Now remind me what nino did
>I'm a massive bitch
>oh wait I want to suck your cock now
>*cries after not being chosen*

>>280524096 (OP)
Yes but nini is still shit regardless

>>280524127
It's called character development, but yotsucuck would not know it

4 is a sweetheart. 2 laid it on a little thick.

>>280524268
>character development
Doing a 180 in the span of two chapters isn't character development ninotard.

We like nice girls here.

How do you think Nino got on in the time skip? Think she ever got a BF? It'd be great if she did.

>>280524096 (OP)
Jamal-kun

>>280524096 (OP)
only pros can do it, honey.

Which one?

>>280524445
damn.

>>280524350
it literally is though

>>280524096 (OP)
Honestly, it really felt like Negi was aware of the controversy but didn't care.

Yots just helped sports teams left and right but didn't outright say at any point she wants to do something with her talent. She was the only quint that didn't thought about her future and what she wants to do. So what happens? She casually broke record after record in the past so gets a sports recommendation out of the blue. Problem solved.

>>280524470
I was always a 4fag and lived comfortably until chapter 114. Before that we were well regarded and had no enemies. No one had a bad word to say about Yotsuba. Then she won and became one of the most hated heroines of all time.

>>280524580
That only gets her a uni entrance.
She went on to be a nurse, because she always did great in health subjects and likes helping.

Did you guys not notice that she was obsessed with him when the others didn't even know who he was?

>>280524470
they're already in perfect order, top to bottom.

>>280524470
>Which one?
as a newfag opinion based on appearance:

1. Ichiki=Nino
2. Itsuki
3. Yotsuba
4. Miku

Though Itsuki sometimes surpasses the first 2

>>280524630
When was she ever good in health subjects?
What does F do?
This nurse and physiotherapy route is fairly recent stuff.

Nino > all

>>280524470
Miku. Easily.

btw explain to the newfag the ending

so was it a dream or not?
Why was past Futaro dreaming about future wedding?

>>280524736
Parallels. Past F didn't like the quints and the quints argued. Future F likes the quints and the quints laugh in harmony.

>>280524771
Not what I asked about.

I asked about how he was dreaming about the wedding

>>280524790
There are no specific details, anon. So if you are trying to imply he dreamt all of the manga or he specifically dreamt about picking Yotsuba or dreamt about marrying Yotsuba, then just give up. He had a dream that involved a wedding and Negi used that for the parallels scenes. That's about it.

>>280524878
>So if you are trying to imply he dreamt all of the manga or he specifically dreamt about picking Yotsuba or dreamt about marrying Yotsuba, then just give up
isn't that's what manga implying?

>He had a dream that involved a wedding and Negi used that for the parallels scenes. That's about it
why did he have to make him say he was dreaming about a wedding for that? Him saying he was dreaming about the wedding had nothing to do with that scene and quints being annoying. He could've picked just anything Futaro did with Quints in the past to show that they were annoying

>>280524096 (OP)
GRVTAL GRVKE TRVKE.
That's why Nino should have won.

>>280525003
what is this retard saying?

I don't think Nino ever actually loved him. It was always about her and what she wanted.

>>280524924
The manga abruptly goes back to the past from the wedding, so it does feel like he dreamt everything, but then the honeymoon and all that shenanigans still happened. So it's just an artistic choice. Not a fan of it myself but it is what it is. F called his wedding a dream like day ch 1 so maybe that's why Negi presented as such. And then there is the fact a VN came almost immediately out after the ending, so the dream possibility opened up the possibility for routes.

IIRC at the time classic

>>280524096 (OP)
And Nino admits in the next chapter that she was wrong about that.

>>280524353
But not nice girls who are pathetic (PTSD/survivor guilt) pitybaits

ninibros...

>>280524580
>Honestly, it really felt like Negi was aware of the controversy but didn't care
More like didn't care because he didn't want to make 5toubun at first. Even he mocks at them and their fans in Sentai Daishikkaku.
The Yotsuba end doesn't come as something planned out of wanting to project his happy married life, but as a fuck you to harem "horseracing gamblers".

>>280524606
>we were well regarded and had no enemies
And that's because nobody considered Yotsuba a serious contender until the flashback arc. She was the dark horse because genki girls were destined to lose. I still remember the despairposting every week, the "Zetsuba" memes, empty classroom smile. I have a folder full of rope edits made by anons here.
All of them got absolutely BTFO.

>>280525228
what?

>>280525288
Honestly that flashback made me 50/50 on her or Itsuki. 123 were completely fucked and had been for many arcs.

>>280525288
>the one girl who didn't need convincing, already knows his name and is obsessed with him
How did you not get it?

>>280525286
>doesn't come as something planned out
But he planned it from the beginning.
His editor literally spilled the beans about the original premise of the series (mc met girl tears ago and is now a quint he must find) and sent everyone in a cope frenzy because it happened before the ending.

negi is actually continuing the manga under the "chickeIII" alias check it out

>>280525030
Just facts.
If Negi put in 5toubun the passion he is putting in Sentai instead of seeing it as a money grubber polluted with toxic otakus he mocks and not-so-subtly criticizes, Nino would have won.

>>280525286
>doesn't come as something planned
It was a plan 5 years in the making

>>280525286
He supposedly said in an interview that he doesn't like heroines who start the story with already having a crush on the MC.
So did he lie here or just went against his preffered heroine choice?
And he supposedly also said that first half of the manga is about the bride's feelings, second half is about F's feelings since it has to become mutual, yet neither parts really feels like it's exploring the intended character at all, really.

