Nepotism in One Piece - /a/ (#280893078) [Archived: 14 hours ago]

Anonymous
7/25/2025, 10:07:11 AM No.280893078
nepotism-piece-and-its-3-4-characters-that-quite-literally-v0-zl1q82sui6cf1
After this week's chapter folks are complaining about nepotism being a major factor in the story, it most certainly helps, but it isn't everything.

>Luffy
Sure he is the son of Dragon and Grandson of Garp, but Garp didn't teach him about haki battleship bags/etc..... He was rather behind the other supernova's when he got to Sabaody..

>Ace
Didn't get shit handed to him, Garp did a ass job of training him as well. No one taught him the haki basics before setting out in the world. He didn't even learn swordsmanship.

>Teach
lived on Whitebeard's ship for years, didn't get any special training and got a shitty glove instead. Had to scheme and plot to get everything. Honestly he could have begged thatch for the fruit, but still.

>Momo and Hiyori
Hiyori isn't shit wholesale, and Momo has no training with the adult body. Also their grandfather was was good craftsman, but didn't have much battle prowess nor did he educate anyone on the craft.

>Katakuri
None of Big Mom's kids are really that out there aside from maybe Katakuri and Cracker.

>Law
His parents were normal doctors, he climbed up on his own, and fell because he didn't have man power.

>Same with Kidd
Got pretty far, but he didn't have man power and fell flat.

>Caribou
he ain't shit, even with a good logia

Nepotism isn't as big of a deal as folks are making it out to be.
Replies: >>280893096 >>280893121 >>280893675 >>280894628 >>280895435 >>280896729 >>280897071 >>280897109 >>280897917 >>280897938
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 10:09:54 AM No.280893096
>>280893078 (OP)
it's more like meta nepotism, you aren't relevant to the story if you aren't a close relative to someone important
Replies: >>280893152 >>280894522
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 10:11:50 AM No.280893121
>>280893078 (OP)
kill yourself pasta spamming redditor
Replies: >>280893152
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 10:16:00 AM No.280893152
>>280893121
I only typed it once yesterday and didn't get to reply, chill out. Folks are bitching about this.

>>280893096
There are plenty who aren't
Replies: >>280893179
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 10:18:58 AM No.280893179
>>280893152
you are anti-4chan
Replies: >>280893490
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 10:54:22 AM No.280893490
>>280893179
I have probably been here longer than you have diaper girl..
Replies: >>280893513
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 10:56:17 AM No.280893513
>>280893490
you weren't even here before captcha was implemented, roodypoo
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 11:12:52 AM No.280893675
>>280893078 (OP)
>Katakuri
Are people really complaining about nepotism in the Big Mom pirates? That's like their whole thing.
Replies: >>280893918 >>280895709
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 11:29:42 AM No.280893918
>>280893675
All of the other children couldn't do anything aside from cracker and Katakuri. Big Mom herself didn't train anyone.
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 12:15:09 PM No.280894522
>>280893096
It's the other way around, actually. If you are relevant to the story,chances are you will have important relatives popping up.
Luffy is not important because he is Garp's grandson. Garp is important because Luffy is the main character. Garp would not exist if the character of Luffy didn't exist, Garp's narrative importance entirely derives from him being Luffy's grampa.
Replies: >>280894550
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 12:18:42 PM No.280894550
>>280894522
you'll never succeed in explaining to 4channies that fiction is just made up by the writer
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 12:23:57 PM No.280894609
Blackbeard and Whitebeards final conversation feels now a bit dull since we now know wb was on bb's fathers ship. And rocks seems to have been such a world changing character. Who cares about a man roger was waiting for? It's all about rocks now
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 12:25:19 PM No.280894628
>>280893078 (OP)
kill yourself redditor
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 12:26:46 PM No.280894646
>BB was on WB's ship
>WB was on BB'S dad's ship
By the pattern, WB's son will be on BB's ship.

