Are characters actually supposed to be less beautiful than what we believe to see? The creator approved of this casting

yes, anime characters are usually simple shaps with a lot of negative space you can interpret into whatever you want. it's just that boys are very vocal and they want to see sex bombs

>>281348928 (OP)
We should not be seeing niggers at all.

>>281348982
>it's just that boys are very vocal and they want to see sex bombs
i agree with that, but I don't want to see a character's skin color changed without a reason

>>281348928 (OP)
Shut the hell up, niggers.
Why you're harassing these pretty white girls is beyond me.
Just because Vivi is from Alabasta, and just because Alabasta is in a desert, doesn't mean she's going to be a darkie like the rest of you niggers.

>>281348928 (OP)
SHEEEEIIIT

>>281348928 (OP)
If they are going to make these characters black then it would be better to keep their natural hair colors, the black washing already shits all over the original design so you might as well go all in.
Keeping the blue hairs just makes them look retarded

Those is going to be a nice pol thread, good job moods.

>>281348928 (OP)
More like "The creator was pressured into approving this cast by the investors"

>>281348928 (OP)
Objectively good and authentic casting.

dat piece

>>281349672
or just a few blue hair strands or something

this show has some of the most retarded styling, makeup and wardrobe i have ever seen in filmmaking. absolutely vile shit

>>281349677
Hello Netflix bot.

>>281349769
Not really

>>281350025
>I'm racist

>>281348928 (OP)
Oda approved of the casting

>>281350250
to be fair, japanese people don't take this shit as seriously as we do. it's just pantomimes to them

>>281348928 (OP)
We should not be seeing niggers at all.

>>281350198
Yes. That is the correct thing to be.

>>281350250
So? Oda is not an infalible god, he's a retard for approving it.

Ummmm what? I can't belive this fucking space. Didn't you fucking white males know that you're evil???!! We should celebrate this diversity, these women are beautiful strong queens. It's a mistake that the characters were drawn with pale skin in the first place 75% of the world is PoC get it through your heads you patriarchy white bigots.

>>281350250
Toriyama approved of Dragon Ball Evolution too, until it bombed, then his real thoughts came out

>>281350198
Not really despite being on this site

>>281350250
Oda is a pedophile.

>>281349677
netflix bot is malfunctioning, it is speaking call center english

>>281350250
I don't think he cares about it much and he shouldn't he should get his money

>>281349783
lel gib me dat piece

>>281350250
>Approve of this casting or you're racist.
Y-Yeah l-looks good bro haha

>>281350312
Ms monday and mr 1 should be black but nojiko? Why?

>>281348928 (OP)
The future is ugly, bros.

>>281348928 (OP)
WE WUZ

>>281350520
because she got big lips, and only black people have big lips, until you draw a black person with big lips, then you're racist for assuming black people have big lips

>>281350437
>Oda is a pedophile.
No he isn't. /a/ jannies are pedophiles though and they flood every One Piece thread with loli trash

>>281350250
Araki approved too the designs for the Jojo OVAs even when he did that face that people usually post the gif. "Author Approved" just means that the author cant go against what the company and investor say to him.

>>281349328
nta, but I think OP agree this casting is just plain WTF.

>>281348928 (OP)
It is a legitimate problem with trying to translate 2d anime/manga to 3d, the 2d characters are made to look perfect 10/10 which isn't really achievable irl

>>281348928 (OP)
Reminder: don't watch Netflixs adaptation, they're woke trash who hate fanservice and don't have the balls to sexualize female characters, they'll censor every Nami outfit, they'll censor every Robin outfit, they'll remove any and all lewd fanservice scenes, don't support woke trash or they'll keep making woke trash without female nudity nor female lewdness

>>281350955
tf is this picture

>>281350250
Oda approved the money

>>281351022
ragebait posted in every OP thread on /tv/ and /pol/

a/ is full of dumbass. and racist people.
This one actually the one what wrong.
Nico robin with full on make up visible. Netflix, this is not romance drama, but adventure-action

>>281348928 (OP)
No the issue is you’re thinking representationally instead of literally. Anime characters are hot for being drawings, not as representations of a 3dpd you make up in your head.

