Thread 40557320 - /x/ [Archived: 843 hours ago]

Anonymous
6/19/2025, 1:11:00 AM No.40557320
mythology
mythology
md5: 6274fdbc4098553d396bc8ef76d0ef16🔍
Why are monotheistic religions antithetical to supernatural beings unaffiliated with Heaven and Hell? You can't have ghosts, nature spirits, whimsical tricksters, fairies or whatnot because they don't fit the framework of divine vs infernal, or any narrative concerning sin vs virtue, I think it's rather frustrating that monotheism force the supernatural into a strict dichotomy rather than having it be fluid and nuanced like humanity is.

Do /x/ agree that the whole heaven-hell dualism is fake and gay compared to the more complex beings found in mythology? There's deeper truths to be found about entities you can't predict than one that is either obviously holy or obviously damned.
Replies: >>40557529 >>40557568 >>40557827 >>40557833 >>40558551 >>40558644 >>40562375 >>40564417 >>40566467
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 1:12:34 AM No.40557327
Ass and shit. Piece of shit.
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 1:21:52 AM No.40557367
You would have to ignore pretty much the entirety of folklore from "monotheistic" cultures to come to that conclusion
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 2:02:44 AM No.40557529
>>40557320 (OP)
>Protestant-with-dad-issues-kid hands typed this
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 2:11:48 AM No.40557568
>>40557320 (OP)
Imagine being created with the rest of your angelbros ex nihilo, you're infront of your creator, the big bro calls upon rebellion against him, you know that that's pretty much everything that exists. So yeah there are only two ways in that scenario.
Replies: >>40559568
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 2:12:31 AM No.40557570
They are not antithetical, it's just that we got unlucky with the monotheistic religions that went mainstream being retarded.
Even during the early modern period in Europe there were various nature spirits commonly acknowledged, but that culture was abandoned after the Enlightenment so only the grug brained religious stuff survived.
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:19:45 AM No.40557827
>>40557320 (OP)
because judeo-christianity is a memetic domination structure for jews and gentiles alike. It's meant to subdue its followers and promote universalism until the creation of its egregore is complete. Then all of the religions will be merged together and the followers will all be consumed by that egregore.

There's a reason that universalism and herd morality all come from judaism. And when "they" create that God (capital G)- it will attempt to rule reality and all of the supernatural stuff outside of it will wage war on it
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 3:21:14 AM No.40557833
>>40557320 (OP)
this is also why the top ss nazis were anti-christian btw. They were actually occult pagans which is why they adopted all of the roman (pagan, non-christian) iconography
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 5:53:18 AM No.40558551
>>40557320 (OP)
There is no dualism. Hell is a place of desolation a prison for fallen angels
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 6:17:15 AM No.40558644
>>40557320 (OP)
>Why are monotheistic religions antithetical to supernatural beings unaffiliated with Heaven and Hell?
Name three.
I can think of only one that is like this.
Did you just mean Judaism and it's branches because you don't know any other monotheistic religions?
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 11:20:42 AM No.40559568
>>40557568
Genesis does not say anything was created ex nihilo, that's a claim theologians make to make their god appear tougher than he is.
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 11:25:21 AM No.40559576
...did all the antichristian shills of /pol/ move here? Go away shoo
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 6:00:57 PM No.40561214
Bump
Anonymous
6/19/2025, 8:50:46 PM No.40562375
>>40557320 (OP)
Are you aware that non-dualism is a meme? Non-dualist gods are entities of light and their opposites are entities of darkness, making them meta-dualist beings
Replies: >>40565024
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 3:17:26 AM No.40564417
>>40557320 (OP)
Gnostics and Rosicrucians align with more of what you’re talking about from the Christian perspective
You have the Kabbalistic Jews, Sufi Muslims, or the many other mystery schools
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 5:19:11 AM No.40565024
>>40562375
>Are you aware that non-dualism is a meme?
Just reconcile the truth already
Anonymous
6/20/2025, 10:51:46 AM No.40566467
>>40557320 (OP)
>whimsical tricksters, fairies
They are borderline demonic.