← Home ← Back to /a/

Thread 281508985

22 posts 14 images /a/
Anonymous No.281508985 >>281509050 >>281510793 >>281510895 >>281514350
>people still consider FMA to be the best shonen ever
Jesus fucking christ
Anonymous No.281509037
Hello funnyschizo. You in post nut clarity after fapping to shota porn again?
Anonymous No.281509050 >>281509103 >>281509136 >>281509510 >>281512396
>>281508985 (OP)
Ok? Do you have an alternative?
Anonymous No.281509103 >>281509136
>>281509050
Anonymous No.281509136 >>281509201
>>281509103
How about posting a show who's only perfect arc isn't just a remix of Dragonball's greatest hits?

>>281509050
>Ok? Do you have an alternative?
Only one I can think of is Eureka 7.
Anonymous No.281509201
>>281509136
Yorkshin isn't like DB at all
Anonymous No.281509311
>best shonen ever
Not much of an achievement.
Anonymous No.281509510 >>281509981 >>281511202 >>281511850
>>281509050
Most shonen sucks but I miss back when anime used to have actual deep themes in them, brotherhood and fairy tail were the beginning of the end when the medium became slop
Anonymous No.281509981
>>281509510
FMA has very deep themes relating to empathy and interconnectedness, antiracism, antifascism and a distinct critique of the postwar world created through the modeling of a German state thatโ€™s ultimately created to enable the biggest genocide for profit scheme.
Anonymous No.281510793 >>281511326
>>281508985 (OP)
>People still condider making this idiotic joke on /a/ is worth killing a thread
Faggots like OP are the reason I kept getting behind the Kinnikuman Nisei storytime threads until I just gave up.
Anonymous No.281510895 >>281511326 >>281511372
>>281508985 (OP)
Can a series that primarily deals with political drama, domestic terrorism, and legal ramifications of war crime really be considered a shounen. No 12-year-old is gonna understand or care about any of that.
Anonymous No.281511202
>>281509510
fma thinks he on the team lmfao
Anonymous No.281511326 >>281512185
>>281510793
>idiotic joke
Only FMAtard malfags think anyone who dislikes their shit series is doing a "joke". The real joke is all the fags who spent a decade+ botting MAL, anilist, etc for FMAB to be on top despite the fact that it is generic trash
>>281510895
It ends with a literal power of friendship kumbaya ending lmao, none of those themes matter when the conclusion is still babyshit
Anonymous No.281511372
>>281510895
Part of the reason FMA is so powerful is that it is an introduction to those sorts of topics for teenagers, as many of the best shounen are
Anonymous No.281511850
>>281509510
I think it's less about deep themes and more about ambitiousness of the works. I'm not going to say everything was ambitious in the good old days or whatever, but the constant LN and even WN adaptation barrel scraping pollutes the ambitiousness of modern works since the underlying framework can't really be fixed.
These stories are often very grand in scope with hundreds (sometimes thousands) of chapters, but thematically they say very little. Something that really stuck out to me was when I watched Cautious Hero; I could see the underlying efforts of the studio staff, from the fun visual gags in the animation to the framing of events, but it's like the whole team was shackled by the writing in the original work.
Parasyte is on the other hand a fantastic adaptation of the source material, both the manga and anime stand in their own right. Because the studio had an excellent skeleton to draw from they were capable of creating their own slightly different take on it that was (in my opinion) equally as good.
This doesn't touch on the fact that proportionally less original anime is made now too which exuberates the issue. All in all it's primarily a symptom of the harder economic times in Japan, where now the main groups who field money for anime are publishers that are in need of an advertisement for their media that actually makes money, so consequently even more anime than before is an advertisement for other media (which of course was a thing in the past as well, just proportionally less so).
Anonymous No.281512185 >>281512371 >>281516968
>>281511326
It ends with Ed exemplifying a major theme in the story, sacrifice. The shonen fight was just fluff
Anonymous No.281512371 >>281516968
>>281512185
It does โ€œpower of friendshipโ€ as well because the entire series has been building up the themes of bonds and community. Even the dynamic between Father and Hohenheim spells out the same thing with Hohenheim taking the path of forging a relationship with all the people in his stone in order to counter Father whose isolation is so extreme that he starts chopping off his own emotions. The tag team bonanza against Father highlights different people that the brothers have impacted through their journey so itโ€™s not really fluff, itโ€™s just as much part of the thematic conclusion as the notions of sacrifice/exchange.
Anonymous No.281512396
>>281509050
Uhh, obviously?
Anonymous No.281513722
bump
Anonymous No.281514350
>>281508985 (OP)
And not a single thing you do will ever change that.
Anonymous No.281516315
Its good
Anonymous No.281516968
>>281512185
>>281512371
>bonds and community
Aka generic shonen shit. Also even if those themes were "good" doesn't matter if the execution is horrible