← Home ← Back to /a/

Thread 279992763

65 posts 18 images /a/
Anonymous No.279992763 >>279993551 >>279993799 >>279995879 >>279999162 >>279999971 >>280001736 >>280002209 >>280002390 >>280004311 >>280004854 >>280008065 >>280008943 >>280015527
>male protagonist isn't a bland self-insert
>female protagonist isn't a dumb whore
>no third wheels trying to get in the way
>no "NTR-bait"
>no long misunderstandings
>no "will they won't they"
>they actually talk about their problems
>sex scenes
>18+ doujinshi by the mangaka herself
How can any other romance manga even compete?
Anonymous No.279992816 >>279992978 >>279993086 >>280001801
>10 volumes of nothing happening
Anonymous No.279992978
>>279992816
Sorry the characters aren't retarded enough to get your fix.
Anonymous No.279993086
>>279992816
But the manga has 11 volumes
Anonymous No.279993551 >>279993665
>>279992763 (OP)
>mangaka herself
Huh, I thought this was done by a dude
Anonymous No.279993665 >>279994307
>>279993551
How? It was obviously written by a woman
Anonymous No.279993799 >>279993902 >>279994521 >>279995899
>>279992763 (OP)
>Female author
Anonymous No.279993902 >>279994521 >>279995899
>>279993799
Why she hates tomboys so bad?
Anonymous No.279994307 >>279995397 >>280000140
>>279993665
>Uhhhh only a woman could draw this!
Shut up
That aside, I've never seen definitive proof (i.e. images, media posts, etc.) either supporting or disproving the author's identity
Anonymous No.279994521 >>280011624
>>279993799
>>279993902
>ntr out of nowhere
Obsession
Anonymous No.279995397 >>279995607 >>279995818
>>279994307
This. While there are plenty of women in the mainstream and hentai scenes, whether their work is cultured or trashy, any claim about an author's gender should be taken with a grain of salt (unless photos already exist or they've got the usual shoujo/josei tropes down). That said, I'm here to enjoy and maybe fap, not to debate.
Anonymous No.279995607
>>279995397
Ase to Sekken is basically a josei/TL manga with the sex scenes replaced with sniff rape (except for the actual sex scenes). It's so obviously written by a woman.
Anonymous No.279995818
>>279995397
Aside from the yaoi hands, the perfect guy who can read her mind, and the focus on female issues, the author uses "atashi".
Anonymous No.279995879 >>279997201
>>279992763 (OP)
Sounds boring.
Anonymous No.279995899
>>279993902
>>279993799
Nah, he's just a faggot.
>have the Japanese tism
>don't reciprocate despite having years to resolve yourself
>She dates another guy
>WHUUUH? HOW COULD I GET KEKED?
Anonymous No.279997201 >>280001811
>>279995879
why?
Anonymous No.279997567
I didn't like the FeMC very much, she was too Japanese timid and collectivised for me to like her as a person. Although I didn't really dislike her either, she just bored and annoyed me slightly.
So then it got to the part where her brother was introduced and his behavior was almost condomed and then I said "fuck this, I'm out" and dropped it.

I really liked Telework Nakadashi, the mangaka is very good.
Anonymous No.279999162
>>279992763 (OP)
there are dozens if not hundreds of manga like that, newfag
Anonymous No.279999971 >>280001268 >>280001780 >>280002594 >>280003241 >>280011647
>>279992763 (OP)
Misunderstandings are literally a staple in good romance/drama, without them you aren't left with much else
Anonymous No.280000140 >>280002362 >>280007665
>>279994307
I don't think I've ever read a male-written romance manga where the female lead has sex 3 times in the first 10 chapters. A skanky MC is a more-or-less reliable indicator of a female author.
Anonymous No.280001268
>>279999971
>good
Anonymous No.280001736 >>280002037
>>279992763 (OP)
Too bad the main gimmick is fucking wierd
>chick the sweats a metrics fuckton
>dude is super into sweat and wants to use it as basis for soap
Anonymous No.280001780
>>279999971
>Misunderstandings are literally a staple in good romance/drama
Wrong.
You just need something to test the relationship or have it develop in different ways.