>>281348982
This is the stupidest thing I've ever heard, do you have brain damage?

>>281351158
it's not stupid at all. it's called "ma" and is a big part of what anime is and also why most characters look white, not because they are but because it's the best blank slate for interpretation. usopp literally has the same skin color as the rest in the anime but there are still enough markers for your brain to infer he probably isn't white

>>281351086
Kill yourself third world ape.

>>281351242
So you're saying that you can't interpret it however you want? God you're fucking retarded.

>>281351242
>Franky (American rep) is the darkest one and darker than the African
Oh no no non o

>>281350250
>oda
he died years ago

>>281348928 (OP)
I could deal with brown but do they have to brown and ugly?

Weren't they supposed to respect the actors nationality?
Why isnt Vivi Egyptian?

>>281351357
there is no reasoning with you, you are actually too racist

>>281349825
ew wt

Shanks just couldn't resist putting a baby in her

>>281351333
another dumbass and racist show its color. and mean. man, what the world we live in.

>>281351609
HAHAHAHAHA did they get these bots from re*dit? Do they its a compliment here?

>>281351086
Women should wear make up always, Vivi and Nojiko are bad and so is censored Alvida

>>281348928 (OP)
Makes sense to make Vivi dark skinned since she lives in a desert area

>>281351974
true heterosexuals are attracted to women in their natural state. you aren't attracted to women you're attracted to the makeup itself

>>281351974
you are just coomer. your brain full of cum. there is difference between make up like they are runaway model and 'supposed' pirates. especially in desert setting. but who cares, right, white is good, black is bad.

ITT: people were shocked when they realized that real people do not actually look like their anime waifus. this was the closest you could get as (shocking) blue hair doesn’t exist in real life.

>>281348928 (OP)
In retrospect these characters were always black coded

>>281350337
Agreed, racism is the new sin, only instead of sinning some type of spiritual loving being. You are sinning a bunch of pedo trillionaires.

>>281352036
tanned skin like pic related (actually egyptian) would make sense, not a dravidian

>>281352078
True hetero chads look women that look feminine and both make up and high heels make them look more feminine
>>281352116
Exactly who cares, a womans purpose in anything is to look pretty

>>281350250
all japanese are yes-men so not surprising.

>>281352249
Makeup doesn't make a woman look feminine. Being thin, having hips and a slender waist and long hair and big eyes are what makes a woman look feminine.

Makeup only makes women look trashy, they do it for their ego because they've been brainwashed by shitty made-up and slutted out beauty standards. At no point in history has a healthy woman with healthy skin looked worse than a woman wearing makeup.

>>281352333
Women have been wearing make up since ancient Egypt anon, Robins make up looks fine if anything Nami needs it too

>>281349226
>without a reason
character comes from the one piece world equivalent of arabia, so it makes sense. Maybe if Vivi was a sheltered kid she could've avoided it IF she was born white (which is already unlikely), but we know she has a tomboyish personality so she would've ended up like that anyway IMO
not that I agree with this, but there IS a perfectly logical reason

>>281348928 (OP)
A background character doesn't bother me, but isn't Vivi currently the most important character of the entire series? So every character related to her will be the same?

>>281352717
Apologies, the casting director didn't get that far in the series

>>281352717
well imu is already pitch black so

>>281352709
>character comes from the one piece world equivalent of arabia
It makes sense to cast an actor who looks completely different?

>>281352333
Makeup does, in fact, make a woman look more feminine. Even when the makeup is subtle, it's trying to make her eyes look bigger, her face rounder, and her nose smaller.

>>281352791
Do peole actually think this shitty show makes it past Enies Lobby (if this far)? The actors will be 40 by then

Maybe if they skip a lot of things like they already do but also entire arcs but then it's not even One Piece and everyone should admit it's retarded trash

If they skip Skypiea that's a death sentence

wanpiss fans deserve this for being the most obnoxious fanbase in media

>>281352952
we deserve an amazing show? why thank you, racist :)))

>>281352811
idk every dark skintone looks the same to me, you're all niggers

>>281353087
>racism
jannies, you know what to do :)

>>281352914
2023 East Blue
2025 Alabasta
2027 Skypea
2029 Water 7
2031 Thriller Bark
2033 Summit War
Timeskip!
And yes they will skip a shit ton of material but this seems like the logical plan.

