← Home ← Back to /a/

Thread 280922678

33 posts 30 images /a/
Anonymous No.280922678 >>280922687 >>280922752 >>280924027 >>280924329 >>280924837 >>280926024 >>280926222 >>280926243 >>280926260 >>280926365 >>280926486 >>280928913 >>280929694 >>280929849 >>280929921 >>280930961 >>280931101 >>280931712 >>280932515 >>280933046
Is CGI inherently bad?
Anonymous No.280922687 >>280922695
>>280922678 (OP)
I don't know, post more of that doro hedoro muscle mommy tho
Anonymous No.280922695 >>280924808
>>280922687
Anonymous No.280922752
>>280922678 (OP)
No. But it has become an abused short cut for lazy people.
Anonymous No.280924027
>>280922678 (OP)
Yes, good CGI is as time-consuming as good 2d animation
Anonymous No.280924329
>>280922678 (OP)
CGI can look good if it's done with heart & soul.
Anonymous No.280924808
>>280922695
Bump
Anonymous No.280924837 >>280926243
>>280922678 (OP)
Its 2025. If you can't tell good cgi and bad cgi apart you are completely lost. YES there is a difference.
Anonymous No.280926024
>>280922678 (OP)
Only when they mix mediums
Either keep it all 2d or all 3d, stop mixing shit together, it never works
Anonymous No.280926083 >>280926192
Depends on the anime
Anonymous No.280926192
>>280926083
BEHOLD
Anonymous No.280926222
>>280922678 (OP)
CGI mixed with hand drawn art is inherently bad, yes.
Anonymous No.280926243 >>280926449
>>280922678 (OP)
Yes.
Rise in CGI followed the rise in phonefag use to watch anime.
>>280924837
No it's all bad.
When someones says 'muh CGI was good' it's either because they lack eyes, are watching on a tiny phone screen, or are trying to defend their 4/10 pedoAbyss anime in the hopes that homoerotic man-on-boy smut goes mainstream.
It won't, but I'm sorry that happened to you.
Anonymous No.280926260
>>280922678 (OP)
>Is CGI inherently bad?
Yes, but I feel like weird shit series like dorohedoro pull it off well enough to be passable.
Anonymous No.280926314
CGI as in 3D models only or the kind computer generated effects that ufotable uses on Fate and Kimetsu no Yaiba?
Anonymous No.280926365
>>280922678 (OP)
It's bad when you get poos to do it.
Anonymous No.280926449
>>280926243
>No it's all bad.
Anonymous No.280926486
>>280922678 (OP)
cgi rarely seems to have been used because the studio thought 'this will produce the best product,' just 'this will produce adequate product on schedule.' dorohedoro was unwatchable. cgi is the worst possible medium to render hayashida's artstyle
Anonymous No.280928913
>>280922678 (OP)
No, not always.
Anonymous No.280929694 >>280929913
>>280922678 (OP)
CGI will find its place.
It's basically the same as going from hand drawn to digital.
Digital is its own pros and cons vs hand drawn. And CGI will be very much the same.
But CGI is still relatively new and it'll mature and become more refined
Anonymous No.280929849
>>280922678 (OP)
No, but anything done well in 3D is ALWAYS more impressive if it is done at least as well in 2D.
Anonymous No.280929913 >>280930036
>>280929694
>CGI is still relatively new
The fuck? CGI has been around for over half a century at this point.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RqQvVts5Yj0&list=PLUaT3EWBdc1dOsBV7cQ9wNGWyoamirzH_&index=2&ab_channel=UltimateHistoryofCGI
Anonymous No.280929914
I liked Akudama Drive.
Anonymous No.280929921
>>280922678 (OP)
I just hate how the hair looks in 3D models
Anonymous No.280930036 >>280930429
>>280929913
Disingenuous argument.
It hasn't been widely used in anime until relatively recently.
A couple of fringe cases over the past few decades doesn't mean we should expect quality be perfect.
Anonymous No.280930111
No
Anonymous No.280930429
>>280930036
Stop making excuses for Japanese hack-jobs. CGI has been around for long enough.
Anonymous No.280930961
>>280922678 (OP)
Ajin got fucked over by incomplete soulless CGI adaptation that nobody watched. It fucking sucks and hardly ever used to its strengths in anime.
Anonymous No.280931101
>>280922678 (OP)
No. Just like in movies, if you notice it's CGI then it's bad CGI.
Anonymous No.280931712
>>280922678 (OP)
Even in otherwise well done examples they still almost always fuck up emulating smear frames/motion blur and the result looks choppy and terrible.
Anonymous No.280932515
>>280922678 (OP)
yes
Anonymous No.280933046
>>280922678 (OP)
A tool is only as good as the hands that wield it
Anonymous No.280934153
Arcane in 3D is probably better animated than 97% of all anime out there.