>>280525355
I know it was planned, but the reasons weren't story related, but actually meta.

Nino won my and /a/'s heart

>>280525355
Ayaneru returns as the Yotsuba voice when supposedly she liked Miku the best and cosplayed as Miku. That should've been telling.

>>280525393
What words are you trying to say, at the start there.

>>280524268
>Making every sentence end with "fu-kun" is character development
The only ones who went through actual character development were Miku Eatski and Ichika

>>280525440
Ayaneru was supposed to voice all the quints to ramp up the mystery factor tho.
Although i can't imagine her having a more softspoken (Miku), brash (Itsuki), mature (Ichika) or assertive and competitive (Nino) tone. In my head, she always was associated with mentally challenged retards and hyperactive fireballs like Ochunko or Yotsuba.

>>280525583
And Nino too.
Yotsuba? She simply went back to the self she had before being kicked out of that school. And considering she applied for being a nurse, we can say she simply gave up and just let Futaro guide her life.

Also opinion from the newfag:
Before the Yotsuba retcon, the most obvious winners were gonna be either Ichika or Itsuki.

Ichika just had too much focus and pov, Futaro was valuing her opinion above else , she was no.1, the leader, the one who looks like the bride in flashforward based on hairstyle and color and her character arc was basically stop holding back, which Yotsuba stole.

Itsuki was the first one he met. The one who got closest to his family. The one who is trying to become smart like his dream girl Rena promised and he imagined she was gonna be.
They argue like a "married couple" troupe.

>>280525587
>i can't imagine
You don't have to imagine
https://youtu.be/XqibXQ6cMng

>>280524268

Its called the consequences of your own decisions. She verbally abused and drugged the guy she'd soon consider her own love interest.

She can character development all she likes from the nose bleed stands with the rest of the losers.

>>280525587
Supposed to, but they used the excuse it would've been too tiring. In reality they most likely came to the conclusion that 5 top tier VA is better than 1 doing multiple voices. Or 4 cause honestly Miku just got there for the lulz.
https://youtu.be/XqibXQ6cMng?si=Ay-nZR7fVC4k8TGc
IMO 2-3-4 sounds great, Ichika is the weakest one by far, Itsuki is only passable.

Still don't fully understand why most Yotsufags are ESL and spics, must be something in the water there.

>>280525639
>the Yotsuba retcon,
Oh anon, people always thought she'd be lolikano because of her massive issues.
Ichika was built up to self destruct and Itsuki was the bait first girl, you even acknowledge said meta reason.

>>280525639
>it was either gonna be the first girl meta or the evil one aka the most anti-meta pick (which circles it back to being a meta pick)
nope.

>>280525728
>it would've been too tiring
don't forget to pay your respects to Yuu GODsakawa voiced 4 heroines in a single 30+ hours visual novel

>>280525639
Lol. Lmao.

Ichika had zero chance after the Miku incident. Hyphotethically only some massive apology tour could have saved her, but nah, you know nothing about fandoms if you think you can fuck up the fan favorite and still get the W.

Fatso from the second half almost entirely disappeared. Her only real chance was the first girl trope, nothing else. But surely F as a tsundere all along that pretended his annoyance whenever the fat fuck showed up in his home. Even pre school festival. Surely, he loved her and picks her in 3 days when he just wanted her to fuck off.

When are people gonna get past the fact that Yotsuba won because she was nice to the guy? Nino and Miku treated him like shit at first. Itsuki did too but he started it and kept pouring oil on the fire. Ichika was condescending even if she wasn't being a bitch.

>>280525833
It's not unusual in VN's and gacha shit. Kancolle or what was that called (is it still a thing?) had plethora of characters voiced by the same VA. Anime recording have stricter schedule than VN recordings, but props to her regardless.

>>280525702
>Its called the consequences of your own decisions.
Something Yotsuturd didn't think about when she became Nino on steroids in the other school.
She verbally abused and drugged the guy she'd soon consider her own love interest.
Not worse than having dragged your siblings into your own failures. A reminder the other 4 quints left that school because of Yotsuba being kicked out. She hindered their futures.

>>280525743
>>280525745
Ichika's thing was about finally being selfish instead of letting her sisters take things. Here the "evil" is actually supposed to be a good thing.
And first girl meta just works.

That's why him choosing Yotsuba is so out of character. They barely had moments together. She's the most retarded and childish one, nothing like the Rena he envisioned.

>>280525910
>She hindered their futures.
They were all dumb as fuck and cheating every exam.

>>280525864
Yotsuba while generally nice, she knew him. That's all about it. She reached out, cause she knew him, he was not a stranger to him.
Miku thought he was a stalker, which he didn't really deny, but she didn't call the cops, so it's fine. F was the one that tricked and lied to her the next day, so when was she a bitch exactly in this?
The absolute favorite one is the big Yotsuba help is literally her going to sports clubs from the moment Miku joins. So much for the past traumas or the grand F support.

>>280525923
>finally being selfish instead of letting her sisters take things. Here the "evil" is actually supposed to be a good thing.
And then it was revealed she was a MASSIVE cunt when she's selfish.
>And first girl meta just works.
It really doesn't.
Fuutaro just falls for the girl whose dream was
>getting married and having a family
which, ironically, are his wishes too. The swing scene is really telling.