Misunderstandings are the lamest and worst ways to create drama, often used by poor writers because they can't think of something good or interesting.
Anonymous No.280001801
>>279992816
>yabbadabadoo'er needs constant girls introduced and the same 10 tropes happening for the 999th time
judaism is a mental illness
Anonymous No.280001811
>>279997201
Because, despite the complaints of tropes in romance stories, they're part of what makes the genre interesting. Just reading about people dating and having sex with no tension to challenge their relationship is boring.
Anonymous No.280002037 >>280007746
>>280001736
>dude is super into sweat and wants to use it as basis for soap
He literally doesn't. The smell fetish is pretty irrelevant though.
Anonymous No.280002209 >>280002362
>>279992763 (OP)
The autismal shilling for this manga is now obnoxious enough that I'm starting to hate it.
Anonymous No.280002362 >>280002446
>>280000140
>>280002209
Agree. We need more Rent a Girlfriend and Chainsawman threads instead.
Anonymous No.280002390 >>280002940 >>280003216
>>279992763 (OP)
qt got robbed
Anonymous No.280002446 >>280002845
>>280002362
Nah Im serious, I've tried reading it a while ago when anon recommended this mango and found both leads to be too vapid to like. That's fine though, whatever. But since then Ive seen like ten more threads which all read like anon being mad his favourite manga is not more popular, like come on it has SEX, dont you want SEX?? Its really beginning to grate.
Anonymous No.280002594 >>280003182 >>280005164
>>279999971
Misunderstandings and love triangles and other romance cliches are all dreadful. Romance that's actually interesting involves two broken people learning to love and trust each other, with the main conflict being their own personal struggles.
Anonymous No.280002845 >>280002928
>>280002446
Have you tried not entering threads about mangos you don't like?
Anonymous No.280002928 >>280003153
>>280002845
Generally yeah, because OP doesn't format them like a faggot.
Anonymous No.280002940
>>280002390
Sad!
Anonymous No.280003153
>>280002928
Try to avoid them next time like any functional person would. No one is going to stop making threads because some random retard is screeching about them.
Anonymous No.280003182
>>280002594
This. They are lame tools used by lame writers who can't write characters with internal struggles.
Anonymous No.280003216 >>280003339
>>280002390
To be fair, she had like three years working under him and she basically admits she wanted him to work up to asking her organically going from a kid sister dynamic to dating. Hard to feel too sorry for her when her plan was basically "just keep being around him til he bites".

It's also made clear that before he finds FMC, the MC was pretty much game to date anyone and is a very easygoing person so he probably would have happily entered into a relationship with tomboy kouhai if she had made a move.
Anonymous No.280003241
>>279999971
It depends on the writing, but they're usually more miss than hit.
Anonymous No.280003339 >>280003400
>>280003216
Genki tomboys are made for cucking
Anonymous No.280003400 >>280003670
>>280003339
>Genki tomboys are made for cucking

They are the weakest of the tomboy species
Anonymous No.280003670 >>280003704
>>280003400
How can we fix them?
Anonymous No.280003704
>>280003670
Nonstop sex and cuddling
Anonymous No.280004311 >>280004343 >>280007085
>>279992763 (OP)
Couldn't get past the first chapter. It read like a generic shoujo oneshot.
Anonymous No.280004343
>>280004311
I think it started out as one.
Anonymous No.280004854
>>279992763 (OP)
Then you should consider checking this out
Anonymous No.280005041
>attractive young couple
>no serious problems just a few misunderstandings
Itโ€™s literally the standard JP romance. Even if itโ€™s supposed to be a harem or love triangle, itโ€™s ALWAYS a mono romance with gimmicks and supporting characters. If itโ€™s a shounen romance, the girl will be the most attractive (or second if itโ€™s a harem gimmick), if itโ€™s a shoujo romance the guy will be the best overall. Absolutely basic standard JP romance.
Anonymous No.280005164 >>280008301
>>280002594
You only think this because the ONLY contact with romance media is Japanese. JP literally canโ€™t do love triangles so theyโ€™re just mono romances with annoying third wheels. JPs are obsessed with moral purity so no one is allowed to make bad decisions therefore it must only be misunderstandings and as a Westerner you dislike that slop. Itโ€™s just low-grade slop.
Anonymous No.280007085
>>280004311
Because it was suppose to be generic oneshot. The serialization started about a year later. The first chapter is the worst part of the series.
Anonymous No.280007665
>>280000140
read more trashy Light Novels (don't actually)
Anonymous No.280007746
>>280002037
I was promised sniff fetishism but all I got was a mature relationship manga about overcoming adult issues
Anonymous No.280008065
>>279992763 (OP)
Sounds like a recipe for making boring schlock on par with all the "quirky girl sits next to loser" manga.
Anonymous No.280008301 >>280008351 >>280008460 >>280011723
>>280005164
No such thing as a non-mono romance, cuckcel.
Anonymous No.280008351 >>280008596
>>280008301
What about the Romance of the Three Kingdoms
Anonymous No.280008460
>>280008301
You only have this opinion because your only exposure to romance is from Japan. As I said, itโ€™s low-grade slop.
Anonymous No.280008596
>>280008351
Mono romance since Wu is irrelevant.
Anonymous No.280008943 >>280011276
>>279992763 (OP)
I bet you like marie biscuits.
Anonymous No.280011276
>>280008943
In small doses only because I'm not a fatty.
Anonymous No.280011399 >>280011437 >>280012046
Is this the worst SF skin ever made?
Anonymous No.280011437 >>280012143
>>280011399
shit wrong thread lmao
Anonymous No.280011624
>>279994521
>ntr
he never answered her chocolates back so deserved
Anonymous No.280011647
>>279999971
stupid monkey ass take
Anonymous No.280011723
>>280008301
jobless reincarnation does this doesn't it?
Anonymous No.280012046 >>280012143
>>280011399
Is that shaggy from scooby doo?
Anonymous No.280012143
>>280011437
>>280012046
kek
Anonymous No.280015527
>>279992763 (OP)
>another fujo series
dropped