>>281353081
you're welcome

>>281348982
Yes anon, this Nojika clearly was intended as a potential 5/10

>>281353087
Cope amerilard

>>281348928 (OP)
>hollywood abomination shit.
>this is how they are supposed to look because author aproved it.
And you are insane same as the others thinking that live action is good (it isn't).
Are they sex goddess? yes any female in one piece is a sex bomb with infinite appeal because most are girls between 10 to 18 years old so are in their peak (reduced to 10 because of boney).
>but muuhhh author aproval
you know how they do shit don't.
>either aproved those awfull characters or we will stop your manga from being published here.
>and we gave you lot of money so you can't refuse.
Which makes the author aprove shit in lot of cases in other is simply miscomunication or manipulating him to choose either "girl that passed audtion or man that passed audition" and seeing how oda hates troons he will choose girl.
Your shitty live action will never be how the characters are supposed to look in real life because you are a faggot!! you hate sexy girls hence you don't want to admit one piece girls are sex bombs that hasn't changed at all and will never change even if your shitty flop action shows something different.
>Nami : 17 years canonically after time skip so still on peak.
>Flo action : put an over 30 year old hag that doesn't has the appeal and will never show as much skin as nami showed.
KYS!!
>anime girls = sex bombs.
and japan knows it hence the live action AV of one piece is far more popular (because the girls look like the anime counterpart).

When you give L1 the function of staying pressed once you tap it you can make PW3 legit feel like Dark Souls on the hardest difficulty

>>281348928 (OP)
ARABasta

>>281353388
Good thing it's Alabasta and Arabasta is the retard translation

>>281353369
>piece girls are sex bombs
Maybe if their waistline made sense

>>281353430
Japs don't have the letter R

>>281352036
Desert area doesn't collerate Dark brown or Black.

also she is Indian. nothing fits

>>281348928 (OP)
>The creator approved of this casting
I really don't give a shit what the original creator thinks. That doesn't automatically change what I think.
I'm almost certain all of the people who defend Netflix's modern raceswaps wouldn't have defended M. Night's casting choices for The Last Airbender even if the original Avatar writers were to agree with them.

>>281348928 (OP)
nobody is going to admit this, not netflix and especially not shareholders, but hiring "beautiful" black women is infinitely cheaper than hiring mid white women. if this got out then woke might actually perish

>>281351022
>>281351068
>RagebaACK

>>281348928 (OP)
>the creator "approved"

>>281348928 (OP)
Really no way to interpret seeing the anime and casting them like that other than having contempt for the source material

>>281348928 (OP)
Why do we need 3-5 threads for this nigger adaption you fucking faggots?

>>281352709
anyway in anime she white and in adaptation, she should be white, imho

>>281348928 (OP)
Oda has always drawn all sorts of characters with the logic that even in real life, people look vastly different. It's just exaggerated to cartoonish levels in One Piece. In real life, we can't feasibly exaggerate people's sizes and bodies in the same way as it's done in One Piece. Instead the most logical way to represent the differences between people is to cast people of all sorts of ethnicities, genders etc. This alone is, in my opinion, enough of a reason, but it's also worth noting that the Live Action version isn't made to appeal to people who watch anime. Anyone interested in anime and One Piece have already watched the One Piece anime. This is for the "normies", and they see this sort of diversity as a good thing 99% of the time. You forget that /a/ exists in a bubble that isn't reflective of reality.

>>281351468
>White people don't care cause the OG character techincally isn't white.
>Jews are happy it isn't arab.
>Pajeets are happy playing as an arab.
>Arabs don't care.
>Oda cocksucker will continue to suck

>>281352717
This isn't going past season 4.

>>281348928 (OP)
but that's not Vivi that's Miss Wednesday

>>281353679
The Alabastans really should've been arabs

>>281352036
>tomboy like Princess Daisy
Aussie and Midwestern yanks are brown too?