>>280525923
>Here the "evil" is actually supposed to be a good thing
In terms of her character development? Maybe. But why would that shoot her up in the list as a romantic partner for Fuutarou? You're considering Fuutarou's POV for Yotsuba but meta/reader's POV for Ichika. Pretty inconsistent logic.

>>280525864
kuuderes are always better. we want the warming up of a once hostile beauty with naturally strong protective habits.

>>280525864
Less about being nice, but more about taking Fuutarou out of his routine.
However, there's a more disturbing reason Yotsuba won.
If this wasn't a romcom, neither be romcom-tinted, Yotsuba would be basically like the FeMC from Boy's Abyss... a pitiful existence that only causes misery to others, except the MC for some twisted reason. The reasons Fuutarou chose her weren't just "the promised quint" and muh Rena, he knows Yotsuba is a disaster as a person who, without proposing it, guided Futaro to come out of his shell, but still despite of such a contribution, vocationally, she would have it more difficult in life than other people because she's dumb, hasn't a defined dream (at first muh soccer player, then becoming a bride, only to settle as a nurse), so he rather chose to share the burden with her.

Kek... it's like all the harem anime (be it faux-harem, romcoms, dark harems, misery porn) have some type of unspoken code where the winning girl has to be someone that, either purposefully or not, makes a change in MC's life.

Captchuh: Pd0py (Pedo pii)

>>280524470
Miku, my beloved...

It surprises me that so few lewd pictures of the Quints get posted in these threads. They actually discuss the series.

Had Gotoubun been made a few years earlier, Nino could have won. The tsundere meta reigned supreme in early 2010s.

>>280524096 (OP)
maybe if she wasn't such a massive bitch someone would have recommend her too

>>280526081
>Had Gotoubun been made a few years earlier, Nino could have won. The tsundere meta reigned supreme in early 2010s.
You meant "had the quints be Negi's passion project...".
In Sentai, the resident Nino (Hisui) has it easier about D than the resident Yotsuba (Angel).

>>280526081
Nino isn't even a tsundere. She's actually honest with her feelings. She acts like a total bitch at first because Fuutarou intrudes in her life, but as soon as she realizes she loves him, she immediately confesses and then keeps trying to seduce him.

Nene from MayoTuna? Now that's a real tsundere.

>>280526211
This argument again...
Dude, you can keep forcing about this, but fucton of anons think of her as a tsundere and nothing you can do about. It doesn't help Taketatsu voices her to boot.

>>280526211
>Nino isn't even a tsundere. She's actually honest with her feelings. She acts like a total bitch at first because Fuutarou intrudes in her life, but as soon as she realizes she loves him, she immediately confesses and then keeps trying to seduce him.
She's a menhera... same as Yotsuba, but their mental illness is channeled in different ways. In Nino's case, is by being a selfish and aggressive almost yandere-ish, in Yotsuba's case, it's all about her PTSD.

>>280526278
I only read the manga a week or so ago, I'm not whoever you think about. But nice knowing there are other people who aren't retarded.

>>280526211
This correct take again...

>>280526005
>But why would that shoot her up in the list as a romantic partner for Fuutarou?
Because Ichika is literally shown to be perfect in every way:
-has a career
-studies while working
-is the most sociable
-is shown to be practically the smartest quint by her main subject being math and science
-scores the highest despite being tired from working, just because she did not want to give up
-objectively the prettiest quint in the verse
-she's the one he goes to when he needs advice

>You're considering Fuutarou's POV for Yotsuba but meta/reader's POV for Ichika. Pretty inconsistent logic
Because Yotsuba doesn't work in anyway, it's just most obvious from Futaro's POV. She's so retarded and so childish that she's still wearing her childish underwear, doesn't brush teeth and is a retard.
She's the opposite of what Futaro imagined Rena to be.

>>280526278
Itsuki is the resident tsun tho.

>>280526211
that just means she's a classic tsundere.

>>280526078
There isn't many quint lewds to begin with.

>>280526401
Nino is a postmodern tsundere.

>>280526388
>she's the one he goes to when he needs advice
Implying it's only her all the time. Total bullshit. And he doesn't go anywhere. Usually he has chance enounters with the quints and they converse about the latest developments.

>>280526394
She is the resident food joke.

>>280526404
Why is that? They're super hot.

I only searched for doujins and was surprised there were so few of them (Bad Mushrooms ones are kino though), but I attributed it to Gacha eating up everything. Shouldn't affect fanarts as much.

>>280526388
Is this your first romance manga? You are not going to survive the winter with this level of romcom illiteracy. Romance MCs most of the time never end up with their ideal girl. In fact it's more likely for them to fall for a girl who's way out of their strike zone.

>>280526388
>Because Yotsuba doesn't work in anyway, it's just most obvious from Futaro's POV. She's so retarded and so childish that she's still wearing her childish underwear, doesn't brush teeth and is a retard.
>She's the opposite of what Futaro imagined Rena to be.
Still Fuutarou chose to share the burden because of what Yotsuba contributed to him as a person.
Hence why if you take the romcom goggles out, this story would be basically what Boy's Abyss or Domestic Girlfriend ended up being (and i know Rent-a-Girlfriend will end the same). In these type of stories, the "makeines" basically have a brighter individual future and a personal drive to reach them, and MC is simply a teenage or a selfish womanly need for them because he feeds some desire, compared to the "katsuine" whose future is basically linked to MC's and has issues MC could relate in a certain way.

