rpgs you find the most immersive?

Modded TES, Witcher 3. I also found Final Fantasy X extremely immersive back in the day.

>>3767993 (OP)
Minecraft

>>3767993 (OP)
TES, Cyberpunk 2077, Dragon Age Origins, Baldur's Gate 2, Fallout 1, and I'll mention Stalker too.

>>3768014
modded stalkers a good one

>>3767993 (OP)
Final Fantasy 1, because I can play my own party and not be bogged down by some failed anime writer's snowflake characters.

>>3767993 (OP)
Life.

>>3768005
What makes w3 immersive? I find that the story collapses near the end. That was also when the game wasn't fun to play anymore.

>>3768126
The sole reason I hope for iwd 3

>>3768208
NTA, didn't even finish the game, but I found myself absorbed by the environments, music, stories and characters. A somber tone seems to do it for me.

>>3767993 (OP)
The ones that have life sim elements. Like Conan Exiles, Ultima Underworld, UnReal World.

>>3767993 (OP)

>>3768228
What's wrong with her thighs? Is this rickets?

>>3768219
Is that alone. I still claim that w3 has side quests that are incorparated into main quests, at least some of them. Should be the norm and could certainly be done better. Problem is that games aren't made for gamers.

>>3768260
>somber tone
Is that it, that's the sole reason? "
From a technical standpoint I think it's clear that stories in games don't have a high standard. Which is a shame, really.

>>3768261
>Is that it, that's the sole reason?
No. It's one reason among the others I mentioned, you dumbass. What's wrong with you

>>3768230
foot binding probably

>>3768219
>absorbed by the environments, music, stories and characters.
>>3768266
Wtf illiterate or blind?

Kingdom Come: Deliverance

>>3767993 (OP)
deus ex

>>3767993 (OP)
Gotta define immersive. Modded Skyrim is about the best when it comes to the amount of things you can make it do, including the most basic stuff like using furniture or ingame writing for your RP.
I personally have a preference for fantasy in an urban setting, an itch which I got from Hunter x Hunter and which FFXV rubs somewhat, although the game is so incomplete on a number of levels.

>>3770443
in a MODERN setting, urban or not*

>>3768228
kino rpg

>>3767993 (OP)
VTM Bloodlines

>>3767993 (OP)
The Witcher 3 only
Kingdom Come Deliverance
Cyberpunk 2077
The Elder Scrolls Skyrim
Fallout 3

For me it was Fallout 3 and maybe 4

>>3767993 (OP)
Dark Souls, back when I first played it. The world felt dangerous and I didn't know what to expect, just slowly trying to make my way through the trials. Then the first invasion happened. The decision to not have music at all times was perfect.

>>3767993 (OP)
FFVI's world of ruin feels like an empty MMO to me.
So it's immersive in the sense that I imagine an alternative reality where the SNES was capable of broadband internet connections and FFVI was an MMO that has been abandoned.

>>3767993 (OP)
My favorite is Fallout: New Vegas. I put a lot of points on the Survival skill and other non-combat ones so I can live off the range and dumpster diving as much as possible. It's really great to wait until it's dark to craft a bunch of steaks for the road.

>>3775407
Fo4 for me for similar reasons

>Campfire + Wet & Cold
>Some mod for darker nights
>Out exploring
>Late afternoon / early evening
>"Better set up camp soon"
>Look for a comfy spot with trees nearby
>Magic hour, purplish red sunset
>Find comfy spot
>Start a fire
>set up tent
>Get cooking by the fire
>Night falls
>Eat by the fire
>Check map and make plan for the morning
>Drink water
>Watch the sky for a bit
>Crawl into tent and sleep
There are a lot of things wrong with Skyrim but you can max out comfy to 100 in this game
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l64jEr_LuOU

>>3776258
based.

>>3768208
The quest structure is amazing, towns are somewhat interesting, good va, decent characters for the most part. Story does collapse at the end.

>>3776448
>quest structure is amazing
go there and use le spidey sense

>>3776453
I'm not saying the quest beats are awesome. It's how some side quests have multiple solutions and some do change the course of the main quest(s). Side quests having an intro and outro is awesome, too. W3 has plenty of downsides, make no mistake.

>>3776472
Well I can say the quests are awesome. There's no gameplay mechanics for alternative solutions like stealth, but the story "makes up" for it.

Get the premise, investigate, read up on the monster, prepare, combat, then some revelation/twist or choice occurs, all resulting in a nice little witcher story.

Now, if we could merge Witcher 3 with an open world sandbox game, with custom characters and gameplay options for warrior/mage/thief archetypes.. We would be approaching a perfect RPG.

>>3776481
Yup, that's what w4 should've been. That's what they promised for quite a while. What we got was ciri boss.

>>3776490
>That's what they promised for quite a while
Where..?

>>3776493
I don't archive the Internet. Even before cp2077 came out, word was that ciri won't be the protag. No one believed this ofc, as most devs are notorious liars. You might check out old forum posts.

>>3776522
Source: a youtube comment said
>hey guise wouldnt it be cool if you could make your own gerald??

>>3776535
Meme mind. You do realize that cdpr communicates over multiple channels, even their own forums? They do issue yearly reports, too.

>>3776596
>They do issue yearly reports, too.
I was skeptical at first but now I believe you. It's evident they have lied and betrayed you.

>>3776258
Wish I could do this but remove main quest and just have radiant quests with perma death.

>>3776791
You can bro

>>3767993 (OP)
Cyberpunk 2077 100%

>>3768126
not only are you retarded, but you picked quite possibly the worst rpg that lets you build your whole party.

>>3776791
This is basically what I hope wayward realms can do if it ends up not being vaporware

>>3767993 (OP)
Id have to say probably system shock 2. I haven’t been so stressed before in my life. All the progress in the game feels really rewarding and upgrades really let you have any type of build you want.

>>3781533
You now hear Med Sci 1 in your head

Baldur's Gate 1-2, Fallout 1-2, Planescape Torment, Arcanum, Gothic 2, Morrowind

>>3768230
She just has a huge vagina

Is the lost valley campaign in solasta good?
I didn't like palace of ice.