← Home ← Back to /a/

Thread 281418903

39 posts 18 images /a/
Anonymous No.281418903 [Report] >>281418913 >>281419471 >>281419919 >>281420288 >>281420338 >>281420809 >>281421136 >>281422879 >>281423587 >>281423649 >>281425602 >>281426991 >>281429834 >>281431617 >>281433281 >>281435996
Why do isekai protagonists never have children in their previous lives?
Anonymous No.281418913 [Report] >>281423467 >>281428637 >>281435868
>>281418903 (OP)
because that makes it sad that they left their children behind without a parent
Anonymous No.281419471 [Report] >>281420288 >>281435476
>>281418903 (OP)
This guy had a daughter,
Anonymous No.281419720 [Report]
That's the case for the guy in that "I got kicked out of the Hero's party so I decided to fuck all of their moms" story.
He had a wife and at least one kid, so when he reincarnated he was still stuck with the mindset of a father and couldn't see any of his peers as romantic options.
Anonymous No.281419919 [Report]
>>281418903 (OP)
Because usually their previous life was shitty and lonely enough to not want to go back.
Anonymous No.281420288 [Report] >>281422377 >>281426431
>>281418903 (OP)
Makes it harder to self-insert

>>281419471
Only legally speaking. Ep 1 basically told you upfront the child didn't share his blood
Anonymous No.281420338 [Report]
>>281418903 (OP)
The middle aged guy who became a villainess does. She even helps him out across worlds.
Anonymous No.281420692 [Report] >>281420703
This guy did
Anonymous No.281420703 [Report]
>>281420692
He got isekai'd twice
Anonymous No.281420734 [Report] >>281420863
Moral law. If the MC had children then they'd be required to constantly worry about getting back to his world and rejoin his family. He musn't have any attachments in order to avoid having to constantly satisfy JP moral law in fiction.
Anonymous No.281420809 [Report]
>>281418903 (OP)
They were hikineets that dropped out of society.
Anonymous No.281420863 [Report]
>>281420734
So you're saying that in order to get isekaid to meet my waifu, I mustn't have any children here? Easy enough I guess
Anonymous No.281421136 [Report]
>>281418903 (OP)
It would be interesting if they were a deadbeat dad like that guy from the Squid Game.
Anonymous No.281422377 [Report] >>281423713 >>281436245
>>281420288
>rich douchebag biodad went to jail
>cuck NBR dad died
>cheating whore was left with nothing
That poor kid
Anonymous No.281422879 [Report]
>>281418903 (OP)
Because they're reincarnations
Anonymous No.281423467 [Report]
>>281418913
yeah its sad
Anonymous No.281423587 [Report]
>>281418903 (OP)
If you have clear attachments then you're kinda at least tokenly obliged to occasionally say "I have to find a way back" even if you don't want to write such a story.
Anonymous No.281423649 [Report] >>281426962
>>281418903 (OP)
Watch more anime?
Anonymous No.281423713 [Report] >>281424064
>>281422377
Pretty much. Mom hit the wall and is a deadbeat who tells her daughter to be a prostitute because she doesn't want to get a job.
Anonymous No.281424064 [Report]
>>281423713
I'm so glad womens rights get repelled this decade.
Anonymous No.281425602 [Report]
>>281418903 (OP)
virgins
Anonymous No.281426431 [Report] >>281428037
>>281420288
>Only legally speaking. Ep 1 basically told you upfront the child didn't share his blood
That's not confirmed. It would be within the guide's MO to be lazy and just fake DNA/blood test results to create a false impression rather than going to the trouble of actually "implementing" it since for him the subjective reaction is all that matters and if his targets are despairing about a fake situation that's not even true, that might actually be even more "TASTY!" for him.
Anonymous No.281426638 [Report]
we literally just had one last season
Akuyaku Reijou Tensei Ojisan, MC (an old-school otaku) even gets guided by his otoge playing daughter
Anonymous No.281426962 [Report]
>>281423649
5 Gulgs?! Sasuga Grace sama!
Anonymous No.281426991 [Report]
>>281418903 (OP)
kill yourself willful-retard
Anonymous No.281428037 [Report] >>281428923
>>281426431
When has the guide been depicted as lazy? That's your headcanon based off the time where he had so little power it was all he can do.
Anonymous No.281428637 [Report]
>>281418913
My thought when I started watching Akuyaku Reijou Tensei Oji-san.
Anonymous No.281428923 [Report] >>281428986
>>281428037
No, he instinctively went for the data-manipulation solution. The power-limitation was just about how he implements it (rather than making up Liam's data as he planned, he had to swap his with someone else's). The fact that he tried to do his "usual routine" without even realizing that he could no longer do it is proof that it's his usual MO.
