← Home ← Back to /a/

Thread 280718485

42 posts 24 images /a/
Anonymous No.280718485 [Report] >>280721685 >>280722206 >>280722505 >>280723733 >>280726841 >>280727030 >>280727306 >>280740126 >>280741156
Silent Witch
How much of a difference between the Light Novel source and the anime can you handle before it sticks out like a skyscraper in the middle of a small forest?

For reference, the anime segment summarised all of this into 40 seconds. This is why you should also read the Light Novel source if it's an anime adaptation from one
Anonymous No.280718813 [Report]
Fuck Monica
Anonymous No.280719307 [Report] >>280732323 >>280734105
not going to waste time on light novel when i'm too busy looking at pictures
Anonymous No.280719729 [Report] >>280721154 >>280726678 >>280727160 >>280727376 >>280735355
so... she fucks the cat?
Anonymous No.280720770 [Report]
buy it anon!
https://detail.tmall.com/item.htm?id=944954867175
Anonymous No.280721154 [Report]
>>280719729
Yes
Anonymous No.280721685 [Report]
>>280718485 (OP)
Too many words
Anonymous No.280722206 [Report]
>>280718485 (OP)
Happens a lot
Anonymous No.280722505 [Report]
>>280718485 (OP)
It's just an inevitability that changes and cuts need to happen in an adaptation like this. The difficult thing is making the adaptation actually make sense and flow well on its own, which I don't think they really managed to do here.
Anonymous No.280723733 [Report] >>280726171 >>280726202 >>280726292 >>280726374
>>280718485 (OP)
Longer doesn't equal better
Also, just noticed there's V2s for episodes 2 and 3, anyone has idea what got changed?
Anonymous No.280725880 [Report] >>280731939
Wife
Anonymous No.280726171 [Report] >>280726202
>>280723733
On episode two, there is no text change. Only removal of \c&Hffffff&\fnsansSerif
So styling changes I guess.
Anonymous No.280726202 [Report]
>>280723733
>>280726171
Same on episode three.
Anonymous No.280726292 [Report]
>>280723733
All instances of \c&Hffffff&\fnsansSerif was removed when it comes to episode three. But on episode two it was all except one, at 19:01
Anonymous No.280726374 [Report]
>>280723733
Yeah, It's only a few font changes.
Anonymous No.280726678 [Report]
>>280719729
No
Anonymous No.280726841 [Report]
>>280718485 (OP)
Loius is a genius. Prince was right with his 2nd assumption, but honestly who could believe this rapebait is a bodyguard?
Anonymous No.280727030 [Report]
>>280718485 (OP)
First light novel adaptation?
Anonymous No.280727160 [Report]
>>280719729
Maybe
Anonymous No.280727306 [Report] >>280727846 >>280734321
>>280718485 (OP)
Honestly, I'm not impressed so far. The first mystery was an asspull - instead of presenting us with an actual puzzle, Monica simply pulled dirty gloves out of her ass like it's BBC's Sherlock, and that was the entire solution. Also, Monica's inability to talk is getting annoying now. All the long, labored pauses could be cut in half, and nothing would be lost. I get that it's a big part of her character, but they could've directed it better.
Anonymous No.280727376 [Report]
>>280719729
idk
Anonymous No.280727846 [Report] >>280727898 >>280727965 >>280728313
>>280727306
>everybody is supposed to wear gloves
>this girl isn't wearing gloves shortly after the pot fell
>monica later finds a pair of gloves at the scene
Anonymous No.280727898 [Report]
>>280727846
Too complicated, it needs more tell and less show.
Anonymous No.280727965 [Report]
>>280727846
the manga looks like shit
Anonymous No.280728264 [Report] >>280730112
surely this is against the dress code?
Anonymous No.280728313 [Report] >>280728402 >>280728584
>>280727846
>everybody is supposed to wear gloves
This was never established.
Anonymous No.280728402 [Report]
>>280728313
To put it more simply.
Everyone are wearing gloves, including her, but she happens to appear without gloves after that incidient.
Anonymous No.280728584 [Report]
>>280728313
A proper lady wears gloves, especially white ones (though they are free to adorn them as they wish). It's a show of their nobility, because who gets their gloves dirty? Only commoners would, and only they wouldn't be seen wearing gloves like that all the time, either. The LN does mention this sort of stuff, but it's hard to translate that into the anime.

Monica's gloves are white and unadorned to go along with her cover story of being abused by her adoptive family. They're even not the right size for her, being slightly too big for her hands.
Anonymous No.280730112 [Report]
>>280728264
Not for her
Anonymous No.280731939 [Report]
>>280725880
cute
Anonymous No.280732323 [Report] >>280733671
>>280719307
Considering her powers as the silent witch all that I can imagine from looking at this picture is her casting the wind spell to upskirt herself in front of him and pretending to be embarrassed.
Anonymous No.280733671 [Report]
>>280732323
it's silent witch, anon
not silent bitch
Anonymous No.280734068 [Report]
Anonymous No.280734105 [Report] >>280734518
>>280719307
Monica wouldn't wear cute panties like that. Plain panties with yellow stains fit her more.
Anonymous No.280734321 [Report]
>>280727306
The chick wasn't exactly a master criminal considering both her, the dude in episode one and ice guy now apparently are under some kind of mind Magicks.
Anonymous No.280734518 [Report]
>>280734105
Indeed, they are too high class for a girl like her. If anyone caught sight of her such a fancy pair of panties on her, they'd think she had stolen it or that something is off about how she is treated yet allowed a fancy pair of panties
Anonymous No.280735355 [Report]
>>280719729
Can you repeat the question?
Anonymous No.280737534 [Report]
kot sex
Anonymous No.280738513 [Report]
Anonymous No.280740126 [Report]
>>280718485 (OP)
I'm kinda mad, the slap scene and everything around it was one of my favorite parts of the LN
Anonymous No.280740326 [Report]
Is this witch kaos
Anonymous No.280741156 [Report]
>>280718485 (OP)
I'm a little disappointed they skipped that scene, but I'm still having a blast with the anime. I really hope it gets another season after this.