>>280526602
The manga ended like 5 years ago or so. There are plenty of lewds, but it's not that relevant anymore.
>https://www.pixiv.net/en/tags/%E4%BA%94%E7%AD%89%E5%88%86%E3%81%AE%E8%8A%B1%E5%AB%81/artworks

>looks like Ichika
>same hair as Ichika
>same color as Ichika
>same earing as Ichika
>calls him by his first name like Ichika

Yotsucucks won't gaslight me into accepting retconned ending.

>>280526726
If it's not a complete doujin it doesn't count.

>>280526627
>Romance MCs most of the time never end up with their ideal girl. In fact it's more likely for them to fall for a girl who's way out of their strike zone and usually have a trainwreck personality or are women on their dead ends.

>>280526211
Nene does not even like the Buck so she isn't tsun

>>280526627
>"you should accept out of character bad writing because most romance manga are badly written too"
lul the fuck?

>>280526758
I'm not saying you should accept it, but you should have seen it coming.

>>280526735
all the loli quints had pink hair you dipshit, it's their neutral hair color. just randomly giving her orange hair would have made it way too obvious

>>280526735
Ichika called him Fuutarou-kun. So if this is your argument, then the bride is Miku. (When bride says his name it's in kanji, when Miku it's in hiragana)

>>280524096 (OP)
I dont remember Fuutarou using they/them pronouns

>>280526735
ninocuck doesn't realize that the bride calls him Futaro

>>280526735
Kek, all the quints were pink haired.

And i know who's gonna win in Shiunji family because of the rule of the "winner has to be a trainwreck/have the most boohoo past" story.

>>280524096 (OP)
>your

>>280527051
The oak tree?

One of the most loved fanarts

>>280527051
Banri is winning the "dumb bitch" Olympics right now.

Would it be better if the author did multiple endings like bokuben?

>>280527174
>>280527051
Who the fuck cares how a Miyama Reiji manga ends, they're all complete garbage

>>280527231
no

>>280527239
He is literally the best artist and the best writer all in one, don't insult god you philistine.

>>280527285

>>280526280
>yandere-ish
I don't remember Nino having a jealous streak.

So why did Negi finish the story with Yotsuba never fixing any of her issues? If anything it shows Yotsuba being so shallow that all of her interal problems could have been solved if only she dated Fuutarou. I know that 428fags will make fun of 2fags forever but I still believe that making her the bell kisser when Yotsuba had almost zero screen time on said arc was just such a pathetic addition that didnt make sense that Negi should have just skipped it.

>>280527171
Oh, yeah, this reminds me that in the final arc, you can see the socks of the chosen quint going into the room where F is, which basically meant only Miku and Yots had a shot cause of the dark inking.

>>280527171
Which quint gives the best footjobs /a/?

>>280527400
Yots should've spoken about kid F to everyone, not just Nino who completely forgot, or Ichika who took her place without knowing how important it is to Yots. Even Itsuki figured it out from the details, but somehow didn't felt the rest deserves the knowledge of Yotsuba was first so please, let her have the guy or at least let them talk or force them to talk.

nino a SHIT

>>280527154
Haha, yeah, that one, the "twin". She's the one with more personality issues than the other sisters.

>>280527524
I haven't even touched that story but that's what everyone said last time I asked.

>>280527231
No.
Multiple and harem ends, unless justified by plot bekng supernatural, are just the coward copout for sissy authors unable to face the flame from losing girls fags.

>>280527400
>but I still believe that making her the bell kisser when Yotsuba had almost zero screen time on said arc was just such a pathetic addition that didnt make sense that Negi should have just skipped it.
It was so obviously supposed to be Ichika before the retcon

Instead of helping Nino kiss Futaro there,
she went in and did it herself which would make 100% sense since that arcs starts her no holding back arc.

Yotsuba shit had no build up to be the bell kisser. 0. None.
It goes against her """"arc""""", she should not be chasing Futaro by that point.

Nobody, and I fucking mean nobody fucking ever on this planet who has read more than 5 romcom mangas in the last 30 years thought Ichika had any chance of winning, not even in their fucking fever dreams.

Just look at her "job" and hair, any of those two is a straight disqualification, not even touching on all the other crap.

>>280526278
>Taketatsu
>she isn't voicing Nene in Mayonaka
>Nene is being voiced by a literal who
One of my reasons for living was dashed.

>>280527051
So Reiji said Shiunji would take up 13 volumes to finish in the beginning. Meaning roughly 90 chapters. Considering there is 0 plot in there, it's somehow incredible that even half way it feels like he is stretching it.

>>280527761
The literal who sounds like her, so it's fine.

>>280527770
The horseracing will begin once Banri gets freed from John Lennon.

>>280527400
It retraoctively doesn't make sense for anyone but Yotsuba to be the bell kisser. She's the only one who loved him but was afraid to be OEPNLY flirty. The only other contender was Itsuki but later on we learned she never developed a strong romantic attachment to him like the other 4. Yotsuba's "lack of screentime" is the giveaway

>>280527915
>She's the only one who loved him but was afraid to be OEPNLY flirty
Another thing ninikekes seem to have forgotten: Yotsuba was the only quint who rejected Fuutarou's advances.

