Is this good sakuga?

>>280250384 (OP)
That's just average anime animation.

>>280250384 (OP)
Where's the sakuga?

A bunch of effects and screenshake to hide the still images isn't sakuga.

>>280250384 (OP)
what qualifies as sakuga to you

>>280252004
It's an excellent question. I have very high standards. I only accept Sakuga as high-budget scenes made with traditional animation. But since that's a thing of the past and is almost unwatchable now thanks to digital animation, I'm stepping outside my comfort zone and trying to accept any dynamic scene with fluid sequencing as part of what we consider Sakuga.
If we expand the range, there's a lot to draw from, but not all of it is good sakuga. There's a lot of sakuga that simply has dynamic, fluid animation that isn't really good. Like the legendary Naruto vs. Pain scene, it's a meme in Japanese animation.

>>280250831
The effect animation is the sakuga

>>280250384 (OP)
TV series peaked with this scene.

>>280250384 (OP)
The part at 0:26 where the boner starts crawling out is pretty good but the cut is too short. The rest is mediocre.

bump

>>280252004
do you see what happens when you reply to terminally retarded namefags?

>>280253710
and me thinking that the snake hands in ena where from xavier, I should had read more of their symbolism, https://youtu.be/Td7CBNu0914?si=zkBgkoQRlMEwwhSt&t=93

Does nobody here recognize good effects animation when they see it
Not that I'm surprised, but still, my standards for this board sank even lower

>>280253955
Fuck U moron

>>280253710
Tnx for the bum bruh.

sakuga just means 作画

>>280253710

There is a reason why those old 70s anthropomorphic and animal character shows have pretty good animation in them sometimes, you can highly animate simple looking characters alot easier than complex heavily detailed ones.

>>280250384 (OP)
>You're holding them wrong.
>The guns, you're holding them wrong.

>>280256652
Is it? I remember seeing an interview with a Japanese cartoonist who complained about one of her characters' hair because it was so damn hard to animate. It's not the same with amorphous characters like Shin Chan?

>>280250384 (OP)
>mfw this gets a remake ala FMA Brotherhood and sucks all the "soul" out of it yet again
DAMNIT BONES JUST DO IT RIGHT THE FIRST TIME

watch naruto