Thread 280395437

I finally got around to reading this manga. I had been spoiled about the winner years ago so I knew what to expect, but it was still a very good read thanks to how great the girls were.

I finally understand why the series was such a phenomenon now. I'm planning on watching the specials next.

Miku is best girl by the way and she should have won.

Post your favorite Quints or just discuss the series.

nenebros...

>and she should have won
You now remember she focused her efforts on something F didn't appreciate and was instantly rejected.

I always loved Miku and Yotsuba anyways so I would have been happy with either of them. Ichika and Nino just wanted a version of the MC that he wasn't ever going to be which is partly why they lost. Ultimately it's a really well drawn and well paced series that got undone by the author wanting to keep his Yotsuba pick too secret and as a result gave fans of other girls too much ammo to call bullshit.

If Yotsuba had been as proactive as Nino then people wouldn't be able to call it an asspull choice. Which they use to make the entire manga seem superfluous

>>280395437 (OP)
Miku had like no personality other than to be moe and in love with the MC. She fell for him in the second chapter.
>>280395469
He humored her at points and gave her no reason to think it wouldn't work. He should have been more straightforward on him not returning her feelings. I can't blame Miku for thinking the way into his heart was through his mom.

Ichika had to be sacrificed because she otherwise would’ve been a better fit for Fuutaro based on the presumed qualities that attracted him to her

>>280395469
You mean cooking/baking? Yeah, I don't really get why she hyperfocused on this when the dude doesn't even have taste buds. But at least it allowed her to discover her passion and she's amusingly stuck with Nino who was the other favorite on /a/ as far as I know.

>>280395597
>would’ve been a better fit for Fuutaro
People read toubun and think the extremely career focused quint was a better fit.
F wanted a family, to go back home and meet his wife and kids waiting for him.

>>280395643
>F wanted a family, to go back home and meet his wife and kids waiting for him.
Nice headcanon.
The only thing we ever him desire the most are usually money because he is poor.

>>280395590
>He humored her at points and gave her no reason to think it wouldn't work. He should have been more straightforward on him not returning her feelings.

I think this is why Quintuplets gets a bad rap sometimes. Because it presented itself like a normal harem where every girl had an equal opportunity to win Fuutaro's heart using her own individual personality and charms. But the author was always pretty clearly using the storyline of Fuutaro looking for the specific little girl regardless of who they grew up into as his main plot. So the message of the story gets sort of confused. Like, Ichika and Miku and Nino all warm up to Fuutaro assuming that they can win his heart knowing they weren't the little girl while Yotsuba just watches over him hoping he'll figure it out. Ultimately negating the very notion of a harem

>>280395714
Actually read his swings chapter with Yotsuba for once. He's dense as a brick but he falls for her right there.

>>280395714
Fucking wrong

>>280395718
>while Yotsuba just watches over him hoping he'll figure it out
Which is funny beacuse she DIDN'T want him to.

>>280395718
But he never figured out it was Yotsuba. I actually found it weird how it never got adressed by him, at some point he stopped caring about "Rena".

>>280395782
He just got tired of quint games.

>>280395801
Except he was willing to play a quint game for his confession/choice. That still makes me so angry.

>>280395801
I know, but I assumed there would be an epilogue to this entire storyline.

>>280395843
Him after his wedding realizing
>oh shit I married her!

>>280395437 (OP)
>Male romance
>"Oh no I can only pick one girl"
>Female romance
>fucks and marries every single guy in the story and gets an actual harem ending
I can't take these double standards anymore...
Is there even a single male romance story where the MC at least has an extra mistress on the side and isn't a complete cuck?

Was daddy Nakano actually in a relationship with Rena before she died or was he just her simp to the end?

>>280396441
Pure simp, they were never officially married, and I don't think he was ever officially dating her since she died too early before he could score.

>>280396661
Damn. I hope Nino will eventually get over Futarou and fuck him, because it's obvious she has a giant father complex.

>>280395437 (OP)
Best Quint is best even in a different series

>>280396661
He probably came in her a few times as a student. He was the head of her fan club she was a dumb bitch who fucked her mentor. She probably spread it for desperate students as well

>>280395718
They actually did have an equal chance, they were so equal that Fuutarou actually wanted to reject everyone to avoid hurting their relationship with each other before Ichika pushed him to break the status quo.

Why did she look so fucking fat in that panel?