>>280527761
Taketatsu's tsundere era is over, long gone just like Kugyu's tsundere era. She's auntie now. You will only hear her voicing JKs if its a recurring role

>>280527915
Anons shit on the reason and they are right to do so. Was it last chapter or the penultimate one? So she talks with Fatso and mentions how F fell behind the group and somehow she needs to check up on him. She worries F won't recognize her for some reason even though that shouldn't even be the point, but Fatso reasurres her that he probably will and gives Yots the chance to check up on him. Then there is the aspect of the whole accident or not thingy. Literally it's impossible to portray it convincingly. She rushes there, tiptoes, puckers her lips and magically falls on him and their lips magically touch. Even if she doesn't fall, she somehow totally makes a face of someone that expects a kiss. By the way, previous arc she kissed him on the face and she even said afterwards that think of it as thanking him even though minutes before she had zero intentions of doing anything. So she really shouldn't have any motivations in the arc itself, because she already made a move an arc prior.

>>280527761
>Rumi Okubo
>literally who

Also, she can sound like Taketatsu if she wants.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sr0lJvixQCU

>>280528072
She still did Mirika though who was annoyingly enough came not so much after Nino.

https://x.com/ChickeIII/status/1943973650266566704

>>280528686
Thankfully this guy still draws the good quints once in a while.

>>280528314
Some anons said she would do the kiss if she is lolikano. Then she had to be the martyr character who decided to be a doormat of the other quints when none of them held a serious grudge against her. It's insane how her backstory contradicts a lot of her actions in the manga, be it her romantic tries or the sports clubs thingy. And none of them grabbed her neck and told her that remember what happened last time? Ease the fuck up on pleasing the sports clubs and focus on your damn studies!

>>280528739
Bet he will never ever makes a proper Miku doujin given the first two, but even if he makes one, Nino will 100% ruin it.

>>280528828
There's no better girl than Nino in this manga so by default her presence would only make the doujin better.

>>280527383
quite the contrary, she was ready to help miku go out of her shell and was ready for a fair battle. she only (quite consistently) disliked shady business.

>>280528954
Realistically it's nuclear submarine > aircraft carrier > battleship

>>280526995
When is the next trainwreck airing? The last one I saw was vulvarape...

>>280524470
Itsuki is best girl

>>280524096 (OP)
nino is literally the worst bitch of the whole harem
>i was in love with a version of futaro i didnt know up untill know
>before that she actively makes everything worse for him in every way she can
>after that she does a 180 and wants unlimited amounts of sex

nah fuck that, nino deserves to be raped. ichika was too good so nagi had to nerf her by forcing her to become actual satan, itsuki is mid. Only Miku and Yotsuba are actually likeable and even then Yotsuba clears 9/10 y'all still cannot cope with the fact that best girl won, nothing against Miku of course, it would've been fine had she won, but to hear that "nino should've won"? Kill yourself retarded niggers

>>280529656
I support Palestine too

>>280529656
Miku didn't deserve shit, she spent the entire manga working towards a thing Fuutarou didn't give a shit about.

Nino never had any character development. She simply started classifying Fuu-kun as a potential partner and her brain switched which personality she uses to interact with him.

5 at once.

shit manga, even the mc knows.

Yotsuba is a slut

>>280532859
Negi and 22i are friends. Maybe 22i should take his talents to WSM.

I would take the stupidest one too.

>>280533224
She doesn't wash her teeth.
Good luck having to reeducate her or havkng to handle her ojisan mixed with a clogged sewer breath.

>>280524096 (OP)
reminded nino is right

>>280524096 (OP)
Don't care about Yotsuba, I'm glad Nino and Miku lost.

>>280524096 (OP)
reminded nino is right

When dealing with quints or other twins or triplets, mandatory polygamy should be legal for this situation.

>>280524096 (OP)
Nino was and is the best girl. It's a shame the mangaka couldn't write a convincing ending for Yotsuba.

It's fucking weird that his entire reason for choosing her was one interaction they had at the start of the manga that he never thought about or references a single time and that didn't change how he interacted with her in the least.

>>280525728
She sounds good as Nino and of course as Yotsuba, I don't like Sakura as the other 3.

no one likes ribons

>>280528072
Taketatsu is cursed to voice losers after what happened in Oreimo.

is Ichika canonically the prettiest?

>>280527731
I'm an Ichikachad, and I can tell you I never had any delusions that she would ever win, for one simple reason: she plays the role of the older sister in the harem despite being the same age as the others. Older sisters types seldom win in harems, so for me she was doomed even before Negi decided to make her the devil incarnate.

Short hair was better than long hair?

>>280534094
They look the same, so who's the prettiest is pointless. I do consider Ichika the hottest out of the 5 personality wise.

>>280533961
speak for yourself faggot.

How did animeonlies take Yotsuba winning? I assume many here got spoiled but I could see some people fall through the cracks. Anime only people tend to be a lot less mature or genre savvy so their asshurt was probably more intense.

Yotsuba is just for sex

Cute girls don't need to be smart.

reminder that Ichika route gave us the best story ever

How was the novel?

>>280535097
Negi's gotta be the mangaka with the most accurate impostor artists I've ever seen after Kubo

It’s crazy how Ichika is so much better than Miku. All Meeku did was make bread and mumble like a retard, buts that enough for fags who want a doormat to lust over. Let’s take a look at the facts:
-Miku was going to ask out Fuu on the condition she scored the most points on the exams
-She has the most motivation to try
-got beat out by Ichika who had an acting job to perform on top of school, in utter shambles at this blatant embarrassment
And let’s not forget the only reason she gets a date with Fuu is because of Ichika helping out her inferior sister. Meeku’s character growth is facilitated by others having to go out of their way to help her out. Meanwhile Ichika earns every bit of her growth. 1 acts as an older sister despite being almost the exact same age as them and was the only one to get a job to support them. She has done all that while pursuing a career but 4fags will seethe about her being a snake. Honestly, Ichika is too good for Fuutarou which is why she lost. Only meta reasoning can explain her “defeat” along with strong handed character assassination because Negi wanted a villain. She’s not a date rapist, not a fat fuck girl in the background, nor is she a fake genkitard that only has support by virtue of her getting an unearned victory.

