeon with a bunch of boring boss rematches. There are some interesting story bits but overall I wouldn't bother. 3/10
4 (gba): I also hated a lot of this. Most of the party members feel like they're just sat there silently after they finish their short and boring arc. It's supposed to be about Cecil becoming a better guy but he only succeeds because an endless stream of losers sacrifice themselves for the plot to progress. ||And then come back making the sacrifice meaningless anyway|| Felt like a slog, and the spells all have a weird delay on top of the ATB. 4/10
5 (gba, snes emu): love this and have replayed it a bunch. Story manages to stay engaging despite being lighthearted, characters are all lovable, job system is flawless. Has some fantastic moments and is tragically underrated. 10/10
6 (snes emu, gba, snes with the woolsey uncensored patch): you will already find many other anons to tell you how great this is. Built on the foundations of 4 and improved literally everything. Story can get messy at times with so many characters, but again it has some unforgettable moments. The esper system is a cool precursor to the 3D era materia and junction systems. 9/10