Weevil joins BB confirmed?
Replies: >>280894674 >>280894773 >>280895505
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 12:29:30 PM No.280894674
>>280894646
I don't think it works for clones my guy.
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 12:40:40 PM No.280894773
>>280894646
It's silly. Does it continue all the way to void century or even the times before that?
Replies: >>280894869
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 12:49:24 PM No.280894869
>>280894773
it's a yin yang thing. always a bb in a wb crew always a wb in a bb crew
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 12:49:28 PM No.280894873
The problem is that ODA doesn't want to make his story more complicated than it is. And one thing he has to do as a writer is keep things simple.
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 1:37:28 PM No.280895435
hq720
hq720
md5: 524032866c0cd804123007980798daa9🔍
>>280893078 (OP)
>nepotism isn't as big of a deal as people make it out to be, honest you guys
if you say so, not sure why you would want to talk about it in a childrens cartoon show where literally anyone can be a swordsman or a giga brawler without devil fruits and avoid the seastone and drowning to a puddle debuff
in one piece universe the theme is devil fruits are a double edged sword, brawlers and swordsman can be stronger with haki and air jump and anyone can be strong with G U T S and hard work (except girls cause yuckie)
not sure what kind of nepotism in one piece you're talking about but i hope this thread helped you alleviate survivors guilt or some shit m8, go dry your eyes in a bloodsoaked hundred dollar bill or something
Replies: >>280895553
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 1:41:56 PM No.280895505
buggy1 weevil (2)
buggy1 weevil (2)
md5: 3d55272b6c44cac58422ce62170cad39🔍
>>280894646
>Weevil joins BB confirmed?
Weevil said that he hates BB for WB dead. He will join Cross Guild.
Replies: >>280897688
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 1:45:16 PM No.280895553
>>280895435
>(except girls cause yuckie)
Based. Girls are totally yuckie
Replies: >>280897170
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 1:56:58 PM No.280895709
>>280893675
doesn't hit as hard when literally everybody else does it.
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 2:35:58 PM No.280896231
i don't know if it counts as nepotism, but the whole point of One Piece is inherited will.
Joyboy>Roger>Luffy
Davy Jones>Xebec>Teach
Replies: >>280896873
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 3:09:29 PM No.280896729
>>280893078 (OP)
It's not that hard to understand. The nepotism thing is here because One Piece became a story involving the whole world changing with new important events. The story became a mythology. And when your story become a mythology, most of your relevant characters become related to important characters who did great things in the past and we now see their heirs. This is why you have these storied of divine beings and powerful ancestors.

And it tend to happen on a lot of shounen. You can subvert that trope by adding the importance of free will and not just saying everything was about winning by destiny.

Of course if you wanted a story featuring self-made mens it's kinda disappointing but every shounens were like this before getting mythological.
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 3:18:09 PM No.280896873
>>280896231
>picking up the torch is nepotism
it really isn't, it's a pretty old trope in mythology due to monarchies being so popular, if you pass on the torch to someone else for them to carry out your shared dream = not nepotism it would be closer to heroism
tldr; it's not, it's passing on the torch
https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/PassingTheTorch
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 3:32:25 PM No.280897071
be gone
be gone
md5: fc589670b7ea29b1b09734e395b5a845🔍
>>280893078 (OP)
>NOOOOOOOO I need shitty no-names to get more representations because it appeals to mu pronouns
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 3:34:50 PM No.280897109
>>280893078 (OP)
Luffy is a big nepo baby. Sure, Garp didn't teach him about battleship haki, but he trained him as a child until his teens which carried him until the first half of the grand line.
Then here comes the biggest nepo crime, since he is Dragon's son. He got bailed out by the trannies to get out of impeldown, they were waiting until Dragon gave them the signal to do so and they thought Dragon would be in Marineford as well since Luffy kept saying Ace and him were brothers.

Then for the second half of the grand line he got vouched by red hair and Rayleigh just trained him. Law only safed Luffy because he is a D.
Had Luffy not been son of Dragon or grandchild of Garp then he would not been born in the Goa Kingdom like Dragon and would not have had the chance to meet Shanks.
And if he wasn't son of Dragon then he wouldn't be a D. and Law wouldn't pick up interest in him.
Replies: >>280899361
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 3:38:48 PM No.280897170
>>280895553
wanna kiss, anon kun? :p
Replies: >>280898393
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 4:07:01 PM No.280897688
>>280895505
That's what Buggy needs to stop being the same one joke character. Even Mr Satan wasn't the same joke for that long he got shit to do during Buu while Buggy has been doing nothing since Marineford. It's fucking boring
Replies: >>280903600
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 4:19:03 PM No.280897917
>>280893078 (OP)
The most important theme in one piece is legacy and inherited will
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 4:20:37 PM No.280897938
>>280893078 (OP)
>folks
Twitter's that way
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 4:45:35 PM No.280898393
>>280897170
I-if you're s-sure...b-but it's not like i...it's not like I like you...or a-anything like that...! B-baka!
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 5:25:54 PM No.280899361
>>280897109
>He got bailed out by the trannies etc.
Nigga, Luffy gets bailed out every single arc. Every. Single. Arc. Last arc he literally got bailed out by Joyboy's Haki that was kept inside a robot for 800+ years. It's not nepotism, it's just plot armor because the little retard keeps punching above his weight but the story can't have him die.
Replies: >>280899585 >>280899678 >>280901127
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 5:36:20 PM No.280899585
>>280899361
imagine if there was no Nika retcon and the manga just straight up ended when Kaido killed him
the raid failed and all of his allies and crew died and Wano went back into slavery
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 5:40:05 PM No.280899678
>>280899361
>Joyboy's Haki that was kept inside a robot for 800+ years
Man this sounds wild, almost like that screencap of all the crazy shit that happened in Wano.
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 5:48:33 PM No.280899864
You retards make it so obvious when you've just learned a new word. "Nepotism" being two weeks ago.
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 6:40:13 PM No.280901127
>>280899361
Still he got bailed out by daddy's connection before see Kuma and trannies and he got bailed out by Grandaddies connection before see Kuzan.

Of course as the chosen one he is carried by fate and destiny on top of privileged nepo shit.
Anonymous
7/25/2025, 7:45:50 PM No.280903600
>>280897688
He create cross guild, dude