>>281348928 (OP)
>meant to be fantasy
Everything!
>>281348685

>>281350437
>>281350690
His teacher did nothing wrong, redditroon

>>281354293
>fake SH
kek

>>281351357
Nahh, he's right

>>281349769
Nojiko is fine, and I don't really care about Vivi, but Indians are not Arabs, so you can't really call it authentic casting, unless you just mean anyone brown will do.

>>281354704
Egyptians aren’t arab either.

>>281348928 (OP)
>The creator approved of this casting
oda only approved the casting of the SH, everything else was without his involvement

>>281354886
No, the Vivi actress thanked Oda for personally chosing her.

>>281354704
>Nojiko is fine
Since when is tan black?

>>281351643
>vin diesel makino
my sides

>>281353430
Isn't it the other way around?

Oda greenlit it. Stay mad

>>281355829
Oda's a retard, kill yourself nigger lover.

>>281355875
Cope and seethe

>>281350360
He knows more about something he made than you do, dumbass

>>281355875
based
>>281355829
cringe

>>281355484
Don’t you know that ganguro Sicilians exist.

>>281348928 (OP)
It's funny that no one got mad about Usopp's race

>>281356395
Cope fag

>>281356395
Can you say that again? Can't hear you over all that mad.

>>281356451
He's already black, kinda

>>281356507
Can't hear you over the smoke detector beeps.

>>281356451
Nobody actually cares about the live action.

>>281356523
Retard

>>281356523
Huh?

>>281356588
Blacks don't change the batteries of smoke detectors

>>281356569
>>281356588
It's the kind of thing you need a 3 digit iq to understand, kind of a high hurdle for apes isn't it.

>>281356497
>>281355944

>>281356682
I know what that mean i just think that you are a retard

>>281356745
means*
I*
retard.*

>>281348928 (OP)
Vibrant hair color usually puts women in weave territory post 2015

>>281351643
This one was the worst honestly because she is actually supposed to be cute and she's not cute instead. Vivi's black actress is still cute in the photos.

>>281356971
Stop calling this indian bitch black

>>281356971
She's indian

>>281351643
Soon diesel engine powered hydrogen.

anyone who says "fuck racists" probably has never met Indians at their workplace

>picking a jeet to play the hottest girl in one piece

Actually shameful

>>281351086
>all that makeup
WHORE

>>281348928 (OP)
She'll look better with her hair down. The picture we saw was her playing the part of villain with her hair up.

>>281350411
Toriayama said his input during the development of that film was ultimately ignored though. Meanwhile Oda himself had has vetted and approved every single casting choice

>>281350437

im not racist but this is tiresome

>>281357940
Fag

>>281350690
Kys trannyfag

>>281348928 (OP)
MOOOOOOOOOOODS!!!!

WHY IS THIS SHIT ON /A? TRANNY NETFLIX SHOULD BE ON /TV FOR FUCK'S SAKE YOU FAGGOTS!!

>>281358190
Nami pov

>>281348928 (OP)
3DPD will never be as beautiful so you can cast any female, she'll never reach the necessary level.

>>281353220
I know there are hot black women out there. Why cast the ugliest gorillanigger imaginable?

>>281358388
Fag

1 piss is shit

>>281359401
Retard

>>281348928 (OP)
I have less of a problem with Vivi being Indian. Indian Arab whatever, none gives a shit.
The problem I have is them reusing some buggy carnival in loguetown. It’s kinda cheap, to do it a second time try something else you cheap fucks with no creativity.

I don't care about one piece but seeing this franchise get infested with browns is kino, keep it up and rape the franchise some more so I can laugh. I expect the next season to be 90% brown or I will be very dissapointed. Oda is based for this. Make it as woke as possible please.

>>281348928 (OP)
DEI casting.

>>281348928 (OP)
what's the point of the black woman? the hair isn't even black and it's straight, it's not even respecful towards blacks

>>281360586
Kys trannyfag

>>281360766
There should be legit unironic tranny characters added to One Piece too just to make (You) seethe.

Wouldn't Vivi look more like this?