DOKI DOKI
KIMOCHI AFURETEKU

Yotsuba deserved everything and more

>>280396929
> they were so equal that Fuutarou actually wanted to reject everyone to avoid hurting their relationship with each other

That was superficially. The reality is that Fuutaro would only ever choose the little girl from the swings. It was always her or nobody

>>280397210
Negi wanted readers to know that Yotsuba would have big old tits straining under the weight of all her milk once Fuutaro put a baby in her

>>280396929
Not really. Fuutarou had already had special feelings for someone at the end of Chapter 68. From our perspective, they had equal chances because we didn't yet know who the person Fuutarou had special feelings for was. But Fuutarou knew exactly who he would choose.

Ninopwon

>>280397210
And we are expected to believe she travelled hundreds of miles on bike as her morning exercise. Crazy.

>>280397937
Even this is debatable cause last minute Maeda, Takeda had to give him the push and the whole thing felt like he realized the asspull that it has to be Yots cause she gave herself away = recognized her first. Then he can't recognize her during the wedding. Classic.

So will nino and Mike ever actually get their own bfs some day?

>>280400869
He recognized each one of them during the wedding.

>>280401664
They are in an incestuous relationship.

Would the readers kill negi if the others move on with their lives even if it's better for them as characters? Onodera from nisekoi got that grace.

>>280401702
Just kinda. Itsuki told him she was Yotsuba and instead of calling out her bullshit, he started sweating bullets implying he is really unsure. Didn't watch the movie but I've heard this got cut but dunno if true.

>>280401821
No, but I also hate the way Nisekoi did it. If it's random mooks for the losers, then why don't you make a design at least even if the characters came as an afterthought to fill the BF quota for the rest? The way Onodera's hubby got handled is no better than the faceless Tawawa partners.

>>280401664
Of course, what kind of question is that? Would you turn down either of them?

>>280401821
Negi would've made banks if he made quint spin-off, even if it was done by another author

>>280401664
They get regular customers. Easiest path to find a bf where they slowly but surely went to the café to see the girls.

>>280402977
Naito is soon to be free and thankfully his art didn't collapse that much.

>>280395437 (OP)
>Miku is best girl by the way and she should have won.
I don't get this mindset. I always wanted her to lose and 2nd best girl to win instead which is exactly what ended up happening

>>280403037
But it did, current amagami is unrecognizable.

>>280403156
Palatable, it's miles better than the Sentai designs for the quints.

>>280401821
Wtfffffff
Post kosaki's husband ASAP

>>280403493
It's an obscured wedding picture. Only Onodera is seen there. Miyanagi is the family name. That's all there is to it. Her daughter is Miyanagi Sasa. Basically Onodera 2.0 with fluffier hair. Unfortunately, Raku's and Chitoge's son is a twink.

>>280402062
>faceless Tawawa partners.
What?

>>280395437 (OP)
nakano kawaii

>>280403493
Yeah bro and the internet didnt flip over it

>>280405028
You tell me.
They are "literally me" placeholders, lmao

>>280402062
>>280402977
Is it possible to make spin offs with losers and have it be good? Like in nisekoi, Marika literally went to meet Y-san in the epilogue. Shit was cash. I remember Ichigo 100% had a one shot surrounding the main black hair loser but her relationship with that guy in it didn't go too far because he was too much like the original MC or something. I think the novelty of Onodera actually producing kids later in life despite being a harem loser was something I didnt see much before

>>280397704
More like AfurEATteku

>>280405332
As opposed to Raku, a dude filled with so much personality.

>>280405420
>Is it possible to make spin offs with losers and have it be good?
I'm sure it'd be possible, but I'm not sure if any author would bother unless they really loved the character(s) and the series to a ridiculous extent. Most would rather just write the winner; have the other girls hook up with randos or stay single, and move on to a new series.

>>280397210
Ovulating

So we're all playing the dungeon RPG right?

>>280403634
You mean he's an ikemen who's seen by her saving a cat from the tree

>>280405838
Didn't the High Score Girl mangaka make a spin-off about the loser?

>>280406024
Yeah but iirc it was her being single teacher and not being laid

>>280405509
Point is he doesn't even has a design to judge and the daughter inherited the mother's look.

>>280405925
More like the boring combination of Raku and Chitoge. Actually looks like Chitoge with short hair, but boy. But damn somehow the name 'Haku' is the worst part. Raku, Haku.

>>280396214
>Is there even a single male romance story where the MC at least has an extra mistress on the side and isn't a complete cuck?
Isekai are like that.

>>280396214
>>Female romance
>>fucks and marries every single guy in the story and gets an actual harem ending
What manga are you reading where the female has multiple spouses? That's against the law!