1 is the first and best girl.

I can respect every girl choice outside of Itsuki. Faggots just picked her in the name of sure victory and ended with the humbling of the century. Neither the hottest, neither the cutest, a lazy food joke mom imitator.

>>280537386
Did anyone believed Itsuki was a solid choice? She barely did anything to win Futaro's love.

>>280537511
OHOHO. Plenty believed in her. Like I've said. I have zero respect for anyone that seen S1 and thought that Itsuki is best girl/winner. Cowards beyond belief.

>>280532859
Bokuben is worse thoughbietover the cop out multiple endings suck

>>280537793
Uruka is single route ending is a better and more convincing ending than Yotsuba.

>>280537853
>dead father needs to tell him who he's in love with
Yeah, amazing.
Uruka's route was trash, just like fumino's.

>>280537929
Uruka's route is the only one that doesn't need retcons. Let that sink in.

>>280537853
>Yotsuba out of nowhere
It's been 5 years get it over it

>>280524096 (OP)
Nino worst girl

>>280538021
Not what I've said. Go fuck yourself like usual.

>>280524096 (OP)
I didnt even read this but even I know yotsuba is shit and undeservedly won

Convert to Mayonaka.

>>280538807
NTA. This may work for you in real life, but not here where everyone can just read your post, retard.

>>280539641
Probably you were not the part of the threds or the manga. Uruka and the fags were bullied because Uruka didn't have a dedicated arc like the rest in the manga, yet have plenty of 2-parters. So it made sense her arc was the entire manga till the routes dropped. Unlike Ms. Martyr Complex

>>280534184
false dichotomy, nino is perfect either way.

>>280534184
I liked her long hair better, which it's a shame because people prefer the short hair version.

>>280524470

>>280524470
Miku. Rest is garbage.

>>280540257
/thread
someone finally said it

MomToubon deserved better.

#justice4momtoubonxfutarou

Why every night Yotsuba's husband goes to a hotel where Ichika stays?

>>280524470
For me, it's Itsuki

>>280524096 (OP)
She sounds bitter.

>>280540724
Ichika is a sex demon while Yotsuba is a tard, that's why.

>Make obvious winner
>She never does anything
haha subverted!

>>280536403
Counterpoint: she's into collecting STDs from old executive producers for the chance of playing some slut in a vapid blockbuster movie.
>Meanwhile Ichika earns every bit of her growth.
100% true, but remember: the end doesn't just justify the means. It also assumes their responsabilities.

>>280524127
A woman’s bitchy attitude is one of the hottest things about them

>>280537386
>I can respect every girl choice outside of Itsuki. Faggots just picked her in the name of sure victory
Well she was literally like Futaro's dream girl >>280525923


>Neither the hottest, neither the cutest
wrong >>280524658

>>280537386
I like her because she's prideful and stubborn and I find that really hot

>>280524470
Fixed

>>280543040
Sure if she didn't also try poisoning me and getting me fired

>>280543995
You don't understand banter then.

>>280543958

Drugno belongs to the streets.

Nino would have been better had she not been so radical in her dislike. She got off on the wrong foot and it tanked her. Made it worse when she only liked bad boys. Now she is only good for lewds. Yotsuba and Miku are purest.

>>280543958
get rid of the top left

>>280546676
>Starts being a mega cunt
>Gets slandered for that
Color me surprised.

>first to confess
>how could she win!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!??!?!?!?

Agree with the other anon, most only like Eatsuki because they are familiar if the meta of typical romcom winners. She fits the archetype. Yotsuba meanwhile is a duplicitous wretch of a woman
>oh wow is me, I am le worst and will concede the MCbowl
>I won’t confess and will let my sisters make moves on the man I pine for, relegating me as a background character
This retard thinks all this while throwing a bait confession to Fuu, licking his face in the apartment, and jumping him for a kiss disguised as Worstsuki. Yotsuba is not a good romcom winner, and no amount of subversion will convince me she is a preferable option to 1-3.

The issue isn't with Yotsuba winning, it's how the manga was written as a whole. The one-on-one moments with her and Fuutarou, such as her "confession" and their hang-out on the playground, were leaps and bounds better than any interaction between him and the other girls. If this dude actually sat down and wrote a proper love story and was free from editor meddling, I'd bet money on it being good.

In terms of physical attractiveness I find myself most draw to Ichicute and Nino. Nino can rock both short and long hair, a rare asset in a woman and is more fashionable to the others. Nonetheless it dawns upon me that Ichika is even better looking and more desirable as a woman and person. She stands in her own as someone without ire, someone who can grow from past mistakes and one who supports the growth of others. Besides her playful nature and sharp tongue, she can still be flustered and love struck and captures the feminine allure one yearns for in a partner. From an objective standpoint, she is qualitatively the best girl. 1 without none to compare.

>>280524096 (OP)
Another self-aware thing is where Negi through the little boy in Ichika's side says the story would suck if Fuutarou just gets with Yotsuba and the other girls get no closure. Too bad the closure was terrible and it was a slap in the face to any fan of a losing girl with the Quint's game at the wedding.