He couldn't directly influence the ex-wife's actions either because she was a "misery meal" for the guide like Liam is, so he could not directly influence who she'd actually have the child with in the end and we don't know at what point he even began targeting each of them. The guide doesn't care whose child it is. He cares that Liam feels misery from being cucked and betrayed (making the ex-wife believe it's not Liam's child makes it easier for her to rationalize siding with who she thinks is the actual father). Also fooling the few people involved while the truth is that Liam is still the actual father is easier to maintain than the other way around where he'd have to fool everyone else into believing that he is the girl's father by blood and thus the girl's legal guardian and must thus keep paying her amenities. Fooling 3 or so people is easier than fooling 10+ people.
Anonymous No.281428986 [Report] >>281429500
>>281428923
Why can't we just go occams razor and the cheating wife got impregnated by chad?
Anonymous No.281429500 [Report]
>>281428986
Because the whole damn story is about Liam applying Occam's Razor toward the guide's and his teacher's actions while the schizo "mental gymnastics" versions are actually the truth. I mean just listen to this:
>At the end of Liam's naturally miserable life stemming from his own retarded, naive and too good-willed choices in life, a mysterious friendly guide appears and offers him reincarnation in another world and in this other world his life is much greater, avoiding his past life's mistakes, getting helped by the guide, learning the ultimate flash-style from his respected teacher that truly mows down any foes in his way. The guide and his teacher have both obviously always been good to him.
VS
>the guide was actually an evil "misery emotions-eating"-being manipulating everyone behind the scenes all along and he only appeared helpful to deceive Liam on earth, yet even though he wants Liam to hate him in his second life, Liam still thinks of him as being helpful because Liam's dead pet dog returned as a sort of guardian angel who secretly behind the scenes manipulates events even further to make it seem to Liam like the guide's actions were actually all good because the guide's greatest weakness is positive emotions directed towards him, especially from those he designated as his "long term meals", so the guide who was none the wiser about the pet dog has been attempting to bring fourth misery and an eventual death to Liam but keeps failing despite his miraculous supernatural powers. Also Liam's teacher is actually a fraud who just happened to be, by sheer coincidence and unknowingly to the teacher himself, extremely talented at training super genius sword fighters to master a new, completely unprecedented ultimate sword-style without being able to do any of it himself and also manages to somehow deceive all of his students without being discovered by any of them ever.
Which one sounds more like "being contrived schizo mental gymnastics" to you?
Anonymous No.281429834 [Report]
>>281418903 (OP)
>Why do isekai protagonists never [X]?
Because
GENTLEMEN
isekai... bad and nippon bad.
MCs without child in previous life bad, staying in isekai bad, not bonding with otherworlders good, returning to earth while leaving behind all powers gained good, having an ending that's no different from a "everything was just a dream" ending good.
upvote me
Anonymous No.281430365 [Report]
>expecting people to have children in modern day Japan
Anonymous No.281431617 [Report]
>>281418903 (OP)
authors are hacks what else is new
Anonymous No.281433281 [Report]
>>281418903 (OP)
Can't self insert otherwise
Anonymous No.281435476 [Report]
>>281419471
he was a good father
Anonymous No.281435868 [Report] >>281436621
>>281418913
Isn't it sad that they're leaving their own parents behind, anyway?
No parent should have to bury their son/daughter. Also bad if they just disappear one day from being summoned.
Like if I got isekai'd I wouldn't be able to focus on the isekai stuff because I'd be worried about what my family must be going through.
Anonymous No.281435996 [Report]
>>281418903 (OP)
because the author wouldn't know what to do with such characters, and it doesn't usually feel right to discard the MC's children for plot purposes unlike parents or siblings
Anonymous No.281436245 [Report]
>>281422377
It's fine. She gets Neverending Story'd to the MCs universe for a bit and turns her life around.
Anonymous No.281436621 [Report]
>>281435868
I don't think shut-in shitsekai authors give a single shit about their parents.