Thread 281201635

Which was the happiest ending for Shirou?

>Fate
>UBW
>HF

Nasu already told you, HF.

Fate route
Almost all waifus are alive. Saber got the death she wanted and Illya is in his house

>>281201635 (OP)
Heaven's Feel obviously, and the canonical ending as well.

>>281201665
>>281201780
lol

Why do they love Shirou?

>>281201635 (OP)
UBW good end clearly.

>>281201635 (OP)
Deen Stay Night

>>281201635 (OP)
HF, it's the canon one for a reason.

Fate epilogue

>getting to be in avalon with your wife
Obviously

>>281201635 (OP)
Prisma because he gets to be a normie not worrying about anything at all.

>>281201635 (OP)
>>281202640
>>281201823
Shirou and Sakura are the only ones with true love and the strength to make it work, that's a big part of why Heaven's Feel is the canon story.

>>281202793
>>281201665
>>281201780
Shirou at the end of HF isn't even himself anymore, just mindbroken sex doll Sakura had Touko construct. Truly the worst end

>>281202852
Fate has Shirou dying in the middle east alone and not accepting Alaya's deal before the Avalon retcon.
UBW has him still believing in the fake ideals but it's "okay" because Rin is there.
HF has him living in a slightly "faulty" by the greatest puppet body maker in the universe and living a normal life with everyone there(except Saber kek).
HF also gives closure to Illya's, Kirei's and Archer's problems.

>>281201635 (OP)
3rei

>>281203004
>Fate has Shirou dying in the middle east alone and not accepting Alaya's deal before the Avalon retcon.
Citation needed

>>281201823
Nasu's amwf fetish

>>281203004
>HF also gives closure to Illya's, Kirei's and Archer's problems.
No

>>281203004
UBW's message is that it doesn't matter if an ideal is "real" or "fake" so long as you find value in it. Most ideals are fake. Any ideals you have are probably just shit you copied from somewhere else. Every single ideal that every single individual currently living on this planet is something borrowed or inherited from a predecessor. Even the ideal of "You should just settle for a normal happiness" is just something you copied from someone else. All humans are fake.

>>281204319
*All modern humans are fake
The old ones were cool according to Gil

>>281204319
I like how UBW emphasized that the divide and conflict in the ideas that make up a hero is something profound in and of itself. Shirou, if he chooses to, will live life taking the contradiction to heart. To ride the line between monotonous selfishness and suicidal martyrdom is to be like a surfer, always on the cusp of being eaten by the waves as you experience the most heroic yet brutal life there is. Absolute shonenkino
People think Fate is opposite to HF within the spectrum of seigi - no seigi but it's actually the middle ground. Its message of loving/helping yourself in order to love/help others manages to change Shirou's path of heroism while still keeping the end goal the same. It's definitely more rational, even if it's within a route that ends up feeling lamer than the other ones despite its many qualities.
HF is HF and I like it but this is the /a/ thread so I'm not going to talk about it

>>281201635 (OP)
This one. It's not even close.

>>281201635 (OP)
I love how you ask "happiest for Shirou" because the best ending(s) are where he faces the consequences of his retarded actions and dies.

>>281204918
Shirou being Shirou is ultimately what saves Fuyuki. Without him, the city would have been a massive cursed crater after the war.

The world of Fate is one where insane gods, monsters and humans keep nearly fucking up the world, and heroes need to rise up in order to thwart them. Heroes have to be a little crazy in order to achieve the miracles they need to perform to win. There's nothing reasonable about what's happening in the Holy Grail War. There's nothing reasonable about Angra Mainyu. Heroes are the ones who rise up to take care of the issue when common sense fails.

>>281205222
>There's nothing reasonable about Angra Mainyu
His preferences are

>>281201635 (OP)
Fate Realta Nua > Heaven's Feel > Unlimited Blade Works > Fate

>>281201823
Because he can jump well

>>281202852
>"oh no my soul got put into a sex doll and now im forced to fuck two horny sisters and a possible third purple haired horny older women"

>>281201635 (OP)
t. Shirou
t. Nasu

>>281204528
>>281204319
You still don't get it. Everything of fate and ubw get overwritten because HF is the true story where Shirou finally accepts reality and now can move forward.
Sakura saves his soul from those ruinous ideals and gives him a future.

>>281201635 (OP)
Daily threesome sex with Rin and Saber in UBW alt ending so that one.

Le Sakura Discordtrannies have arrived

>>281208643
and me

Hf.

But on another matter, when are the next chapters of 3rei gonna come out?

>>281201635 (OP)
You can't really quantify happiness, and he is happy in all of them.

>>281201635 (OP)
In the UBW good ending, Shirou dates Rin but still keeps Saber. There's also no implication that he will become Archer, and Rin doesn't go to bongland either

>>281201635 (OP)
Fate. He goes to live with his waifu in Avalon forever.
HF is the worst - not only the wormsut is alive and around, but your body is a fucking dickless doll.

>>281210155
This. HF it's "maybe" the more most popular route, but UBW feel the good one.

I'm pretty sure Sunny Days is the happiest ending and it's not even close.
Read the vn

>>281201635 (OP)
question solved 22 years ago.

>>281201665
>>281201780
>>281202466
He said "happiest"
He had a loli older sister he could fuck without consequence who owned a fucking castle, but she fucking dies in HF and he gets put into a magical sex doll because Archer's arm fucking hates him to death
Fate is the happiest ending because he loses nothing and no one he cares about dies and he gets to live out his fantasy of being a hero.

>HF also gives closure to Illya's, Kirei's and Archer's problems.
Replace "gives closure to" with "ends" and "problems" with "lives"

>>281203004
>Fate has Shirou
escaping eternal slavery after death. Sounds like a win to me.

>>281201635 (OP)
all endings happy

>>281201635 (OP)
idk

>>281201823
high jump skill

>>281214087
Can't beat the high jump, man

>>281201635 (OP)
Ilya wouldve been the true end route, and you know it

>>281214890
Fuck off, baby raper

>>281214923
uhm, she tries to rape him