Ichika's closure: Continued to be the wingman for Fuutarou on a badminton date the next day after being rejected
Nino's closure: Finally gets rejected 5 years later at her sister's wedding
Miku's closure: I actually liked Miku's closure, she realized she didn't need Futarou's love to validate herself, she grew to like herself on her own. Overall best written character, besides the stupid bread plot and Sister's War making her a pathetic baby.
Itsuki's closure: Realizes her feelings after Fuutarou already made his choice, keeps them to herself, also the only girl to never get a kiss.

>>280524470
5 > 3 > 2 > 1 >>>>>>>> my shit this morning > 4

>>280524470
All, would you accept seeing the face of the woman you love cry 4 times more than smile?

>>280547507
what are their names again?

>>280524127
You forgot she literally drugged him twice too.

>>280548100
1, 2, 3, 4, 5

>>280548216
Yeah but he was asking for it.

I really do love these promotionals. The art is really nice.

Just seeing that bitch Yotsuba pisses me off

Can we all agree on the fact the go go loser ranger fucking sucks at least?

>>280550316
It started out good buy man does it meander and add too many characters. It's a mess.

>>280526155
My guy forgetting about the most obvious winner Suzukiri

Ichika was the worst and only girl that deserved to lose

>>280552136
This but shitno

>>280525728
I think Minase Inori would have been a better Miku. She does Itsuki just fine, but soft spoken girls are her forte (i.e. Chino) and Miku would have fit her the best.

>>280525728
>>280552672
But now that I think about it, Inorin (Chino) has to be Ayaneru (Cocoa) little sister so she couldn’t be Miku.

>>280526735
Ichika is the closest one to Yotsuba.
>short hair
>can be pretty athletic
>is an alpha female
>direct
>strong
>yet willing to support her man
Ichika is fine.
Ichika was also the other half of lolikano.

On paper the "best" quint, but not the best quint for Fuutaro. Yotsuba is the cutest though.

>>280536403
Otakus have shit taste and like doormat women because they are so intimidated that any 2d that even REMOTELY does anything resembling a real woman would make their dicks shrink and cause them to shrivel up like the omega incels they truly are.

>>280526735
>Futarou has bunny ears ahoge
>Yotsubest has bunny ears ribbon
It was obvious from the get go if you weren’t a speed reader

>>280536403
>1 is the first and best girl
How is she first girl? Because she's first born?

best girl

>>280553158
Read his post. Ichika wouldn't work for Fuu because Fuu needs someone to dominate. Ichika is far too driven and mature to settle with Fuu.

I hope they make an anime out of the Quint RPG coming out

>>280553494
Ichika = Earth
Nino = Fire
Miku = Water
Yotsuba = Wind
Itsuki = Lightning

Ichika and Itsuki should switch powers.

>>280524096 (OP)
Nino literally drugged the MC, how can anyone think that the author thought of her as a winner???

>>280550316
I think the Invaders Right Association arc was good at least, shame the anime butchered it.

Nino is the retard's choice

>>280524096 (OP)
>writer mocks his own writing
At least Negi is self-aware

Ickya is the worst looking so she never had a chance.

>>280552136
this

Nino my love

>>280524470
Ichika with Nino as a side bitch.

>>280525288
This is why I hate this ending, absolutely pointless story with a very very shallow motivation on Yotsuba, “teehee I dont want you because Im a piece of shit”

>>280526627
Strawberry 100% says fucking otherwise.

>>280525331
>me, watching it for the first time during the scene when he has his hands in his head and yotsuba wakes him up by calling his name
>"uhhh, she's the winner i think?"

>>280524470
oooonly twoooo
can make this world seem right
oooonly twoooo
can make make this darkness bright

>>280553560
and none of the others did anything to stop it. they are all complicit. cry harder

>>280553030
this

>>280555769
>>280555778
>>280555789
>>280555802
>>280555888
kissable

>>280555947
Cry about what? Nino is a loser, that was the end of her story.

>>280524096 (OP)

3 > 5 > 2 > 4 > 1

>>280557574
Fudge, Jurice and Eggsecutioner

>what's going on in this thre... oh, nevermind, carry on, carry on.

>>280555888
Its only you

>>280524470
2 > 4 > 1 > 3 > 5

5>4>3>2>1
No wonder you failed math.

>>280555888

I hope 5toubun threads, particularly Nino threads, never stop getting posted.

>>280524606
Same, I was a quiet Yotsubafag and was happy to see her whenever she popped up. Most people thought of her as their number 2 girl but there was some yotsubafags. Then she was suddenly thrust into the forefront and had to bear the fury of the rest of the fandom. It was worth it though, I was riding high for days on the meltdowns.

>>280524470
harem end nakadashi in all holes just like in doujins.

>>280559087
Maybe it’s because I spoiled the ending before even starting it but the winner seems so obvious in every interaction.
Fate and the other girls keep trying to keep her out of focus but it’s plain as day who wants to be with him every second of the day.

>>280525864
>gonna get past the fact that Yotsuba won because she was nice to the guy?
i never got over the fact that imoto didn't win in Strawberry 100 percent.

or that Oreimo's imoto is a piece of shit.