Princess of Morocco

>>281361421
Kys mongrel

>>281361421
Kiku

>>281348928 (OP)
theres no way Oda approved this, I refuse to think someone with that much artistic integrity would sign off unless they just didnt let him on set

>>281352709
The middle east isn't vantablack

>>281356180
He doesn't seem to recognize shit when he sees it

>>281353087
Indian hands typed this

>>281348928 (OP)
Friendly reminder that the most common reason these faggots give is that it doesn't matter. And the ultimate counter to that flawed argument is that if it doesn't matter there was no reason to change it in the first place.

>>281361678
Everyone has a price, there is no artist that won't sell out given the right motivation. It doesn't always have to be money, they could have threatened him in many ways. Or the simpler explanation is that he has just fallen for the same brainwashing as the west and has accepted guilt for not worshiping africa.

There are like a billion characters in OP piece, are you really gonna blow a gasket any time somebody who is irrelevant for 98% of the manga looks browner?

>>281348928 (OP)
You picked out such an unflattering picture of the actress

>>281362041
She's beautiful, way more than Nami clone Vivi.

>>281362038
Why do they need to be race swapped?

>>281350250
As credible as based on true story spewed by Hollywood.

>>281362091
Fag

>>281362105
What race was Vivi?

>>281362233
Since you are dodging the question your concession has been accepted and filed in the proper folder. Here is your parting (You) don't spend it all in one place.

>>281362041
That's a considerable amount of makeup, and not in character.
You picked the best you could find, and OP picked ones that were relevant.

>>281348928 (OP)
At this point I'm just grateful they didn't raceswap Nami. And they only didn't do it because Oda explicitly said what he intended all the mains cast ethnicities to be in his manga.

>>281348928 (OP)
this is a drawing Oda did of Luffy

As if Jewish producers would get an Arab girl to be in their show. lmao

>>281350250
Source

>>281362917
None, I made it up as a coping mechanism.

>>281362702
yeah thats the only reason why Vivi is a poo because Oda didn't want an Israeli actress playing an Arab princess.

>>281348928 (OP)
>The creator approved of this casting
yeah here's how it went

>oh herro wat u want
>take this bag of cash and let us do whatever
>verrry goodu arigato

>>281348928 (OP)
My problem isn't that they're black my problem is that they're ugly.

>>281352036
Vivi is like Mediterranean/North African.

>>281352325
gf

>>281363615
my problem is that they are black though

>>281363615
>>281363969

>>281350825
its easy not to be black

>>281355829
Oda probably just said "yeah yeah whatever" to the executives

>>281364103
He probably said "Fuck those chuds let's make her black."

>>281354956
i can personally thank stan lee or mcfarlane or kishimoto for picking me for a role in an hypotetical movie that doesn't mean it happened
what would be easier anon, deal with the deserved backlash and admit the character was raceswapped because of the whim of a producer? or lie and hide behind the authors supposed decision?
you are not a toddler

After Berserk 2016 I stopped believing that artists give a shit about their creations. Nips don't have any special honor, it's all just a machine to churn out profits or pass the time until death.

>>281348928 (OP)
>>>/tv/
Eat shit jannies

If Vivi was supposed to be a baboon, why was she whitening the Manga and anime?

Why aren't here negros in the source material? Hm....

>>281349677
good morning saar

>>281364444
and then being a nigger like you became normal and beautiful and everyone clapped, right? in your dreams leshawn

>>281349677
Thanks for reminding me about the vampire with the funny looking tits show.

>>281362233
human race

>>281361421
there's an entire kingdom of them. they are one of the greatest allies of luffy's father

>>281357173
I've worked with people from just about every corner of the globe and they were all just people

>>281364889
>shit that never happened

>>281364809
Those aren't trannys those are cross dressers, it's a completely different thing.

>i saw a people once and they did things so fuck borders and laws and shieeeeeeetttt one race the human race oh but you can't have a white black panther sorry chud race swapping only goes one way

>>281364955
inazuma literally transes gender on a whim almost as much as ivankov

>>281348928 (OP)
I hate netflix

>>281364923
maybe if you spent more time hauling cargo and less time bitching about your coworkers geographic origins you'd have gotten along better and gotten invited to the afterwork piss ups

>>281364726
Your lack of self-awareness is both hilarious and concerning.

