Thread 281502087

Is One Piece the peak of the adventure genre in all of anime?

In anime, certainly not. Future Boy Conan, Made in Abyss, etc

In manga, obviously.

>>281502087 (OP)
>OMG SHONESLOP DA PEAK!
watch more anime dumb tourist

I only find adventure stories interesting in well built worlds. In settings where the author is just making shit up as they go it all feels boring and pointless.

>>281502087 (OP)
Yes and no? It certainly the most successful and certainly among the best adventure shonen, but as far as adventures go, Dungeon Meshi, Made in Abyss, Golden Kamui are clearly better.
OP also suffers of terrible quality inconsistencies between arcs and chapters

>>281502087 (OP)
>adventure
>it's just rescuing islands from tyrants on repeat and the crew barely interacting

>>281502223
Literally has the greatest adventure set-pieces in fiction, contrarian.

>>281502087 (OP)
pre timeskip maybe, after it's not even about adventure

>>281502236
>greatest adventure set-pieces in fiction

>same boring island...but in the sky....and also rescue it from evil tyrant

>>281502299
>Chopper
Here's one from his arc. We could literally do this all day. Because the Adventure genre (in Manga) peaked with One Piece.

>>281502309
>Here's one from his arc
it's....a castle... what about it? How is castle = greatest adventure?

>>281502087 (OP)
yeah

>>281502087 (OP)
Here come Togashisexuals

>>281502087 (OP)
No.

>>281502356
>NOOO THAT DOESN'T COUNT

>>281502500
So you can't explain how a castle is a greatest adventure?

If someone showed to me a cardboard box and called it "greatest adventure" I would also question them.

>>281502087 (OP)
Nah, it's a battle show with some adventure flavor added. No, being more adventure-focused than Naruto or JJK isn't a claim to fame, btw. Even out of ongoing battle shonen, Frieren has more actual adventure.

>>281502820
There's nothing interesting about any of the places they go to in Frieren.

>>281502858
>There's nothing interesting about any of the places they go to in Frieren.
neither in one piece

"it's Japan but NOT!"
"it's Spain but NOT!"
"It's average candy island but NOT!"
"it's Atlantis but NOT!"

>>281502820
Frieren is even more dull, kek.

>>281502087 (OP)
https://youtu.be/ZwJZa9mrwBw?si=kep7Yxu5wPjqLKYv

I'd say Mushoku Tensei is the most proper fantasy adventure anime I've seen up to date, its the one that truly captured the vibe of adventure. And it also had the best-looking visuals

>>281503351
>I've watched two anime

>>281502087 (OP)
That's HxH

>>281502211
Agreed, in terms aof adventure One Piece fucked up post ts.

>>>/tv/213729178

one piece thread on /tv/ need more people to shit it up

>>281502236
goddamn kino

>>281502186
>In manga, obviously.
lol fucking no, OP's cultural relevance is self contained, it hasn't inspired as many other series as it s relevance might give you the impression.

>>281502880
>being this dishonest
>spain
actually a toyland filled with toy people
>food island
absolutely a crazy place to go with entire living food forests
>atlantis
oh sorry atlantis isnt fun for you
>zombie dark castle island
>sky island
ill grant you Wano is nothing special.
>future island
all sorts of weird robot shit here
>elfbaf
entire island is on giant god tree, has literal hell and heaven

>>281504559
I dunno why inspiring other series is used like it's the ultimate barometer of relevance. One Piece would be difficult to imitate, Oda is a bit idiosyncratic.

>>281502437
>>281503492
HxH is not adventure. The DC arc could be on its own an Adventure arc but generally HxH is more of a psychological thriller than anything else.

>>281502186
>Future Boy Conan
Based. Also, the first Dragon Ball and Tekken Chinmi are great.

I think adventure anime and manga are the best early on when the author just pulls random insane locations out of his ass, and you never know what's gonna come next.
Pretty much as soon as the world is "explained" through some way of filling up as many plot holes as possible with logic, the show loses like 50% of its appeal.

>>281507050
I agree. Still, i think the worst part is when the MC just stops interacting with nature as a puzzle, and it becomes just routine. In One Piece's case, when they had to collect materials or solve the way to navigate was kino in comparison to just travel from A to B to fight with the local cartels.