>>280524268
actions have consequences, if someone was a dick to you for years then stopped for a month you're not gonna treat him like you're best friend right away

>>280559147
Trust me bro, during the manga's run very few people thought she'd win. More people thought Itsuki would win than people thinking 1234 could win combine. It wasn't until the reveal in ch 85~ did people consider Yotsuba's dark horse candidacy. Ch 105~ sealed it but most people were hopeful Yotsuba wouldn't win. Then Ch 113, what a 2 week period that was since the manga was on break for a week.

>>280559087
The 5 trillion cope theories after Fuutarou went to Yotsuba's room were great.
>He's actually going there to confront her about the childhood friend thing for closure
>He's going to Yotsuba's room specifically reject her
>This is how Miku/Nino can still win [schizo babble]

>>280559298
Off model, Nino isn't that big.

>>280559260
What happens in those chapters?
I just started S2 but I like spoilers.

>>280559320
I have never watched the anime so I have no idea what it covers or if the story is the same. I may even have the chapters mixed up.
>Ch 85~ Yotsuba is revealed to be the girl Fuutarou met when they were young and that she was a cocky retard. She was the source of everything going wrong.
>Ch 107~ Yotsuba is the only one given sad closure in the festival arc.
>Ch 113~ Fuutarou goes to Yotsuba's room, implying he chose her

>>280559318
She will be after our children.

>>280559394
thanks

this is really pathetic

Yotsucute

>>280555780
Tf are you talking about. Aya was the promised girl, he asked out nishino by accident and fell in love with her like 2-3 times. Negi took all the positive things from strawberry 100 and put them into yotsuba and all the negative shit into ichika

>>280559776
It's a false flag by a Nino hater who ants to purge our thread with the bump limit.

>ninobros
WERE'S SO FUCKING BACK BROS

superninobrothers...

>>280554802
Nah, she's the hottest out of the five, and I'm not even that much into short haired girls.

>>280561659
Apparently you are since they are the same besides their hair.

>>280561688
I know, but Ichika has something that makes her sexier than her sister. It could be the attitude, design or something else, but she's incredibly hot, and I feel that wouldn't change even if her hair would be longer.

>>280561948
It definitely would because her hair sucks.

>>280525003
she is massively popular so she won in a way

>>280559776
A name based filter is shit, takes a single shell command to rename the entire folder.

>>280562084
Nah, she's good as she is.

>>280557574
I swear AI is getting too funny.

>>280524096 (OP)
Nene will avenge Nino.

And Iko will avenge Miku.

>>280524096 (OP)
Nino when she feels 0.01% of mistreatement Itsuki does

also there's an official colored 5toubun?

>>280559185
>him
I'm not treating a guy and a girl attracted to me the same way. Women are also more fickle and retarded than men anyway

And also it's not like they're strangers. It turns out they knew each other in the past in some capacity, and he had to get along with her anyway

>>280563749
>Nene

>>280557574
Nino's cellmate, btw.

ohnonononononibros...

>>280563007
>takes a single shell command to rename the entire folder.
How?

Negi should end his silly power rangers parody and make another harem romcom.

>>280524470
Miku, forever and always. Yotsuba winning is such a "LOOK AT ME, I'M SUBVERSIVE WRITER!" bs, it's still pisses me off.

>>280563667
>>280563685
>>280563702
>>280563714
>>280563732
>>280563753
>>280563823
Long hair is so much more superior it's not even funny.

>>280563941
I mean, Miku was another Kosaki, she never stood a chance.

>>280526756
Right? I laugh at all the people who think she's in love with him. No proof at all.

>>280525864
Itsuki was being reasonable & she warmed up to him naturally. Their relationship progression was PERFECT and had me fooled that she was gonna win.
Then that cock sucker Negi sidelined her and she didn't even get to kiss him.

>you don't get it it's about how men and women can be friends platonically :~)
Then why does she suddenly develop feelings for him after he confesses to Yotsuba? Makes no fucking sense to pull that thread now of all times.

J-kun is so lucky

>>280563983
True.

I like Itsuki most but Nino makes me most horny

Objectively the prettiest sister both irl and storywise

>>280564168
This, but only when Nino is suffering.

>>280563983
>Long hair is so much more superior it's not even funny.
shit taste, faggot

Does Nino shave down there?

>>280564320
He's right, retard.

Miku > Nino > Ichika

Itsuki and Yotsuba were never even part of the race. Yotsuba was clearly picked at random, nearing the end.

>>280551944
She dumped D.

>>280564642
It's Miku and Nino who never had a snowball's chance in hell if you knew anything about storytelling.

>>280553560
>Nino literally drugged the MC, how can anyone think that the author thought of her as a winner???
In the showa and early heisei ages, that shit meant a winning flag.

2btfos...

>>280525288
>genki girls
Not this shit again.
She's a passive menhera, Nino's an active menhera

>>280564914
Nino had some chances since she was the token tsundere, Miku had 0 tho.

>>280558447
based

>>280565150
Damn, they really are identical.

>>280565150
>>280565368
fuutarou would know who is who with his eyes closed.

>>280565368
which is a problem, the winner was being teased for having little girl pantsu

>>280565398
They're going to sit on him?

I need to sex every quint except Yotsuba

>>280565650
Are you afraid of gorilla women?

>>280565736
I don't think she'd be a good fuck, personality wise

>>280565716
Nino and Ichika need more stuff together.

>>280526401
this describes Itsuki more than Nino
Nino was definitely an off/on switch

>>280565783
so you're afraid

>>280566958
no because I don't get the impression that she would be jackhammering herself into my crotch which I'd enjoy

ninibros..