Anonymous
6/13/2025, 11:00:10 PM No.3781772
Why hasn't this game been remade?
Replies:
Thread 3781772 - /vrpg/ [Archived: 861 hours ago]
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 11:04:15 PM No.3781774
>>3781772 (OP)
Because I'm using my reality altering powers to prevent it.
Because I'm using my reality altering powers to prevent it.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/13/2025, 11:17:27 PM No.3781776
>>3781772 (OP)
It was. For the PS2. You're a retard.
It was. For the PS2. You're a retard.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/14/2025, 12:23:03 PM No.3782039
What's with the obsession with remakes?
Why remake a game when you can make a better game instead?
Why remake a game when you can make a better game instead?
Replies:
Anonymous
6/16/2025, 12:58:44 PM No.3783394
Anonymous
6/16/2025, 1:00:05 PM No.3783397
>>3782039
I'm guessing you're not familiar with the Ys series.
A significant portion of the series is essentially remakes.
I'm guessing you're not familiar with the Ys series.
A significant portion of the series is essentially remakes.
Replies:
Anonymous
6/16/2025, 2:04:30 PM No.3783408
why do people pretend to care about ys v
Replies:
Anonymous
6/16/2025, 2:35:59 PM No.3783415
>>3783397
I'm familiar with it
I enjoyed the gameplay of Oath in Felghana. The final boss fight with Demonicus was very memorable. But it could have been a better game if it didn't inherit so much crap due to being a remake of Wanderers from Ys.
Celceta wasn't terrible but it was worse than Dawn of Ys and also worse than the other party Ys games.
I'm not completely opposed to remakes. In very rare cases there are games that are brilliant in almost every way, then a remake can fix the gameplay and be one of the best games ever (although even then it won't erase the original, fans of the game will play both). But nowadays it feels like people want every game to be remade and I don't get it.
I'm familiar with it
I enjoyed the gameplay of Oath in Felghana. The final boss fight with Demonicus was very memorable. But it could have been a better game if it didn't inherit so much crap due to being a remake of Wanderers from Ys.
Celceta wasn't terrible but it was worse than Dawn of Ys and also worse than the other party Ys games.
I'm not completely opposed to remakes. In very rare cases there are games that are brilliant in almost every way, then a remake can fix the gameplay and be one of the best games ever (although even then it won't erase the original, fans of the game will play both). But nowadays it feels like people want every game to be remade and I don't get it.
Anonymous
6/16/2025, 4:31:24 PM No.3783504
>>3781772 (OP)
It's coming, 100%.
It's coming, 100%.
Anonymous
6/16/2025, 5:48:31 PM No.3783545
>>3781772 (OP)
They'll get to it eventually.
They'll get to it eventually.
Anonymous
6/16/2025, 6:03:34 PM No.3783558
>>3781774
Keep on
Keep on
Anonymous
6/16/2025, 10:43:31 PM No.3783752
>>3783408
Every other Ys game has a version released in America, and we're missing a little piece of Adol's story.
Every other Ys game has a version released in America, and we're missing a little piece of Adol's story.
Anonymous
6/16/2025, 11:02:11 PM No.3783757
>>3783408
>why do people pretend to care about ys v
Because it sucks and they don't want to play the shitty version while also saying they played ever Ys game
source: I say this
>why do people pretend to care about ys v
Because it sucks and they don't want to play the shitty version while also saying they played ever Ys game
source: I say this
Replies:
Anonymous
6/17/2025, 8:46:48 AM No.3783970
>>3783757
I played it recently just for the sake of completionism. I wouldn't say it was a BAD experience but it was deeply unengaging experience. Was mostly just kind of boring. Dull characters, art, and music. Nothing really stands out. the story is barely existent even in the superficial function sense. The color pallet is boring. And I don't like not really having a sense of what anything actually looks like. Maybe this isn't a problem if you had the manual but I remember older Ys games had those cool character portraits and stuff. Here even supposedly important characters are almost indistinguishable from NPCs.
I played it recently just for the sake of completionism. I wouldn't say it was a BAD experience but it was deeply unengaging experience. Was mostly just kind of boring. Dull characters, art, and music. Nothing really stands out. the story is barely existent even in the superficial function sense. The color pallet is boring. And I don't like not really having a sense of what anything actually looks like. Maybe this isn't a problem if you had the manual but I remember older Ys games had those cool character portraits and stuff. Here even supposedly important characters are almost indistinguishable from NPCs.
Anonymous
6/18/2025, 2:40:34 PM No.3784654
>>3781772 (OP)
The explanation they gave was that every time they make a new game in the series, the staff wants to spend that dev time making a new game rather than remaking Ys V, which seems reasonable to me.
The explanation they gave was that every time they make a new game in the series, the staff wants to spend that dev time making a new game rather than remaking Ys V, which seems reasonable to me.