>>281348928 (OP)
Approved of the casting from which choices provided from the casting directors???? Pic related.

>>281364483
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=idHRDLhj91Y

>>281363615
It's very rare to find an attractive black woman to be fair. Even black men don't want them.

>>281365092
This says more about you than me. I have a better job than that, bongshit.

>>281358388
Truth

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pWtR2CXFDMs

After leaving Cimmeria and reaching the pictish wilderness, the mighty cimmerian barbarian Luffy has saved Rebecca from a bunch of savage Picts. The warrior princess from Zingara in the south is now travelling with him. They must escape the dangerous jungles and survive against the terrible Pictish barbarians and ferocious saurians of the swamp. Our heroes's destination are the ports of Zingara to find a boat and travel into Barachan islands, starting a pirate life and find the mysterious treasure of a dead Barachean pirate called Goldo Rogero.

>>281365388
if that were true you'd have better things to do than shitpost on 4chan

The pic on the bottom right looks like a man wearing a wig. I wonder if Netflix doesn't just hire the cheapest actors they can find.

>>281365482
Shows what you know about decent jobs, lol.
Don't @ me with any further euro-peasant slang.

>>281365337
Here’s the casting directors.

>>281354256
Not even getting a season 2.

>>281365019
>white black panther

You had a lot of those.

>>281348928 (OP)
Shieet we wuz anime gurlz y'all

>>281348928 (OP)
My nigger fatigue is at an all time high
Kill all shitskins niggers and Jews
Dragon ball won
One piece forever lost
Total nigger death
Total Jew death
Total Indian death
Anyone who defends this ugly shit deserves to die
/a/ has been taken over by sjw troons
>>281365579
Every single time
Ugly foid Jews

>>281365579
>>281365850
Reform Judaism strikes again!

>>281365541
you've clearly never done an honest day's work in your life, nor have any fruitful endeavors that you invest your wages into. You're just here mucking about in shit paddock like a rusty drongo with the rest of us

>>281348928 (OP)
You realize the mangaka is a commie right? If he thought it would trigger you he would have made more characters black.

>normalfag defending niggers on 4chan
some people really get out of line if you let them huh?...

>>281366045
Stfu tranny

>>281353915
she's still got the cleavage, just looks like they're hiding her loose skin from the weight loss

>>281357991
and yet he said people should go watch the movie and enjoy it(just to look at it as an alternative interpretation)
the point is the creators lie(whether out of their own accord or because they were pressured by their publisher) to make more money. Most mangaka have no integrity for their work(at least a few years into the career), they just do it to earn money

>first they came for the red hairs
>and I said nothing
>next they came for the blue hairs
>....

What's everyone upset about? If they were picked despite looking nothing like their roles whatsoever, that means their acting is just that good. Season 1 was already fantastic, seaons 2 is going to be amazing!

>>281348928 (OP)
UGLY
UGLY
UGLY

>>281348928 (OP)
NIGGER
NIGGER
NIGGER

Jack Black as Jagaur D. Saul

>>281348928 (OP) >>281350250
with the world's economy in the shitter, nobody sane is going to turn down a massive pile of shitflix cash no matter how fucking hilariously awful the adaptation targeting a side-market at best (west is practically irrelevant in terms of anime/manga marketshare) is cast/handled

no shit oda "approved" the casting; I doubt he even looked at the paperwork before signing off on it

>>281368790
side character #26 does not have perfect acting skills?!! No, we have to search far and wide to find the best actress for this 5 minute role, even if she looks like a man!

>>281368947
Resemblance to the character is clearly not a priority whatsoever, so why would that matter?

>>281368978
>an adaption based on a VISUAL medium does not need resembles to the characters aesthetics
just admit you want to fuck black trannies and we can start to have a honest discussion

>>281348928 (OP)
That Nojiko is especially egregious. Why do they think blue wigs on black people looks good

>>281369172
Sarcasm, anon

>>281366218
Wheres her tummy?

>anime gives robin tanned skin, everyone loves it
>forces toei to whitewash her
>vivi is one of the palest characters in the series
>gets an hindu to play her
at this point he's just doing it to piss us off